Well every year you have the chance to miss the playoffs by just that much, would fans rather be Edmonton and pick first every year but always suck?
Edit: we aren't bad enough for McEichel, and we've been picking 5 - 10 for years and it gets us no where, I want to make the playoffs instead of drafting a kid who will be an impact for us in 5 years.
Edmonton doesn't want to be Edmonton where they pick first and always suck. People constantly forget the second part of this equation: after the 1st round how does Edmonton draft? Not very well. Does Edmonton support their draft picks with support structure so the kids can earn their way through the line up? No, not really? Does Edmonton have good goaltending, so where you still lose more than you win - you're in it well? Weeeehhhhheeell?
if our stable is full of players that are great for support and developing well (but not predicted to do anything special), this means, the organziation is lacking picking the draft picks positions that have the potential to be the #1 centre, #1 Defensemen that this organization needs. the likihood of getting them is between draft picks 1-10. (in "weak" drafts, it's usually 1-5, but in suspected deep drafts such as this one, and next years, 1-10 and good scouting gets that).
I want playoffs more than anything, and I 100 percent feel that struggling to make the playoffs/1st round exits are a part of development, however in this case it will be more detrimental than beneficial in this case, because I personally feel that a good chunk of this team needs to be broken up simply because of the mindset and attitude that seems to whiff from the team. a #1 C /D will not help with the complacency or any of the other myriad of problems that they suffer from. And I'd rather start putting pieces to develop a great program so we're constantly contending (and not just because we're in the East, but we've got a legitimate shot) vs: we can make the playoffs and it's "thanks for showing up, excuse us as we steamroll right by you."
Sometimes the notion of "I want this NOW vs. waiting for 5 years" is what holds us back. I'd rather take the bitter now (Not making it) and having a long legacy of success later vs. squeaking in and we still have the multitude of issues. Just because the team was winning doesn't mean they were a good team.