You guys can spin it all you want, but the fact remains that your Captain should never say anything like that.
Who cares if it is true. You don't go into an elimination game thinking you are going to lose. Especially if you are "leading" 20 guys.
I don't think many would argue he shouldn't have said it (since in sports you can never say negatives, even in the face of all negatives, etc..against you).
That said, he didn't say they wouldn't win the next game or the series. Rationally if you look at ANY team that is down 3-1 it is doubtful they will win the series.
Once again you put way too much stock in a captain - if the other guys on the team hear that and decide to fold up shop, shame on them. They are all individuals who need to give it their all for the team regardless and I expect they will do that.
That said, Pitt DOES have a ridiculous PP and that was Alfie's main point. The Senators have had the best PK for most of the season yet Pitt is still finding ways to score with seaming ease. Only one game in the entire play-offs the Pens haven't scored at least 3 goals and that was game 3 this series when they had 50 shots on net.
Be upset with the remark but to go back and somehow lay the blame on Alfie for the Senators not winning a Stanley Cup and then implying that he and fans are losers is just sour grapes and you come off looking the worst in that dialogue.