BillDineen
Former Flyer / Extinct Dinosaur Advisor
- Aug 9, 2009
- 9,375
- 8,101
Eh. I dont think he is as bad as you are saying. He is easily better than White who struggled here a lot. His advanced stats were mid road on some things, bad on others and good on others. What you typically get for a 4th line player.
and he should.Hextall is paying him like a 3rd liner, so that's where I think he fits in Philly.
Nothing wrong with a four year deal for Weise if it's 2.5 or less. That's a disposable contract with small downside risk that's easy to get out of by trade if need be. A lot like the Talbot deal. As long as AAV is small, I have no concern.
Also not seeing how it conflicts with Hextall's earlier comments. He preaches cautiousness, not total avoidance of term altogether. People seem to think when he mentions his reluctance to things like term, letting teenagers play, etc. that he's swearing off these things entirely... realistically, Hextall isn't ever categorical about making those decisions. Just that he's cautious. He has the right mindset. Lots of people seem to think categorically and assume that Hextall does too, but I don't think that right.
Nothing wrong with a four year deal for Weise if it's 2.5 or less. That's a disposable contract with small downside risk that's easy to get out of by trade if need be. A lot like the Talbot deal. As long as AAV is small, I have no concern.
Also not seeing how it conflicts with Hextall's earlier comments. He preaches cautiousness, not total avoidance of term altogether. People seem to think when he mentions his reluctance to things like term, letting teenagers play, etc. that he's swearing off these things entirely... realistically, Hextall isn't ever categorical about making those decisions. Just that he's cautious. He has the right mindset. Lots of people seem to think categorically and assume that Hextall does too, but I don't think that right.
When Hexy talked about being scared of term, he must have mean term at $4.5m+.
I buy the idea that Weise could be dealt with like Talbot down the road if necessary.
those players are the sandpaper that helps guys out the g. Great signing.Weise for 4 years, $2.5M cap hit per year is a poor use of cap space, IMO.
Falling in love with a "heavy" checking line player who happened to score a few clutch playoff goals when he was younger and cheaper.
Sort of like the Talbot signing, who ultimately ended up being a buyout after they managed to dump him.
way better than read and way more will and compete.I'm surprised how many of you are ok with this deal for Weise but rail on Matt Read.
I'm surprised how many of you are ok with this deal for Weise but rail on Matt Read.
I'm surprised how many of you are ok with this deal for Weise but rail on Matt Read.
Yep. Says all you need to know. Not a bad guy to target.Well, Read is getting over $1m more, and has scored less at ES than Weise under his current contract.
Last two years:
Raffl - 149 games, 54 ESP
Weise - 150 games, 50 ESP
Read - 159 games, 43 ESP
VdV - 151 games, 28 ESP
White 107 games, 24 ESP
PEB - 155 games, 24 ESP
Weise for 4 years, $2.5M cap hit per year is a poor use of cap space, IMO.
Falling in love with a "heavy" checking line player who happened to score a few clutch playoff goals when he was younger and cheaper.
Sort of like the Talbot signing, who ultimately ended up being a buyout after they managed to dump him.
That doesn't make it a good deal.Read is getting paid $3.625m per year and isn't exactly outplaying Weise.
Weise at ~$2.5m is a better deal