seventieslord
Student Of The Game
A follow up to my thread, "Consistency In Goalscoring".
I tracked the leading assist collectors year after year and compiled charts of how often each player was in the top-2, top-15, top-10, top-15, and top-20 in assists.
As in the goalscoring study, I thought it would be important to take this a step further than simple "top-10s" as is usually discussed because there are some great players who came close to the top-10 numerous times and there are some sketchy players who may have made the top-10, or even top-5 twice, and never made the top-20 again. Better sample size, better results.
In total, 97 seasons of top-level pro hockey are counted. All ties are counted as they are. A five-way tie for 10th means that there are 14 players in the top-10. Of course, it means you only need one more player to round out the top-15 as well.
As I said in the goalscoring study, I also thought that it would only be prudent of me to take this study back as far as possible, rather than consider the NHL the start of hockey - it's not. From 1910 through 1926 there were two, and sometimes three top-level leagues and it would be unfair to players of the post-1926 era to consider their post-consolidation accomplishments at the same level as one who played in a half-league in, say, 1919. So I went over the leaderboards of the NHA (1910-1917), PCHA (1912-1924) and WCHL/WHL (1922-1926) and constructed a simulated consolidated top-20 playmakers list based on the actual stats of those leagues. This was not done just with raw numbers but intuitively based on what I have learned about all these early players and the telltale signs about the strengths of each of these leagues over the years. The gap by which the assist leaders of each league dominated had a lot to do with slotting subsequent players. As I said, this was done intuitively and to the best of my abilities - I'm not interested in debating the merits of the system. It was done subjectively, with objectivity in mind, if that makes any sense.
Unfortunately, unlike the goalscoring study, this one needs to commence with the 1913 NHA season because that is the first year that assists were recorded with any semblance of regularity in that league. Even still, just 10 players received assists at all, but the leaderboard, with Malone and Lalonde topping it with 5, appears quite realistic. The PCHA was recording assists right from the start but their inagural 1912 season goes to waste with no NHA stats to consolidate with.
The WHA was not included, for the same reasons described in the goalscoring study.
I'm not going to attempt to account for any "watered-down" periods of time. We're all smart people here and we can look at this list and come to our own conclusions based on it.
Charts to follow, then tidbits. Comments welcome.
(ties in charts are broken by the next-most "prestigious" column)
I tracked the leading assist collectors year after year and compiled charts of how often each player was in the top-2, top-15, top-10, top-15, and top-20 in assists.
As in the goalscoring study, I thought it would be important to take this a step further than simple "top-10s" as is usually discussed because there are some great players who came close to the top-10 numerous times and there are some sketchy players who may have made the top-10, or even top-5 twice, and never made the top-20 again. Better sample size, better results.
In total, 97 seasons of top-level pro hockey are counted. All ties are counted as they are. A five-way tie for 10th means that there are 14 players in the top-10. Of course, it means you only need one more player to round out the top-15 as well.
As I said in the goalscoring study, I also thought that it would only be prudent of me to take this study back as far as possible, rather than consider the NHL the start of hockey - it's not. From 1910 through 1926 there were two, and sometimes three top-level leagues and it would be unfair to players of the post-1926 era to consider their post-consolidation accomplishments at the same level as one who played in a half-league in, say, 1919. So I went over the leaderboards of the NHA (1910-1917), PCHA (1912-1924) and WCHL/WHL (1922-1926) and constructed a simulated consolidated top-20 playmakers list based on the actual stats of those leagues. This was not done just with raw numbers but intuitively based on what I have learned about all these early players and the telltale signs about the strengths of each of these leagues over the years. The gap by which the assist leaders of each league dominated had a lot to do with slotting subsequent players. As I said, this was done intuitively and to the best of my abilities - I'm not interested in debating the merits of the system. It was done subjectively, with objectivity in mind, if that makes any sense.
Unfortunately, unlike the goalscoring study, this one needs to commence with the 1913 NHA season because that is the first year that assists were recorded with any semblance of regularity in that league. Even still, just 10 players received assists at all, but the leaderboard, with Malone and Lalonde topping it with 5, appears quite realistic. The PCHA was recording assists right from the start but their inagural 1912 season goes to waste with no NHA stats to consolidate with.
The WHA was not included, for the same reasons described in the goalscoring study.
I'm not going to attempt to account for any "watered-down" periods of time. We're all smart people here and we can look at this list and come to our own conclusions based on it.
Charts to follow, then tidbits. Comments welcome.
(ties in charts are broken by the next-most "prestigious" column)