Create your all-time penalty killing unit
- Thread starter Herzeleid
- Start date
VanIslander
A 19-year ATDer on HfBoards
From the Original 6 onward...
1st PK unit: Guy Carbonneau - Bob Pulford - Bobby Orr - Rod Langway
2nd PK unit: Butch Goring - Bob Gainey - Doug Harvey - Tim Horton
1st PK unit: Guy Carbonneau - Bob Pulford - Bobby Orr - Rod Langway
2nd PK unit: Butch Goring - Bob Gainey - Doug Harvey - Tim Horton
Lemieux - Gretzky
Orr - Harvey
Lemieux and Gretzky together in their best seasons would combine for 25 shorthanded goals!
Throw Orr and Harvey behind them that total would go up, and they wouldn't get scored on.
Orr - Harvey
Lemieux and Gretzky together in their best seasons would combine for 25 shorthanded goals!
Throw Orr and Harvey behind them that total would go up, and they wouldn't get scored on.
TheDevilMadeMe
Registered User
Defensemen:
Serge Savard - Bobby Orr
Scott Stevens - Doug Harvey
Forwards:
Bobby Clarke - Frank Nighbor
Wayne Gretzky - Jari Kurri
Serge Savard - Bobby Orr
Scott Stevens - Doug Harvey
Forwards:
Bobby Clarke - Frank Nighbor
Wayne Gretzky - Jari Kurri
John Flyers Fan
Registered User
Just going with players I have seen: Clarke, Gainey and Orr are absolute locks.
There are plenty of candidates for the other defense spot: Potvin, Bourque, Stevens, Pronger, Savard, or Chelios.
I'll take Bernie Parent circa 1974, at his absolute peak, and he also faced more PP attempts than any goalie alive.
There are plenty of candidates for the other defense spot: Potvin, Bourque, Stevens, Pronger, Savard, or Chelios.
I'll take Bernie Parent circa 1974, at his absolute peak, and he also faced more PP attempts than any goalie alive.
seventieslord
Student Of The Game
Bobby clarke, craig ramsay, bobby orr, bill white. Parent in net. JFF already covered why.
LG-GW620 Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; U; Android 1.5) AppleWebKit/528.5+ (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/3.1.2 Mobile Safari/525.20.1 Java/Jbed/7.0 Profile/MIDP-2.1 Configuration/CLDC-1.1 MMS/LG-Android-MMS-V1.0/1.2
LG-GW620 Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; U; Android 1.5) AppleWebKit/528.5+ (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/3.1.2 Mobile Safari/525.20.1 Java/Jbed/7.0 Profile/MIDP-2.1 Configuration/CLDC-1.1 MMS/LG-Android-MMS-V1.0/1.2
Marotte Marauder
Registered User
- Aug 10, 2008
- 8,587
- 2,442
Axxellien
Registered User
Time To Kill:
Defense=Forwards- Westfall, Mohns,.... Kitty Bar The Door Artists, A. Stanley, A. Arbour,..... Second Goalie Goldham,...Bob Orr, P. Pilote. Turk Sanderson for CounterAttack....Mobility.... Stapleton, Bill White,
Defense=Forwards- Westfall, Mohns,.... Kitty Bar The Door Artists, A. Stanley, A. Arbour,..... Second Goalie Goldham,...Bob Orr, P. Pilote. Turk Sanderson for CounterAttack....Mobility.... Stapleton, Bill White,
Ohashi_Jouzu*
Registered User
Wow. Surprisingly tough. I guess I'd be tempted to go with some topics of recent conversation and start with a defensive "squad" consisting of:
Langway, Robinson, Orr, Bourque (but all are LH shots, and a wise choice in Harvey, albeit another LH shot, obviously gets omitted. Also, I have always thought of Scott Stevens as better value 5-on-5, so he doesn't get consideration from me here. Feel bad not having Lidstrom, either, but similar deal).
Forwards... Forwards... I love Gretzky, and his SH goals, but I don't think I'll jump on that trendy pick. For me, Clarke and Gainey have to be there. Maybe Carbonneau and/or Madden, but that makes me feel like I'm leaving out some better (but perhaps less "sexy") picks from earlier years. I'm gonna have to think about it a bit more.
Langway, Robinson, Orr, Bourque (but all are LH shots, and a wise choice in Harvey, albeit another LH shot, obviously gets omitted. Also, I have always thought of Scott Stevens as better value 5-on-5, so he doesn't get consideration from me here. Feel bad not having Lidstrom, either, but similar deal).
Forwards... Forwards... I love Gretzky, and his SH goals, but I don't think I'll jump on that trendy pick. For me, Clarke and Gainey have to be there. Maybe Carbonneau and/or Madden, but that makes me feel like I'm leaving out some better (but perhaps less "sexy") picks from earlier years. I'm gonna have to think about it a bit more.
Steve Kournianos
@thedraftanalyst
1st Unit
Carbonneau-Larmer
Bourque-Stevens
2nd Unit
Gretzky-Tikkanen
Lidstrom-Ramsey
Brodeur
And I say Brodeur for goalie because I always thought Haske and Roy were vulnerable to long shots from the point that got through their whole career, whereas Brodeur was virtually inpregnable on the PK from 40 feet out or more with or without screens
Carbonneau-Larmer
Bourque-Stevens
2nd Unit
Gretzky-Tikkanen
Lidstrom-Ramsey
Brodeur
And I say Brodeur for goalie because I always thought Haske and Roy were vulnerable to long shots from the point that got through their whole career, whereas Brodeur was virtually inpregnable on the PK from 40 feet out or more with or without screens
