Brodeur win record in the regular season or Roy win record in the playoffs?

[Frozen Lake]

You want carrying a team on your back? Patrick Roy in 1993.

Anyhow for the poll - Roy easily. As others have said, you gotta be consistent and on your game year in and year out, Nevermind the fatigue from so many deep runs. Heck, from 1996-2002 he played 17 or more games every single spring except one.

Roy also faced all of the best teams of his era in the latter half of his career.

Does Brodeur not need to be on his game year in and year out, playing through fatigue?

im a bit confused by your reasoning considering Brodeur was in more playoffs

 

[Adele Dazeem]

Roy is the better goalie for me, but Brodeur's record is much more grueling.

 

[Mickey Marner]

Roy averaged just over 8 playoff wins per year, meaning his average season ended in the conference finals. That's pretty crazy.

Modern regular season wins are a bit inflated by the elimination of ties.

 

[spiny norman]

Lopsided result.