Choose the BEST Fantasy Roster

tigervixxxen

Optimism=Delusional
Jul 7, 2013
53,060
6,156
Denver
burgundy-review.com
You all may have noticed a thread the last week or so where a few of us drafted a complete fantasy roster. The draft is now complete and we'd love some feedback on the rosters we have constructed. The parameters were a 88M cap, 23 man rosters, 2015 draft eligibles in play, no overseas players and cap hits determined by their 2015-16 salary (UFA/RFAs were allowed to use their salary from 2014-15).

Please help choose the "best" roster below. Best in terms of best team to take the ice now and in the future, essentially which roster you would choose as your own. The poll above is for "best roster" but if you have any opinions on best/worst use of cap space, most/least realistic, etc then we'd love to hear your opinions. This is all in fun, I'll reveal the anonymous team GMs when the poll closes (or you can cheat and look in the other thread).


Team A: Atlanta Flames

Andrew Ladd (4.4) - Anze Kopitar (6.8) - Patrick Kane (10.5)
Gustav Nyquist (.950) - Matt Duchene (6.0) - Patrick Sharp (5.9)
Jeff Skinner (5.725) - Jack Eichel (.925) - Nail Yakupov (2.5)
Curtis Lazar (.894) - Brandon Sutter (3.3) - Tom Wilson (.894)
Dylan Larkin (.925), Jamie McGinn (2.95)

Jonas Brodin (4.16) - Drew Doughty (7.0)
Morgan Rielly (.894) - Tyler Myers (5.5)
Patrick Wiercoich (2.0) - Matt Dumba (.894)
Josh Morrissey (.894)

Roberto Luongo (4.53)
John Gibson (.721)

= 79.25M


Team B: Atlanta Thrashers

James Van Riemsdyk (4.250m) - John Tavares[C] (5.5m) - Mika Zibanejad (925k)
Alex Galchenyuk (925k) - Ryan O'Reilly[A] (6m) - Jiri Hudler (4m)
Alex Tanguay (3.5m) - Tomas Plekanec (5m) - Jaromir Jagr (3.5m)
Matt Beleskey (1.350m) - Carl Soderberg (1m) - Nikolai Kulemin (4.187.5m)

Duncan Keith[A] (5,538,462m) - Brent Burns (5.760m)
Simon Despres (900k) - Tyson Barrie (2.6m)
Mattias Ekholm (1.037.5m) - Jared Spurgeon (2,666,667m)

Pekka Rinne (7m)
Andrew Hammond (1.350m)

Nacho Connoisseurs: Jarred Tinordi(870k) - Patrick Bordeleau (1m) - Artem Anisimov (3.283m)

cap: 72,143,129


Team C: Brooklyn Americans

Alex Ovechkin(9.538) - Ryan Getzlaf (8.250) -Mats Zuccarello (4.500)
Johnny Gaudreau (1.850) - Ryan Kesler (5.00) - Nikita Kucherov (0.894)
Ryan Callahan (5.800) - Kevin Hayes (3.750) - Kyle Okposo (2.800)
Michael Frolik (3.300) -Bo Horvat (1.744) - Devante Smith Pelly (.800)

Erik Johnson (3.750) - Jay Bouwmeester (5.400)
Dan Hamhuis (4.500) - Justin Faulk (4.833)
Kris Russell (2.600)-Shea Theodore (.894)

Cory Schnieder (6.00)
Scott Darling (.570)

Scratches:
Adam Lowry (0.925)
Nick Ritchie (.925)
Chris Bigras (.894)

Total Cap - $79.517


Team D: California Golden Seals

Evander Kane (5.250) - Sean Monahan (.925) - Jakub Voracek (4.250)
Jaden Schwartz (2.350) - Kyle Turris (3.500) - James Neal (5.000)
Chris Kreider (2.475) - Zemgus Girgensons (.894) - Brendan Gallagher (3.750)
Adam Henrique (4.000) - Lars Eller (3.500) - Tyler Ennis (4.600)
Max Domi (.863) - Mikko Rantanen (.950)

TJ Brodie (4.650) - Alex Pietrangelo (6.500)
Karl Alzner (2.800) - Dougie Hamilton (.894)
Danny Dekeyser (2.187) - Erik Gudbranson (2.500)
Jon Merrill (.840)

Carey Price (6.500)
Steve Mason (4.100)

Current Cap Used: 73.278


Team E: Colorado Rockies

Taylor Hall(6mil) - Nathan Mackinnon(0.925mil) - Corey Perry(8.625mil)
Marian Gaborik(4.875mil) - Patrice Bergeron(6.5mil) - Marian Hossa(5.275mil)
Alex Steen(5.8mil) - Val Filppula(5mil) - Jarome Iginla(5.333mil)
Andrew Cogliano(3mil) - Sean Couturier(1.75mil) - Carl Hagelin (2.25mil)

