Sounds right... Whitney is only worth a type C prospect...
realistically anything more than Bart and a 4th/5th round pick would be overpayment for Whitney...But he could atleast help the PP some I'd hope, he'd also probably be paired with Chara or Seids most of the time which will help balance out his defense zone liabilities.
The Kaberle deal helped us win a cup and I don't think we can ever say that was a bad trade due to that fact alone...I do worry about either one of Dougy AND Whitney playing important minutes come playoff time though, but if Mcquaid is healthy by round 2 (if we can get past the first test) my guess is one of them (most likely hamilton) sits, barring another injury to a defenseman
Now if the rumored Boychuck for Whitney rumors are true...