We've won the hardest division in hockey before while actively engaging from the blueline. The complete disappearance of the offense can in some ways be traced to a terrible transition game that's getting exposed. Forwards fly the zone, and have consistently all year. That puts more stress on the D to skate the puck out and evade the forecheck, something Shatty and Pietro seem to be the only ones capable of. Like I said, I get it.....but all things being equal, you still have a coach playing two slow footed defensemen against a speedy team, even if we should respect their transition speed. It works both ways in my view. You can't put it all on the forwards for backside pressure when the D passively allow the other team to enter the zone. That's more ice to cover, and the Wild (or every other team this season) are already in good scoring positions.
The neutral zone is key. So I'm not entirely sure why there's such a gap between our forechecking forwards and our D if we're getting killed over 50 feet of ice. I take your point about the first touches, and that's absolutely an issue that's been raised and discussed repeatedly. Bouwmeester looks rickety, like he hasn't fully recovered from his groin injury. You can see it with his exits. He's just pushing the puck up the wall to get a tip at the red line. Shatty's getting pressured hard-Pietro (as you identified) is the only one capable of accurate break out passes. That's wrecking us.
This is my axe to grind. I can't stand it, and I feel crazy for it. We changed the way we broke out mid-way through '13-14 and we were less explosive in transition because of it. Tarasenko's individual efforts, Schwartz and occasionally Steen have masked the issues that, to me, have been building for a while now. Our passing has been atrocious lately.
Gauging opinion here, but have you really felt confident against the Central this season? We had a +1 goal differential and largely beat up on the Avs. I don't want to diminish the wins, but it's not like we controlled play against the Jets, Hawks, or Preds to any discernible degree. Take a look:
http://blues.nhl.com/club/teamvsteam.htm. The Wild may be a fast team but we make nearly every opponent look fast. We're a skilled team, more so than in recent years, and we did a lot winning this season because of it. We've also done it with the look of a less cohesive five man unit and a less effective defense.