Andrej Sekera(2.75mil) - Erik Karlsson(6.5mil)
Olli Maata(0.894mil) - Kevin Shattenkirk(4.25mil)
Darnell Nurse(0.925mil) - Zach Bogosian (5.142mil)

Devan Dubnyk (0.800mil)
Ryan Miller(6mil)

extras:
Nik Ehlers (0.925mil)
Kerby Rychel (0.925ml)
Connor Hellebuyck

total cap $85,369,000


Team F: Hartford Whalers

Jamie Benn "A" (5.25) - Aleksander Barkov (0.925) - Blake Wheeler (5.60)
Tomas Tatar (2.75) - Derick Brassard (5.00) - Evgeny Kuznetsov (0.900)
Nino Niederreiter (2.666,667) - Nick Bjugstad (4.10) - Bryan Little (4.70)
Justin Abdelkader (1.80) - Darren Helm (2.125) - Sam Reinhart (0.925)

Cam Fowler (4.00) - Shea Weber "C" (7.857,143)
Niklas Kronwall "A" (4.75) - Jacob Trouba (0.894,167)
Trevor Daley (3.30) - Damon Severson (0.605,833)

Jonathan Quick (5.80)
Robin Lehner (2.225)

Press box: Michael Dal Colle (0.925), Scott Laughton (0.863,333), Mirco Mueller (0.894,167)

Total: $68.856,310
Cap Space: $19.143,690


Team G: Minnesota North Stars

J. Huberdeau (0.894) - L. Couture (6.000) - T. Oshie (4.175)
M. Boedker (2.55) - D. Krejci (5.250) - L. Eriksson [A] (4.25)
T. Hertl (0.925) - M. Hanzal (3.100) - D. Brown [C] (5.875)
V. Namestnikov (0.925) - C. Eakin (1.900) - R. Smith (3.425)
E. Condra (1.25) - L. Draisaitl (0.925)

V. Hedman [A] (4.000) - S. Jones (0.925)
O. Ekman-Larsson (5.500) - C. Ceci (0.894)
N. Hanifin (0.925) - A. McQuaid (1.567)
G. Reinhart (0.925)

T. Rask (7.000)
C. Pickard (0.622)

Cap Hit: $63.771 M
Cap Space: $24.229 M


Team H: Montreal Wanderers

Nick Foligno --Evgeni Malkin -- Vlad Tarasenko
Alex Killorn-- Pavel Datsyuk -- Radim Vrbata
Daniel Sedin -- Henrik Sedin -- Bobby Ryan
Marcus Johansson-- Mark Scheifele -- Anthony Mantha
Lawson Crouse -- Dylan Strome

Dmitry Kulikov -- Johnny Boychuk
Nikita Zadorov -- Dustin Byfuglien
Brooks Orpik -- Dennis Wideman
Ivan Provorov

Semyon Varlamov
Andrey Vasilevskiy

Total Cap Hit: $85,896,333


Team I: Nashville Predators

Pacioretty(4.5)-Backstrom(6.70)-Nichushkin(.925)
Parise(7.538462)- Nugent-Hopkins(6.0) - Simmonds(3.975)
Nash(7.8) - Jordan Staal(6.0) - Pastrnak (.925)
Martin(1.0) - Shaw(2.0) - Clutterbuck (2.75)

Josi(4.0) - Ekblad(.925)
Muzzin(4.0) - Ellis(2.5)
Gorges(3.9) - Klein(2.9)

F. Anderson (1.15)
Allen (.850)

Extras
Wennberg (.925)
Duclair (.7725)
Gudas (.991667)

Salary- 73.027629
Cap- 88.00
Space- 14.972371


Team J: Pittsburgh Pirates

Hartnell 4.75 - Seguin 5.75 - Forsberg .832
Lee .850 - Johnson 3.33 - Strome .863
Drouin .894 - Stastny 7.0 - Williams 3.65
Komarov 2.95 - Sheahan .950 - Fast .783

Leddy 5.5 - Carlson 3.9
Hjalmarsson 4.1 - Klingberg 4.25
Gardiner 4.05- Tanev 4.45

Nylander .925
Oleksiak .833
Petry 3.075

Bishop 5.95
Mzarek .550

Cap = 70.185


Team K: Quebec Bulldogs

Saad - Crosby - Hornqvist
Hoffman - Toews - Pavelski
Nelson - Thornton - Toffoli
Marchand - Bäcklund- C.Smith
Marner, Fiala

