Better Rookie DMan

[Patagonia]

A select few Ranger fans believe Fox is a close comparable or slightly better than either Makar or QHughes.

They believe stats are irrelevant and player intangibles are being ignored in the comparison.

Which player would you consider the better young DMan?

Click to read more...

 

[Skinnyjimmy08]

RIGHT NOW its Makar and it is not even close at all. and I capitalize RIGHT NOW cause I can see these 3 flipping around a lot throughout the year and in future seasons. All 3 are very special but Makar is playing like one of the best dmen in the league, let alone out of fellow rookies

 

[aufheben]

Really making a poll because 1% of our fan base thinks this?

 

[bandwagonesque]

Really making a poll because 1% of our fan base thinks this?

Nope. Making a poll because he insisted everyone else was wrong/arguing in bad faith and refused to make one himself. This isn't an attempt to smear Rangers fans. As far as I know, he's an army of one.

 

[Bgav]

Makar
Hughes
Fox

 

[Cucumber]

Maker now
Hughes has more protential imo.

 

[NyQuil]

Yikes.

 

[Filthy Dangles]

.

 

[HockeyDBspecialist]

why is Fox even in the conversation ?

 

[Patagonia]

Nope. Making a poll because he insisted everyone else was wrong/arguing in bad faith and refused to make one himself. This isn't an attempt to smear Rangers fans. As far as I know, he's an army of one.

Actually, there were 2 Ranger fans adamant Fox is comparable and might be better. They're extremely under rated regardless of the stats. Trying to measure the opinions including NYR fans which we believe most would agree Fox might be good, but not better than either Makar or Hughes.

 

[GhostfaceWu]

Maker now
Hughes has more protential imo.

Says nobody.

 

[KirkAlbuquerque]

awesome petty poll to get back at one poster

 

[bigdog16]

Yeah this is dumb

 

[The Crypto Guy]

Really making a poll because 1% of our fan base thinks this?

The sad thing is, I don't even think 1% of our fan base thinks this.

 

[Pavel Buchnevich]

Nope. Making a poll because he insisted everyone else was wrong/arguing in bad faith and refused to make one himself. This isn't an attempt to smear Rangers fans. As far as I know, he's an army of one.

Just so we can get this clear, so this person stops spreading misinformation, @bandwagonesque is unable to read or is deliberately lying about what has been said. It's one or the other. And what's clear from the discussion about these players is that @bandwagonesque likes making big and untrue proclamations that when asked to back up, he clams up and refuses to back up.

As to the poll that @Patagonia put up, it's a good question. Makar will probably finish the highest in the Calder voting due to the circumstances of this season. How they would do on the same team with the same opportunity for success is hard to tell. Apparently thats too much for @Patagonia because he's an offended Avalanche fan. He's been doing this for days now. He can't handle anything other than believing exactly what he believes. Seeing someone voice a slightly different opinion than him was too much to handle that he needed to put up a meaningless poll that we all know what the results will be.

 

[Sasso09]

Just so we can get this clear, so this person stops spreading misinformation, @bandwagonesque is unable to read or is deliberately lying about what has been said. It's one or the other. And what's clear from the discussion about these players is that @bandwagonesque likes making big and untrue proclamations that when asked to back up, he clams up and refuses to back up.

As to the poll that @Patagonia put up, it's a good question. Makar will probably finish the highest in the Calder voting due to the circumstances of this season. How they would do on the same team with the same opportunity for success is hard to tell. Apparently thats too much for @Patagonia because he's an offended Avalanche fan. He's been doing this for days now. He can't handle anything other than believing exactly what he believes. Seeing someone voice a slightly different opinion than him was too much to handle that he needed to put up a meaningless poll that we all know what the results will be.

At the end of the day you still tried comparing Fox to Makar.....

 

[Pavel Buchnevich]

At the end of the day you still tried comparing Fox to Makar.....

What's your point? Can I not have a different opinion?

 

[Future GOAT]

Right now it's Makar by a very significant margin.

 

[spiny norman]

The lopsided result arrived quickly.