Evaluate players 1st round

[llamateizer]

how do you Evaluate players,
P.K. Subban MTL D 6 1 3 4 +1
Tomas Plekanec MTL C 6 1 2 3 +3
Torrey Mitchell MTL C 6 1 2 3 +3
Brian Flynn MTL C 5 1 2 3 +0
Max Pacioretty MTL L 5 2 0 2 +0
Dale Weise MTL R 6 2 0 2 +3
Brendan Gallagher MTL R 6 1 1 2 +2
Alex Galchenyuk MTL C 6 1 1 2 +2
Lars Eller MTL C 6 1 1 2 +1
David Desharnais C 6 0 2 2 -2
Brandon Prust L 6 0 2 2 +2
Greg Pateryn D 3 0 2 2 +1
Tom Gilbert D 6 1 0 1 +4
Andrei Markov D 6 0 1 1 +0
Alexei Emelin D 6 0 1 1 +0
Devante Smith-Pelly R 6 0 1 1 -2
Nathan Beaulieu D 3 0 1 1 +1
Jeff Petry D 6 0 0 0 +1
Jacob De La Rose L 6 0 0 0 -1
Pierre-Alexandre Parenteau R 2 0 0 0

Price 4 2 1.94 .939


My take
A+
Tokarski, played 0 minute

A
Price (1 bad goal last game)
Dale Weise, Gretzky, hard working
Brendan Gallagher, Played perfectly his game
Greg Pateryn, Surprisingly good bottom pair D
Nathan Beaulieu, Good before injury
Jeff Petry, Generated offense, Liked him

A-
Lars Eller, stats not there, played a good 1st round
Brandon Prust, good job, agitator

B+
P.K. Subban, had decent games, some errors made
Torrey Mitchell, played good his role
Devante Smith-Pelly, playing hard, finishing his hits. Accepts his role

B
Max Pacioretty, didnt looked 100%, free Pass
David Desharnais, People hate him, but he played hard
Alex Galchenyuk, Beside OT goal, not that much
Pierre-Alexandre Parenteau, Game 1 not present, game 2, better game

B-
Tomas Plekanec, Relatively absent, but played good defensively
Brian Flynn, Beside game 1, Absent
Tom Gilbert, nothing to say
Alexei Emelin , nothing to say
Jacob De La Rose, kid is 19yo
C+
C
Andrei Markov , Rough 1st round
C-

Click to read more...

 

[PuckNorris]

I wish you were my prof in college. Would have made the Dean's list.

 

[llamateizer]

I wish you were my prof in college. Would have made the Dean's list.

I'm an optmistic guy in general.

Proof: I like Therrien (beside game 5)

 

[Nicko999]

how do you Evaluate players,
P.K. Subban MTL D 6 1 3 4 +1
Tomas Plekanec MTL C 6 1 2 3 +3
Torrey Mitchell MTL C 6 1 2 3 +3
Brian Flynn MTL C 5 1 2 3 +0
Max Pacioretty MTL L 5 2 0 2 +0
Dale Weise MTL R 6 2 0 2 +3
Brendan Gallagher MTL R 6 1 1 2 +2
Alex Galchenyuk MTL C 6 1 1 2 +2
Lars Eller MTL C 6 1 1 2 +1
David Desharnais C 6 0 2 2 -2
Brandon Prust L 6 0 2 2 +2
Greg Pateryn D 3 0 2 2 +1
Tom Gilbert D 6 1 0 1 +4
Andrei Markov D 6 0 1 1 +0
Alexei Emelin D 6 0 1 1 +0
Devante Smith-Pelly R 6 0 1 1 -2
Nathan Beaulieu D 3 0 1 1 +1
Jeff Petry D 6 0 0 0 +1
Jacob De La Rose L 6 0 0 0 -1
Pierre-Alexandre Parenteau R 2 0 0 0

Price 4 2 1.94 .939


My take
A+
Tokarski, played 0 minute

A
Price (1 bad goal last game)
Dale Weise, Gretzky, hard working
Brendan Gallagher, Played perfectly his game
Greg Pateryn, Surprisingly good bottom pair D
Nathan Beaulieu, Good before injury
Jeff Petry, Generated offense, Liked him

A-
Lars Eller, stats not there, played a good 1st round
Brandon Prust, good job, agitator

B+
P.K. Subban, had decent games, some errors made
Torrey Mitchell, played good his role
Devante Smith-Pelly, playing hard, finishing his hits. Accepts his role

B
Max Pacioretty, didnt looked 100%, free Pass
David Desharnais, People hate him, but he played hard
Alex Galchenyuk, Beside OT goal, not that much
Pierre-Alexandre Parenteau, Game 1 not present, game 2, better game

B-
Tomas Plekanec, Relatively absent, but played good defensively
Brian Flynn, Beside game 1, Absent
Tom Gilbert, nothing to say
Alexei Emelin , nothing to say
Jacob De La Rose, kid is 19yo
C+
C
Andrei Markov , Rough 1st round
C-

So do I get an A+ because I played 0 min?

BTW-You're way too rough on Markov. Emelin was worse than him over the course of the series. Markov despite his difficulties was still our 3rd or 4th best D-man.

 

[Kamina]

Price: SSSSSSSSSS+++++++++++++

(S is a tier above A)

 

[TRG]

Markov is one of my favorite players and wow he was horrawful.

