Grading the game 25.09.2014

[HABsurde]

Note the players out of 10

Price
Budaj

Subban
Emelin
Beaulieu
Weaver
Pateryn
Drewiske

Parenteau
Pacioretty
Desharnais
Galchenyuk
Gallagher
Scherback
Maholtra
Prust
Bournival
Moen
Hudon
Thomas

Click to read more...

 

[Fazkovsky]

thomas 8, subban 9, pac 8, beaulieu 7.5, weaver 7.5 all of the others player 6 to 7. Weaver is way better then Gorges in my books but problem is that he is old.

 

[CupInSIX]

Anthem singer 8/10 sorry but she held the Canada too long and it was off key

 

[MaxChart]

Note the players out of 10

Price 7.5
Budaj 9

Subban 8.5
Emelin 7.5
Beaulieu 7.5
Weaver 8
Pateryn 7.5
Drewiske 8

Parenteau 6.5
Pacioretty 7.5
Desharnais 8
Galchenyuk 7.5
Gallagher 7
Scherback 6.5
Maholtra 7
Prust 7
Bournival 7.5
Moen 6.5
Hudon 7.5
Thomas 8.5

Everybody played pretty well.

 

[CheldishGamibno]

Price - 7
Budaj - 8.5

Subban - 8.5
Emelin - 7
Beaulieu - 8
Weaver - 7.5
Pateryn - 7
Drewiske - 6.5

Parenteau - 6.5
Pacioretty - 8
Desharnais - 7.5
Galchenyuk - 8
Gallagher - 6.5
Sherback - 6.5
Maholtra - 7
Prust - 7
Bournival - 7
Moen - 7
Hudon - 6.5
Thomas - 8

 

[vokiel]

Price: 7.0
Budaj: 8.0

Subban: 8.0
Emelin: 7.5
Beaulieu: 8.5
Weaver: 7.5
Pateryn: 6.5
Drewiski: 7.0

Desharnais: 4.5
Pacioretty: 7.5
Parenteau: 7.0
Galchenyuk: 9.0
Gallagher: 5.5
Scherbak: 6.5
Hudon: 6.5
Bournival: 8.0
Thomas: 8.5
Malhotra: 7.5
Prust: 8.0
Moen: 7.0

 

[Shutdown]

Anthem singer 8/10 sorry but she held the Canada too long and it was off key

But she looked good doing it.
9/10.

 

[calder candidate]

But she looked good doing it.
9/10.

Definately better than Charles Prévost Linton,
I was very desapointed with the PAP, 1 game ins'tthe end of the world but I expect more, there seem like the was a big build up with Roy comment, him wanting to play both game...

Today game wasn't great lot of fumbling and broken plays, but it was faster and more physical thanthe first game.

Price: 7.5 not bad nothing speacial
Budaj: 8.5 made some great save, but was also lucky

Subban: 8.0
Emelin: 7.0
Beaulieu: 7.5
Weaver: 7.5
Pateryn: 7.0
Drewiski: 7.5

Desharnais: 6.5
Pacioretty: 8.0
Parenteau: 6.5 vs. is old team I was expecting more...
Galchenyuk: 8.0 great goal, seem faster but lot of indidual play from him
Gallagher: 6.5
Scherbak: 6.5
Hudon: 6.5
Bournival: 8.0
Thomas: 8.0
Malhotra: 7.0
Prust: 7.5
Moen: 7.0

 

[zzoo]

It feels great to see Beaulieu skate, so smooth. He has a great offensive hockey sense too. He looks like Subban when he started with Habs, doing some mistakes, but looks so promising.

 

[Alexdaman]

Price: 7.5 (had to play the hardest portion of the game, was solid but looked a little nervous)
Budaj: 8.0 (Buds is in my opinion the only choice for a 2nd the habs have and he showed why)

Subban: 9.5 (Played solid D and looked presidential on the forecheck)
Emelin: 6.5 (Seemed to wander around the ice and looked out of balance)
Beaulieu: 8.0 (Maybe the most talented passer on the blue line)
Weaver: 8.0 (A clear cut upgrade over Gorges)
Pateryn: 6.5 (Looked nervous, but did a passable job)
Drewiski: 6.0 (Clearly the player with the least to offer at NHL caliber)

