In order for those numbers to be meaningful, you'd have to assume they are performing against equal offenses..... which they obviously are not.
Even if I agree I don’t think you can use that to completely disregard the numbers either. What percentage deflation do you want to apply that is actually reasonable? 10%? The performance by both goalies have been very comparable.
I hate saying this on your turf but the Price of 5 years ago is the Price of 5 years ago. He hasn’t looked like legendary Price for a while now. Also I just find the skill logic inconsistent. If the Leafs are oh so skilled why are they not winning? I think we can both agree that on paper the Leafs are more skilled. Is it because they are playing phenomenally and just getting robbed by Price all game? I don’t think so. The same high caliber Leafs offence does not work in the playoffs. I don’t think we can just jump to on paper vs off paper when convenient. You have to somehow quantify the argument. Add in a graph for high danger scoring chances and I bet the numbers between the two goalies are still very similar. But you can’t just disregard Campbell because of the offence argument when our offence isn’t the same post season.
I’m just sick of Leafs fans doing this every year to excuse our core. I guess with you guys it’s a little different. Historically one of your biggest superstars has been your goalie so it’s understandable that there’s a nostalgic bias to believe “Carey’s back” sorta thing. But tbh there hasn’t been a significant difference in goaltending all series. If you come to our board rn it’s a bloodbath; we’ve bashed everyone including the 2 Muskoka boys who have a longer leash than a guy who was a nobody coming into this/last season.
I just want my team to be recognized for the joke they are properly. Just saying goaltending seriously understates how bad the team is at turning up. Objectively speaking by all metrics and eye test imo both goalies nullified each other. Today will be another exhibit of the Leafs folding like a cheap tent as they have in their past 3 game 7s (Columbus series was 2-2 best of 5)