 

[le_sean]

B for Galchenyuk? LOL

 

[Kjell Dahlin]

No time for a complete list but regarding the OP, I would give a better grade to Gilbert and Emelin.

 

[Habs13]

P.K. Subban - Can turn it up some, B
Tomas Plekanec - Still a little girl, C
Torrey Mitchell - Face-offs and nothing more, C-
Brian Flynn - One great game, then invisible, C
Max Pacioretty - Injured, and invisible, C
Dale Weise - What more do you want from a grinder?, B
Brendan Gallagher - All guts, B
Alex Galchenyuk - Disapointing, C+
Lars Eller - Best forward, B+
David Desharnais - Warmed up dog crap, D
Brandon Prust - Not much grind for a grinder, C
Greg Pateryn - Not bad, C+
Tom Gilbert - Too mny mistakes, C
Andrei Markov - Bone-headed plays, own goal, C
Alexei Emelin - Good hits, liabillity, C
Devante Smith-Pelly - Was good for two games, then vanished, C
Nathan Beaulieu - Wasn't playing before injury, C
Jeff Petry - Hope he stays come summer, B
Jacob De La Rose - Had a rough time, C+
Pierre-Alexandre Parenteau - Brings nothing, C

 

[the]

I feel Prust is rated too high any grinder would have had atleast 2 goals with all the chances he had.

 

[PuckSeparator]

Markov was a liability out there... He'd get an F from me. Too slow, too weak and making the dumbest decisions like the one today that almost concussed Price. He deserved to be benched. Honestly, I find this exercise a bit pointless as only a a very small # of Habs had good series: Eller, Petry, 4th line, that's about it

 

[didimentionlarseller]

Carey Price immaculate

 

[Fish on The Sand]

No time for a complete list but regarding the OP, I would give a better grade to Gilbert and Emelin.

Gilbert deserves a bad grade for his dumbass play in game 4 alone.

 

[yoyo999]

Pacioretty is obviously still hurt, IMO

 

[le_sean]

Gilbert deserves a bad grade for his dumbass play in game 4 alone.

One mistake, it's just extrapolated because it was a 1-0 game. He was very solid otherwise.

The entire team deserves a bad grade in that game for not scoring a goal. They had like 1 real scoring chance.

 

[Lshap]

Mr. Markov, I'd like to see you after class. You seem to have lost two gears.

Mr. Galchenyuk, I appreciate you're trying, but I think you need a shooter-tutor.

 

[habdynasty]

One mistake, it's just extrapolated because it was a 1-0 game. He was very solid otherwise.

The entire team deserves a bad grade in that game for not scoring a goal. They had like 1 real scoring chance.

Gilbert was and always been good , for some reason he will always be the whipping boy for some . Markov was terrible every game . Scoring on his on team , falling on his franchise goalie . Passing was bad , here's hoping he rebounds next series.

 

[Lshap]

Gilbert deserves a bad grade for his dumbass play in game 4 alone.

Gilbert was quite good. Amazing how totally different our D is this playoffs, compared to last.

 

[Ohashi_Jouzu*]

I feel Prust is rated too high any grinder would have had atleast 2 goals with all the chances he had.

You gotta admire the compete level, but he might honestly be the worst player in the NHL with the puck on his stick, and I'm including defensemen in there - tempted to include goalies, too.

 

[eFFeRR]

Best players this series:

Lars Eller
Jeff Petry
Carey Price
Tom Gilbert
Dale Weise

Good showing:

Brandon Prust
Brenden Gallagher
PK Subban
Greg Pateryn
Devante Smith-Pelly

Below Average:

Alex Galchenyuk
David Desharnais
PA Parenteau
Torrey Mitchell
Alexei Emelin
Brian Flynn

Terrible:

Tomas Plekanec
Andrei Markov
Max Pacioretty
Jacob de la Rose

 

[le_sean]

Gilbert was quite good. Amazing how totally different our D is this playoffs, compared to last.

Really? You think having a bottom pairing of Beaulieu-Pateryn/Gilbert is better than Bouillon/Murray? I don't know man...

 

[MXD]

Best player Petry, worst player Markov.

Seriously, it's a shame that Beaulieu was injured, and that MT won't scratch Emelin.

 

[rockjngo]

Price A

Subban A-
Markov D (too slow)
Petry B
Gilbert B-
Emelin B
Beaulieu B+
Pateryn B+

Pacioretty B-
Desharnais C-
Smith Pelly C
Parenteau D+
Plekanec C
Galchenyuk C+ (his balance and speed I question is NOT elite.)
Gallagher A
Weise A
Eller B+
Prust B
DLR B+
Mitchell B+
Flynn B+


I think trading Markov for a faster defenseman.

I would consider Galchenyuk for Ryan Nugent Hopkins

 

[Microsens]

A+
A Eller
A- Price and Gallagher
B+ Weise, Gilbert, Petry, Beaulieu
B Subban, Mitchell
B- DSP, Plekanec, Pateryn
C+ Pacioretty, Flynn
C
C- Markov, Emelin, DLR, Desharnais, Prust
D Galchenyuk

 

[Dagistitsyn]

Desharnais / Plekanec / Galchenyuk / Pacioretty = F
Harsh, but they all failed at being top 6 players. I'm a HUGE Plekanec and Pacioretty fan but they need to find a way to be better. DD I expected to have a rough time against Ottawa. Galchenyuk was the more invisible than AK ever was.