Giroux or kovalchuk for McKinnon

[Kardi]

I have a feeling McKinnon will be a beast and I want to trade for him while his stock is at it's lowest? What are your thoughts on trading a current star for him

Click to read more...

 

[AnthonyJohnson]

I have a feeling McKinnon will be a beast and I want to trade for him while his stock is at it's lowest? What are your thoughts on trading a current star for him

Uhh... No. MacKinnon would be lucky if he became as good as Kovalchuk or Giroux.

 

[Kardi]

You think so? he is one of the rare players who started in the Q with an underaged exception. Giroux definitely didn't do that.

 

[Chieftans22*]

If I had to I'd give up Kovalchuk. He won't be producing to the extreme these next few years.

 

[the implication]

Only on HF.. 80pt forward for a prospect.

 

[Kardi]

Only on HF.. 80pt forward for a prospect.

I have to many solid keepers and don't want to lose one for nothing. I'd rather trade kova for mckinnon then lose Nuge

 

[The Hockey Hitman]

I would think in most competitive leagues with knowledgeable GMs, you should be able to get more than MacKinnon for Kovalchuk - and I wouldn't consider dealing him for Giroux.

 

[Kardi]

Surprisingly Kovalchuk for Mckinnon was rejected.. He also rejected Rask, Shattinkirk and nash for him.. LOL

 

[Hutzler]

I have a feeling McKinnon will be a beast and I want to trade for him while his stock is at it's lowest? What are your thoughts on trading a current star for him

You say it like it is a big secret.

Only way I would give up a current star player for a future star player, is if I am not going to be a threat for the next couple years. If you are rebuilding and looking more to win in the future than sure.

 

[Greek_physique]

You'd be dump to trade Giroux for McKinnon...same with Kovie.

Let's see if the Kid produces before you make that type of an offer.

 

[The Colonel]

Did you manage to trade him Kovalchuk before the bomb dropped?