Doughty logged a ton of minutes game in game out in all kinds of situations. Kid is smooth and smart. Yes he has room to improve but I don't see Bogo being better than him now or anytime soon.
Ryan, Versteeg, and Mason all had fine seasons, should that take away from Doughty? No rookie had more of an impact on their team except for Mason.
How so?
Versteeg carried the Hawks on his back for almost a month and was a main reason they finished amongst the elite in the West. Was also fantastic in the playoffs until he went into business for himself taking stupid penalties against Detroit.
Ryan was the best non-goalie rookie by far, and might have netted 50 if he played a whole season.
Both helped their teams make the playoffs, and deserved their accolades as Calder finalists, which I predicted pefectly.
Doughty didnt.
If Bogo had played a whole year, nobody would be talking about Doughty, but even in limited action Bogo made more of an impact, and Iam not knocking Doughty, I just think he isnt as special as Bogo, thats MHO.
He has plenty of time to prove me wrong, but in all honesty, I see him regressing on his performance this year instead of getting better, he walked into a pefect situation in LA where he saw alot of minutes, and thats about it. Hes far from being a Norris contender any time soon, and with Bogo being more physical, I would give Zack the nod as to who will win the Norris between the two. But both are far away from the upper echelon defenseman like Chara, Lidstrom, keith to even be acknowledged for the award anyway.
We shall see
FlapJack- HF's Blackhawk expert