I'm a writer, apologies in advance for the length.
Look, Torts does what he does. For a time, he can galvanize a team to overachieve—that was the story of his CBJ tenure. He got them to 50 (!) wins before Panarin even got there. That's impressive, and that's to his credit.
But it comes at a cost. He will lean as hard as humanly possible on whatever's working in the short term, long term be damned. That's not a great thing to do on a thin, ostensibly-rebuilding team.
Couturier, for instance, was nearly two f***ing years out of the league. He's diminished, but still useful—a terrific defensive center. The Flyers are severely lacking in center depth—Couturier, Frost, Poehling, Laughton/Cates (who are both better at wing). So what does Torts do with that?
Tortorella spent the first leg of the season scratching Frost for no expressed reason and, having limited his own options, absolutely riding Couturier. For the first half of the season Couturier was one of the highest-played forwards in the league. Some nights he eclipsed 25 minutes.
Common sense tells you that, if you have a veteran player who has had 2 back surgeries and 0 games played in nearly 2 calendar years, you might want to manage his workload out of the gate. Tortorella did the dead opposite, and the fatigue built up. Couturier didn't fall off a cliff this season, he declined over a long period of time. You can't tell me that his usage didn't contribute mightily to that.
Meanwhile, Frost has repeatedly expressed that he didn't know exactly why he was scratched (Couturier echoed that when he was as well). And when Frost finally was given proper top 6 usage he...produced like a top-6 center. The Flyers took off this season and held that playoff spot for so long because, with two legitimate top 6 centers instead of one, they were a better team. Since demoting Couturier, they collectively have fallen off a cliff.
This is the stuff that is so maddening, but it's even more upsetting in the context. That context being: What's the f***ing point?
Those of us who have followed this team for 20 or 30 years or more don't want to be lectured about having pride. Until about ten years ago, we might've been the proudest damn fanbase in the league relative to success. We've lost twice as many Stanley Cup Finals as most teams in this league have even appeared in. From 1973 until 2012, there were only a handful of seasons where the Flyers were not in the conversation
So as far as moral-victorying their way to the playoffs...we don't care! We don't give a f*** about SCRAPPY UNDERDOGGIN' our way to a first round splatter. That's the story of the last decade. We're over it. We used to eat Eastern Conference Final losses for breakfast.
The reason so many of us are comfortable selling assets and bottoming out for a bit is because that's at least something that resembles a path towards getting the high-end talent this franchise needs to return to the top.
Instead, these guys are rudderless. Torts was hired over the last GM's head; the current GM and President of Hockey Operations were internal hires because the vapid cable company ownership conditioned hiring based on keeping Torts around. Meaning every outside option turned them down, and the guys they have now are inexperienced mascots who haven't displayed anything in the way of competence or vision yet.
There's a lot to it, and I'll stop myself there, but...it's easy from the outside to go "what's there to be mad about?" But when you follow the ins and outs of this team, the answer is basically...everything. Bad ownership, bad management, no clear future. They're a sales and marketing operation that treats players like shit and fans like exploitable marks.