I doubt very many fans just want to see high scoring games and not care about winning. I think some fans believe it's best to do whatever is necessary to keep star players happy, thus retaining them. This is a fan base that has seen players like Panarin, Nash, Bobrovsky, Foote, PLD, and Carter leave or force their way out. They just want nice things.
I think others believe the best way to to handle it is to hold stars and grinders accountable for their effort and commitment to the team.
I also think some fans and coaches believe the most talented players need to be held the most accountable for their effort. I think this is the approach coaches like Scotty Bowman, Mike Keenan, even Urban Meyer take. Relentless competition and accountability.
My belief is the inability to retain and attract some star players has more to do with ownership than coaching or even the front office. Columbus ownership hasn't been successful selling the team to the league. If it had we would be getting big events like the Winter Classic and much more national exposure. I believe a lot of fans, even players and agents are barely aware there's a team in Columbus. I think it's likely the Jackets aren't on a lot of no trade lists because the players and agents don't even think about Columbus. Not good, not bad - nothing. That's what needs to change.
Looking at the cities, Columbus is no more or less attractive than Pittsburgh, Buffalo, Minneapolis, Denver and the rest of the mid market. It's ownership.