Someone has to see that Eichel reminds a lot about a young Lemieux? Just look at the rush that created the penalty just now. He is very Lemieuxesque. He doesn't look that fast but he just outskated everyone and he doesn't look that good at deking with that long stick but just outdekes eveyrone. Just like Lemieux!
I'm a Sabres fan and have watched about all of Eichel's games so far.
The Lemieux comparison popped into my head a few games ago, before the recent onslaught of comparisons on here (or at least I didn't see them before).
I read the Eichel/Lemieux thread on the main board and there's a lot of defensiveness on there, both from the pro-argument crowd ("I'm not saying he's as good!") and the anti-argument crowd ("Lemieux/Gretzky comps should be banned!")
My comp came from my gut. It wasn't a logical decision. It just "appeared". I said "he's like a smaller Lemieux". Earlier in the year I thought Eichel was being too non-chalant. He's played several games against Tampa already and I got the feeling that he was trying to be Stamkos. This pissed me off because Eichel has just about everything Stamkos has and more. He's a far more well-rounded Stamkos. I also feel he has skills and power that Modano never had (another popular comparision). Since then he's started playing better.
Another poster said that he lacks the "eyes in the back of the head" vision that Lemieux and Gretzky had. I agree with that, although I think McDavid has that.
What Eichel does have is the Lemieux ability to slow the game down, play with zero nerves, and total patience. That patience and zero nerves quality is what all the greats had. Patience is rare in sports. Gretzky, Lemieux, Orr, Crosby, Barry Sanders, Steph Curry. Those guys have it. I don't ever remember Modano or even Stamkos having that patience.
Other posters said that Stamkos is more of an elite passenger, where Eichel is an elite driver. I agree with that too. That puts Eichel's ceiling as higher than Stamkos's. Stamkos is more like Jari Kurri.
And then there is the elite skill-set Jack has. Elite skating, elite shot, elite release, elite reach, elite ability to get his shot on net, elite passing, elite vision (although not the level of the greatest of all time), elite stickhandling. Just a total package. This man was put on earth to play hockey.
The complete skill-set package plus the patience and ability to create space is what reminds people of Lemieux. It's not a poor comparison at all. I can't think of anybody else to compare him to. He's more shoot-first than Forsberg, he's kind of similar to Jagr but not really, he seems much stronger than Federov. I like the Lemieux comp, although he lacks size and a certain intangible Lemieux had that made him LEMIEUX.