San Jose wins in a landslide.
Three things that are important for context:
1. That 2016 4th is now transferred to Philly, allowing AZ to keep their '17 3rd
1A. For Arizona this means they effectively dealt Letunov and a 6th for two 3rds.
2. If Arizona traded Letunov (who's clearly a better asset than two 3rds) and had to add a 6th rounder to get a bite, it's probably because he's not interested in signing in Arizona and may opt to go the free-agent or Europe route, regardless. I suspect Arizona was not an option for him, and San Jose is making a little bit of a gamble, hoping they can convince him to sign with them.
3. Arizona acquired this player for Zbynek Michalek two deadlines ago. Michalek re-signed in Arizona a few months later. Letunov was basically a freebie for the Coyotes anyway.
So while San Jose is the winner here, Arizona isn't really the loser. One team won and the other broke even.
Letunov just had too many options. Arizona doesn't do well with guys that have other options. Haha. We kind of have to take guys who have no choice.
While I'd rather have Letunov, I'm guessing Chayka did what he had to do. Teams likely weren't willing to offer more because they have the same fears that Arizona does about this player having too many options. He's not your typical prospect. There's some risk due to his non-traditional path thus far.
Also, Arizona now has their own 1st, their own 2nd, and their own 3rd next year (due to Philly now getting the SJS '16 4th instead of our '17 3rd).
That means they can offer-sheet somebody now if they choose to. That wasn't an option before. They're a little more flexible this morning than they were last night. That's not the worst thing.