Giordano - Strålman
Vlasic - Vatanen
Enström - Braun
Greene

Lundqvist
Läck

Cap ~87M


Team L: Quebec Nordiques

Gabriel Landeskog(C)(5.571)-Ryan Johansen(4.00)-Jeff Carter(A)(5.273)
Sam Bennett(.925)-Connor McDavid(.925)-Jordan Eberle(6.00)
Eric Staal(A)(8.25)-Jason Spezza(7.5)-Elias Lindholm(.925)
Tanner Pearson(1.4)-Brayden Schenn(2.5)-Zack Kassian(1.75)

Hampus Lindholm(.925)-Kris Letang(7.25)
Ryan Murray(.894)-Adam Larsson(.900)
Marc Staal(5.7)-Travis Hamonic(3.857)

Braden Holtby(1.85)
Jonathan Bernier(2.9)

Extras: Derrick Pouliot(.863)-Ryan Pulock(.894)-Jake Virtanen(.925)

Cap:71.977


Team M: Vancouver Millionaires

Henrik Zetterberg (6.083) - Claude Giroux (8.275) - Phil Kessel (8.000)
Ondrej Palat (3.333) - Derek Stepan (3.075) - Mark Stone (0.873)
Milan Lucic (6.000) - Brandon Dubinsky (5.850) - Boone Jenner (0.778)
Teuvo Teravainen (0.894) - Marcus Kruger (1.325) - Jakob Silfverberg (0.850)

Ryan McDonagh (4.700) - PK Subban (9.000)
Keith Yandle (2.625) - Brent Seabrook (5.800)
Braydon Coburn (4.500) - Rasmus Ristolainen (0.925)

Sergei Bobrovsky (7.425)
Michael Hutchinson (0.575)

BMS 3rd Stringers, AKA "Special Teams Unit"
Artem Panarin (0.950)
Lance Bouma (0.775)
Oscar Klefbom (0.894)

Cap Used: 77.494 mil/88.000 mil​
 

Bender

Registered User
Sep 25, 2002
17,320
8,574
1. Quebec Bulldogs
2. Montreal Wanderers
3. Atlanta Thrashers

In my opinion.
 

member 116861

Guest
Voted for the Quebec Bulldogs. That team has nearly everything.
 

Bone Breaker

Registered User
Apr 2, 2015
1,694
908
Tokyo
imo Brooklyn - best one (specially since they have the best player in the world :P )

and Minnesota - by far the worst
 

ASmileyFace

Landeskog Replacement
Feb 13, 2014
12,156
5,731
9,318'
Bulldogs have a great team.

I don't want to seem mean.... but what in the world happened with the North Stars?
 

Tweaky

Solid #2
Sponsor
Apr 5, 2009
5,548
1,801
Singapore/Thailand
I think the North Stars was one of the ones that was trying to be more realistic....real cap, balanced team, etc. Each one of us had different ideas on how to build a team, and different goals (near term win, long term dynasty, bit of both; fantasy cap team, real cap team...which is pretty much a fantasy cap floor team, etc.).
 

tigervixxxen

Optimism=Delusional
Jul 7, 2013
53,060
6,156
Denver
burgundy-review.com
We weren't sure how quick the cap was going to come up, which is why there are a lot more ELC players than otherwise would have happened. A few teams dropped out early too, which is why Stamkos has "retired" LOL.

Montreal should get some love, I like how that team turned out. No surprise the Bulldogs are doing so well. Made use of almost all their cap plus I know whose team it is, no surprise it turned out so well.
 

PredsHabs

Registered User
Jul 9, 2013
2,474
62
Lyles,TN
I think the North Stars was one of the ones that was trying to be more realistic....real cap, balanced team, etc. Each one of us had different ideas on how to build a team, and different goals (near term win, long term dynasty, bit of both; fantasy cap team, real cap team...which is pretty much a fantasy cap floor team, etc.).

Yea, the Predators are the same way
 

PAZ

.
Jul 14, 2011
17,408
9,791
BC
I think the North Stars was one of the ones that was trying to be more realistic....real cap, balanced team, etc. Each one of us had different ideas on how to build a team, and different goals (near term win, long term dynasty, bit of both; fantasy cap team, real cap team...which is pretty much a fantasy cap floor team, etc.).

This.

Some people tried to stack the team for one season, whereas others went for long term success. Understandable why Bulldogs are easily winning, these are just my observations:

Saad, Hoffman, Toffoli, Nelson, Giordano, Vatanen, Smith and Lack would all need raises the following season.

That being said, they still have a core of Crosby and Toews down the middle. They'd definitely win the cup that year, but the following year they'd get gutted.

If I exclude my own team, my favorites are the Atlanta Flames and California Golden Seals.
 

forsbergavs32

Global Moderator
Jan 21, 2011
27,694
25,301
Fresno,CA
Mine I really went more balanced I think...my core is pretty young with a lot of upside but the depth I have is solid veterans to win now.

Definitely think the bulldogs are probably the best overall though
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad