Brady Tkachuk vs Jasperi Kotkaniemi

[BradyTkachucky]

Simple question, who is the better player now and in the future?

Click to read more...

 

[NyQuil]

Well, you can only provide on response to the poll it's going to be a bit tricky to answer two questions.

EDIT: Ah, fixed, nevermind.

I suspect this poll will be closed fairly quickly.

 

[BradyTkachucky]

Well, you can only provide on response to the poll it's going to be a bit tricky to answer two questions.

Edited, try again

 

[AvroArrow]

Brady, Brady

 

[Rhaegar Targaryen]

Brady pretty easily. Everyone knew this since Draft Day

 

[Big Empty]

Who’s Jasperi

 

[Golden_Jet]

Brady and Brady

 

[Dominance]

Pathetic attempt from top to bottom.

Voted Kotkaniemi out of spite.

 

[BradyTkachucky]

Who’s Jasperi

the guy you just voted for.

 

[Big Empty]

the guy you just voted for.

Pigeon.

 

[Mrb1p]

KK now and forever.

Better p/60 by far and just a much better 2-way playing, not even close on that part.

 

[Samsquanch]

KK now and forever.

Better p/60 by far and just a much better 2-way playing, not even close on that part.

Its posts like these that keep me coming back to Hfboards after 12 years.

Even if this is dripping in sarcasm and going over my head entirely, and its not actually a legitimate attempt to make a valid argument for KK over BT, I appreciate it all the same - and its entertainment value is first class.

If you want to believe that a lie is true and try and convince other people at the same time, there is no better weapon in a hockey debate than using a cherry picked advanced stat to nullify a mountain of real world results.

It takes some serious balls to piss in the face of reality and say that some day your predictions will tip the scale in your favour.

But it takes hard drugs/alcohol/mental impediments to pretend the answer for today isnt Brady Tkachuk. The amount of evidence for this is beyond staggering and conclusive, and you need to feel shame if you think otherwise.

 

[Mrb1p]

Its posts like these that keep me coming back to Hfboards after 12 years.

Even if this is dripping in sarcasm and going over my head entirely, and its not actually a legitimate attempt to make a valid argument for KK over BT, I appreciate it all the same - and its entertainment value is first class.

If you want to believe that a lie is true and try and convince other people at the same time, there is no better weapon in a hockey debate than using a cherry picked advanced stat to nullify a mountain of real world results.

It takes some serious balls to piss in the face of reality and say that some day your predictions will tip the scale in your favour.

But it takes hard drugs/alcohol/mental impediments to pretend the answer for today isnt Brady Tkachuk. The amount of evidence for this is beyond staggering and conclusive, and you need to feel shame if you think otherwise.

Brady plays like 5 more minutes a game and has 4 more points and hes allowed to never defend and cherry pick all game.

Chill out Ottawa fan.

 

[ole ole]

KK for now. Future ,I have no crystal ball.

 

[cudi]

I hear JK is a winger now so easily Brady

 

[Arthur Morgan]

Kidding me Montreal fans.... Brady is obviously better It's not even remotely close.

 

[Golden_Jet]

KK now and forever.

Better p/60 by far and just a much better 2-way playing, not even close on that part.

Lol

 

[smack66]

not a fan of either team and I take Tkachuk 10 out of 10 times. I can understand fans saying KK in the future as you never know how someone might develop but at present it's a no brainer. I think only die hard hab Homer's would see it any other way

 

[Erikfromfin]

I wouldn't even take two Kotkaniemis for one Tkachuk

 

[Jabba11]

Montreal fans can hate on Brady as much as we want, but the kid is a gamer. He's their next Captain. Although, I don't think he'll be a PPG or offensive juggernaut, I can see him being a very valuable part of their franchise for the rest of his career. So, I have to admit that. He is currently more impactful than KK at this time.

But, as for KK, I still think he has a lot of potential, and he's actually extremely skilled. Better skillset than Brady. But, he hasn't put everything together yet and coaches still toying with his position. Set him at center, keep him there, give him PP time, let him shoot and create. If not, we will have another Galchenyuk.

Brady better now, KK has potential to be better but will have to prove it.

 

[SpezDispenser]

Brady, not close. Now, future, wherever.

 

[jetsforever]

Tkachuk of course but this feels like a spite poll

 

[Do Make Say Think]

Brady and Brady.

Kotkaniemi is still going to be an excellent player though.

 

[DoingItCoolKiwi]

I really like Kotkaniemi and dont even think he was a bad pick at #3 but Brady has been absolutely excellent so him all day

 

[amnesiac]

Brady, Brady easily, but I dont think he'll be able to play his style for 12+ years.... it catches up