Desharnais: 7.5 (Good passes which lead to a some decent chances)
Pacioretty: 8.0 (That snipe may lead him to a 40 goal season)
Parenteau: 6.5 (Didn't look too sharp in the D end, but battled hard on the boards)
Galchenyuk: 9.0 (This night looked like it was Galchenyuk beginning of his breakout year)
Gallagher: 6.5 (Played his game but needed some polishing)
Scherbak: 6.5 (Hopefully he doesn't get cut before he takes enough NHL baggage home)
Hudon: 6.5 (Will have to wait for a verdict)
Bournival: 7.5 (Good energy from the energy kid)
Thomas: 8.5 (Incredible speed tonight again and hopefully he carries that energy in Hamilton
Malhotra: 6.5 (faceoff man and adds more credibility to the 4th line)
Prust: 5.5 (Worst forward by far, looked out of pace)
Moen: 6.0 (Moen usual night)

 

[HABsurde]

Price: 7.0
Budaj: 8.0

Subban: 8.0
Emelin: 7.5
Beaulieu: 8.5
Weaver: 7.5
Pateryn: 6.5
Drewiski: 7.0

Desharnais: 4.5
Pacioretty: 7.5
Parenteau: 7.0
Galchenyuk: 9.0
Gallagher: 5.5
Scherbak: 6.5
Hudon: 6.5
Bournival: 8.0
Thomas: 8.5
Malhotra: 7.5
Prust: 8.0
Moen: 7.0

4.5 to Desharnais??? seriously?

 

[Alexdaman]

4.5 to Desharnais??? seriously?

 

[TRG]

4.5 to Desharnais??? seriously?

He was probably trying to write Desharnais' height.

 

[vokiel]

4.5 to Desharnais??? seriously?

Yes he was horrible. H O R R I B L E. As in fumbled the puck as much as AHLer Sorkin on Tuesday.

And I'm usually a Desharnais fan.

 

[Monctonscout]

Price: 7.5 (had to play the hardest portion of the game, was solid but looked a little nervous)
Budaj: 8.0 (Buds is in my opinion the only choice for a 2nd the habs have and he showed why)

Subban: 9.5 (Played solid D and looked presidential on the forecheck)
Emelin: 6.5 (Seemed to wander around the ice and looked out of balance)
Beaulieu: 8.0 (Maybe the most talented passer on the blue line)
Weaver: 8.0 (A clear cut upgrade over Gorges)
Pateryn: 6.5 (Looked nervous, but did a passable job)
Drewiski: 6.0 (Clearly the player with the least to offer at NHL caliber)

Desharnais: 7.5 (Good passes which lead to a some decent chances)
Pacioretty: 8.0 (That snipe may lead him to a 40 goal season)
Parenteau: 6.5 (Didn't look too sharp in the D end, but battled hard on the boards)
Galchenyuk: 9.0 (This night looked like it was Galchenyuk beginning of his breakout year)
Gallagher: 6.5 (Played his game but needed some polishing)
Scherbak: 6.5 (Hopefully he doesn't get cut before he takes enough NHL baggage home)
Hudon: 6.5 (Will have to wait for a verdict)
Bournival: 7.5 (Good energy from the energy kid)
Thomas: 8.5 (Incredible speed tonight again and hopefully he carries that energy in Hamilton
Malhotra: 6.5 (faceoff man and adds more credibility to the 4th line)
Prust: 5.5 (Worst forward by far, looked out of pace)
Moen: 6.0 (Moen usual night)

I thought Drewiske played a very smart efficient game against a very fast team, I thought he would struggle with their small, quick forwards but he was never out of position and made a ton of smart plays.

I think Galchenyuk at 9 is way over ambitious, he made a very nice play on the OT winner and had a few good plays, but overall a solid game, not a very good or great one.

 

[vokiel]

For all pre-season games I keep a score card in the form of a count of good plays vs bad plays. (basically +1 for good -1 for bad, 0 when nothing special happens) Galch had the highest count, Desharnais the lowest for last night.

 

[MXD]

Yes he was horrible. H O R R I B L E. As in fumbled the puck as much as AHLer Sorkin on Tuesday.

And I'm usually a Desharnais fan.

I also think he played a TURRRRRIBLE game.

But then I noticed he won quite a bit of faceoffs. And had like 4 takeaways in the middle of the ice. And drew two penalties.

I cannot give him below 6, really.

 

[vokiel]

I also think he played a TURRRRRIBLE game.

But then I noticed he won quite a bit of faceoffs. And had like 4 takeaways in the middle of the ice. And drew two penalties.

I cannot give him below 6, really.

Good point, I just didn't consider faceoffs at all.

 

[Natey]

I also think he played a TURRRRRIBLE game.

But then I noticed he won quite a bit of faceoffs. And had like 4 takeaways in the middle of the ice. And drew two penalties.

I cannot give him below 6, really.

If I'm not mistaken, we scored on both penalties he drew as well, one which he assisted on.