Especially with Grabo's contract looking worse by the day, I really think it would be a mistake to give a big contract to a guy who can't do better than 50 points playing with Phil Kessel all year. Especially one who is pretty weak without the puck.
Agree with you on all points, but not on your assessment of Grabbo and his salary. The only reason Grabbo had an underwhelming offensive season (and thus seemingly inflated salary) is because of how he was used by Carlyle. Incredibly tough minutes, largely used in DZone starts, and given sub-par line mates for most of the season. Even considering all of this, he still had decent possession numbers, though not the output we are used to.
The first playoff game saw Grabbo playing more of his original role as a two way offensive force - playing more OZone starts, weaker comp, and better linemates - all amounting to being one of the better Leafs out there.
Hopefully Carlyle saw that and plays him effectively, but I'm not holding my breath for Carlyle to make a rational personnel decision.
Bozak is not a 1C, he doesn't have the offensive IQ or defensive ability. At best he is a FO specialist. And for that, I don't mind if the Leafs just let him walk, push up Kadri to 1C, put Grabbo back as a 2C, McClement as 3C and one of the Marlies kids as 4C.