Belfour is a lock. The fourth best goaltender of the strongest era ever for goaltenders. Mixed playoff resume early in his career, but he more than made up for it in the later half. Has a good chance at first ballot, but it depends on the competition. Lock, possible first ballot.
Niedermayer is borderline for me, but will probably get in because voters will remember the end of his career, when he racked up all star bids against relatively weak competition. A Conn Smythe in 2007 and a Smythe-worthy post season in 2003. He was great in the 1995 finals, but overall, wasn't one of the top 3 postseason performers on that team (Lemieux, Stevens, Brodeur). Regardless of weak competition, however, he would be a lock if he played his whole career like he has since 2003. He spent most of the first decade of his career floating, which is why he's borderline for me. I wouldn't induct him on the first ballot. I agree with the poster who said that one more elite season, or a few more very good ones will make him a lock to at least get in. Better than 50% chance.
Blake is kind of the reverse of Niedermayer - looked like he was HOF-bound early in his career, only to fade fast towards the end. He definitely gets "fame" points for the buttchecks he was famous for early in his career. Right now, he's even with Niedermayer, but Niedermayer has a much better chance of adding to his resume. Could go either way.
Recchi is the only forward on the list with a chance to get in anytime soon. He's the type of player that you don't think of as a HOFer, but looking back... it wouldn't be a travesty if he got in. Definitely not first ballot, however. Could go either way.
Andreychuck will not get in while those who actually saw him play are on the committee. Never an elite player in the league for even a season. There's a small chance, that in the distant future, the committee will look at his goal-scoring stats, which are very impressive. Not any time soon; probably never.
Turgeon is notoriously soft. Better peak than Andreychuk, but still never elite. His career numbers are good, but nothing stands out like Andreychuk's goal total. Never.
Mogilny had two elite regular seasons, and one very good one. He spent most of the rest of his career floating and was never very good in the playoffs. Never.