Eh, the present day Sharks are good, but not nearly the best team ever in this position. There really is only one Hall of Famer, in his prime, on the roster, and that's Joe Thornton. Rob Blake is going to be in the Hall, but trust me, he's not quite in his prime anymore.
I'll vote for the 1992-93 Pittsburgh Penguins. They had Mario at his very, very best, Jagr was becoming a superstar, and the same team that had won the last two Stanley Cups. Damn you, David Volek, for screwing up a Lemieux vs. Roy Conference Finals. That said, I still think the Habs win, because Patrick Roy was simply not going to let them lose that year.