Fans think what they want to think. The sad truth is that the offense and the skating is there but if he was ever going to be a dominant D man he'd be better by now. Doughty was leading team Canada to a Gold at his age and missed part of a season before winning a Cup.
Hes a 2nd pairing D man who will score like a first pairing guy and will cost a ton and have to be paid like a first pairing guy since hes big and produces points. Not going to be a top end shut down guy. Please trade him for one if we can do it do not trade him for a forward unless they are an all star and young (Hall.)
90% of this board will insist Bergeron is a better player than Crosby or Malkin because they want to and 90% of this board wouldn't trade him for anything no matter how much it improved the team though.
How many defencemen, besides doughty, that are currently in the NHL are there that were as good as Dougie is at age 21? Or as good as he was in the playoffs last year at 20?
He's going through a slump now, battling the puck alot but he was easily our best defenceman for the first 1/3-1/2 of the season and stepped up when Chara went down. In the 19 games without Chara, Dougie put up 4g-11a-15p and a +6 playing big minutes and the team went 11-6-1.
I don't like the way him and Chara are currently playing together but they have shown in the past to work pretty well together. I think Dougie can really help with z's lack of mobility but It's tough because DH is the guy you want pushing the pace and stepping up in the play and while Z can help cover for guys in his own end he needs someone to do the same for him in the offensive and neutral zone.