Not to mention the Jays have at least produced some players who became regulars which automatically makes them better then the Leafs. Who was the last Halladay the leafs had that was home grown?
Halladay was the 90s. Jays did a great job in the 90s. Green, Stewart, Koch, Halladay, Carpenter, Wells, Rios, Michael Young (sigh). A lot of those guys mentioned were mainstays with the Jays after their glory years, then you add Delgado who was signed (though that was the 80s).
Lind, Stroman, Hutch, Janssen, McGowan, Cecil and probably a couple more I'm forgetting, but basically the core of the team is all trades and free agents.
Yes, they were great trades (some better than others), pickups, signings or whatever. And its good to be successful in those areas. But if they could develop a bit more of their own talent, that would help a lot.
When was the last time there was high excitement for a big prospect? (Lawrie and Gose don't count). Sanchez is one. But really, no one for me since Wells, Rios and Hill. Snider maybe.
I know having a haul like the 09 Cardinals (Miller, Kelly, Carpenter, Rosenthal, Adams) is rare, but it would be nice to pluck and/or develop a stud here and there.