Peeke sucks. 3rd pair guy at best and you shouldn’t want him on the PK. A #7 when healthy if you ask me.
I wasn’t as high (or got as high) as many others were on Blankenburg, but, even then my opinions/expectations of him have cooled a bit. Like others, he’s playing higher in the lineup than he should, and with weaker players, but, his decision making/ability defensively is leaving me wanting more, and that’s what we need from the defense. He’s looking like a 3rd pair guy also that you want multiples better options on both special teams. I put him on the PP over the PK.
Boqvist’s value and impact comes from his offensive ability. If we had ANY sort of defensive depth, I would seriously consider him at wing (or maybe center). Him being just adequate defensively makes him an asset on the PP and capable of playing a 3rd pairing role. Problem is a lot of the time he isn’t actually adequate defensively.
The rest of the defense playing belong in the AHL.
I take Bean and Gudbranson over all these guys, and think Bean-Gudbranson works as a 2nd pair.
I don’t think Jiricek will be ready to play on the top pairing for the next 1+ years, especially on this team and with Werenski. It’s a lot different than playing with Jones, while also having Murray/Savard around, not to mention Bobrovsky and a slew of defensive minded forwards.
We need another top pairing (or a #3 at worst) defenseman. Jiricek or not.
That’s not even touching Roslovic on the PK and who is all responsible for that. That said, swapping Roslovic out for another center is not all that’s needed to be changed on forward either.
Peeke has not had a good season but he just turned 25, which is nothing for a defensive D-man. Boqvist has been a bright spot for me, we're finally seeing some of that talent and he's only 22, he's got plenty of time to round out his defensive game, I doubt he'll never be "good" at that, but for a player like him I'd be happy with "good enough". But he also gets very easy minutes, so he should be doing well.
I was pretty high on Blanks early on but dunno what to think of him, he's just not looked the same after he came back from that injury, dunno if something is still bothering him or if he just lost his mojo or what's going on.
There we come into the problem, the defensive group is so weak right now as a whole, it's hard to judge individual player performance. I agree the defense really needs help, even when healthy there's just no stable veteran D-men who can anchor a pairing. I don't understand what you see in Gudbranson, IMO he's been horrible, though he like everyone else is playing way over their head, so in that sense maybe he's improved from early season, but I see him as a bottom pairing guy, hopefully playing with someone better than himself. I think they are probably going to need to move some young D-men/prospects so that they can get the D into a shape where they can actually bring up the remaining youngsters into a situation where they can succeed without being destroyed. Having dubious defensive coaching doesn't help.
I think Roslovic on PK has been fine, haven't really paid that much attention to it tbh, but at least the numbers would suggest the PK is actually better with him on the ice than without. The biggest problem to me with Roslovic is he just has no consistency to his 5v5 game, one game he can look like superstar offensively and OK defensively, the next he might be completely ineffective and his D can look like he doesn't belong in the league at all. It doesn't help he's been nowhere when the games actually matter, like last season we saw other guys really step it up when they were still in the hunt for playoffs. Then once they get eliminated Roslovic is suddenly a player
Of course there's line combos and other things to consider, but it's still a bad look.