+/- Game: Alumni Edition!!

These Are The Days

Oh no! We suck again!!
May 17, 2014
34,540
20,376
Tampa Bay
Rules are simple and just like last year. As a refresher I'll briefly go over it again. Every player starts at +5 and in each move by a participant a player is assigned a +1 and another a -1. Coloring the name and number green for a plus and red for a minus is optional but does help with someone visual like myself. If you don't do that then at least show a +1 or -1. One or the other is necessary or the vote will not count. We have to be able to see the work

Examples both players are at a 5 when we begin

Bradley (6) a +1 was added to Bradley
Cross (4) a -1 was added to Cross

or

Bradley -1 (4) to show a minus added to Bradley
Cross +1 (6) to show a plus added to Cross

YOU MAY VOTE ONE TIME A DAY ONLY


We continue until a winner is left. The scores reset to 5 once we reach a final 5 of players. This way we aren't dealing with a guy at +76 vs another +58 trading votes back and forth until we've decided as a winner. It'll never get settled.

I tried as much as I could to include the old school 1990's names even if they were not so good. I didn't want the list to comprise solely of Cup winners from 2004 despite them having the majority of our best players ever. If requested we can do a 2004 edition for the next offseason. I'm sure by then Richards will have retired so we can include him.

Bradley (5)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (5)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (5)
St. Louis (5)
Prospal (5)
Modin (5)
Fedotenko (5)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (5)
Houlder (5)
Hamrlik (5)
Sarich (5)
Cross (5)
Cullimore (5)

Khabibulin (5)
Puppa (5)

GO!!!!!!
 

These Are The Days

Oh no! We suck again!!
May 17, 2014
34,540
20,376
Tampa Bay
Bradley (5)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (5)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (5)
St. Louis (5)
Prospal (5)
Modin (5)
Fedotenko (5)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (5)
Houlder (4)
Hamrlik (5)
Sarich (5)
Cross (5)
Cullimore (5)

Khabibulin (5)
Puppa (6)
 

Kramerica Industries

Registered User
Mar 21, 2013
2,749
0
Tampa, FL
Bradley (5)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (5)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (5)
St. Louis (5)
Prospal (5)
Modin (6)
Fedotenko (5)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (5)
Houlder (4)
Hamrlik (5)
Sarich (5)
Cross (4)
Cullimore (5)

Khabibulin (5)
Puppa (6)

PS - no Stan Drulia is one terrible snub, dude.
 

These Are The Days

Oh no! We suck again!!
May 17, 2014
34,540
20,376
Tampa Bay
I felt bad snubbing Taylor but I chose Cullen instead because every Lightning fan I talk to who watched him go into a loss of words when they try to describe how important he was to the team and how amazing it was to see him come back. I started my fandom in the Cup run because it was the first time I had Lightning hockey on local broadcast because we didn't have cable. Then I listened to probably 65 games over the radio the next season.
 

MattM92

Registered User
Dec 8, 2010
6,925
516
FL
Bradley (5)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (5)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (7)
St. Louis (5)
Prospal (5)
Modin (6)
Fedotenko (5)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (5)
Houlder (3)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (5)
Cross (4)
Cullimore (5)

Khabibulin (5)
Puppa (6)
 

The Gongshow

Fire JBB
Jul 17, 2014
25,814
8,299
Toronto
Bradley (5)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (5)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (8)
St. Louis (5)
Prospal (5)
Modin (6)
Fedotenko (5)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (5)
Houlder (2)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (5)
Cross (4)
Cullimore (5)

Khabibulin (5)
Puppa (6)
 

Meuracas

Registered User
Nov 2, 2013
281
296
Bradley (5)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (8)
St. Louis (5)
Prospal (5)
Modin (6)
Fedotenko (5)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (5)
Houlder (1)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (5)
Cross (4)
Cullimore (5)

Khabibulin (5)
Puppa (6)
 

Felonious Python

Minor League Degenerate
Aug 20, 2004
30,825
8,928
Bradley (5)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (8)
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (6)
Fedotenko (5)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (5)
Houlder (0) ELIMINATED
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (5)
Cross (4)
Cullimore (5)

Khabibulin (5)
Puppa (6)


Didn't hold a chance.
 

Iceman

Registered User
Jun 9, 2014
10,640
2,024
Bradley (5)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (8)
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (5)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (5)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (5)
Cross (3)
Cullimore (5)

Khabibulin (5)
Puppa (6)
 

Hoek

Legendary Poster A
May 12, 2003
11,523
8,983
Tampa, FL
Bradley (5)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (8)
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (5)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (5)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (5)
Cross (2)
Cullimore (5)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (6)
 

LightningStrikes

Champa Bay Lightning
Nov 24, 2009
26,281
10,158
TL;DR: Vinny wins. :sarcasm:



Bradley (5)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (9)
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (5)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (5)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (5)
Cross (2)
Cullimore (4)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (6)
 

chasespace

Registered User
Jul 19, 2010
9,045
18
Gator Nation
Bradley (5)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (9)
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (4)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (6)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (5)
Cross (2)
Cullimore (4)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (6)
 

These Are The Days

Oh no! We suck again!!
May 17, 2014
34,540
20,376
Tampa Bay
Bradley (6)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (9)
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (4)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (6)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (5)
Cross (1)
Cullimore (4)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (6)

Boy... Cross and Houlder didn't stand a chance did they?
 

Kramerica Industries

Registered User
Mar 21, 2013
2,749
0
Tampa, FL
Bradley (6)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (9)
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (5)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (6)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (5)
Cross (0)
Cullimore (4)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (6)

--

Cross Cory off.
 

Maelmoor

Registered User
Apr 20, 2004
6,497
1,835
Stockholm, Sweden
Bradley (6)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (9)
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (5)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (5)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (6)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (4)
Cullimore (4)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (7)
 

MattM92

Registered User
Dec 8, 2010
6,925
516
FL
Bradley (6)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (9)
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (6)
Andersson (5)
Selivanov (4)
Cullen (5)

Kubina (6)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (4)
Cullimore (4)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (7)
 

These Are The Days

Oh no! We suck again!!
May 17, 2014
34,540
20,376
Tampa Bay
Bradley (6)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (9)
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (6)
Andersson (4)
Selivanov (4)
Cullen (6)

Kubina (6)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (4)
Cullimore (4)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (7)
 

Maelmoor

Registered User
Apr 20, 2004
6,497
1,835
Stockholm, Sweden
Bradley (6)
Zamuner (6) +1
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (9)
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (6)
Andersson (4)
Selivanov (3) -1
Cullen (6)

Kubina (6)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (4)
Cullimore (4)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (7)

Edit: Adding a + and - after the changed players, in case someone is colour blind
 

MrClutch86

Registered User
Aug 23, 2013
6,173
127
Tampa
Bradley (7) +1
Zamuner (5) -1
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (9)
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (6)
Andersson (4)
Selivanov (3)
Cullen (6)

Kubina (6)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (4)
Cullimore (4)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (7)
 

Outl4w

Registered User
Dec 16, 2011
3,684
2,179
FL
Bradley (7) +1
Zamuner (5) -1
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (5)
Lecavalier (10) The only other 50 goal scorer in franchise history. L4g4nds Never Die
St. Louis (6)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (6)
Andersson (4)
Selivanov (2) -1
Cullen (6)

Kubina (6)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (4)
Cullimore (4)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (7)
 

tjs*

Registered User
Mar 18, 2016
2,103
0
Bradley (7)
Zamuner (5)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (6) +1 for exemplifying what a leader should be
Lecavalier (10)
St. Louis (5) -1 for exemplifying what a leader should not be
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (6)
Andersson (4)
Selivanov (2)
Cullen (6)

Kubina (6)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (4)
Cullimore (4)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (7)
 

These Are The Days

Oh no! We suck again!!
May 17, 2014
34,540
20,376
Tampa Bay
Bradley (7)
Zamuner (6)
Gratton (6)
Andreychuk (6)
Lecavalier (9)
St. Louis (5)
Prospal (5)
Modin (7)
Fedotenko (6)
Andersson (4)
Selivanov (2)
Cullen (6)

Kubina (6)
Hamrlik (4)
Sarich (4)
Cullimore (4)

Khabibulin (6)
Puppa (7)

Vinny can take a minus for a guy who deserves a plus. Wow tough love for the defense and Selivanov.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad