AVs Top 25 Under 25 and/or Born From 1994

[Patagonia]

Team continues to get younger and more difficult to rank their best young players under the age of 25 or born from 1994. Here is my opinion on the player rankings.

MacKinnon (C)
Rantanen (RW)
Makar (D)
Byram (D)
Girard (D)
Newhook (C)
Kaut (RW)
Timmins (D)
Jost (C/LW)
Zadorov (D)

Bowers (C)
Kamenev (C/LW)
Helleson (D)
Compher (W/C)
Burakovsky (LW/RW)
Kerfoot (C/LW)
Greer (LW)
Meloche (D)
Saigeon (C)
Graves (D)

Henry (RW)
Lewis (LW)
Werner (G)
Mutala (RW)
Kovalenko (RW)

Click to read more...

 

[CB Joe]

Compher seems really low. Same with Burakovsky and Kerfoot.

 

[Grackle Party]

I dont know how you can rate Helleson above anyone that plays in the NHL.

The Byram, Timmins, Kaut and Newhook rankings are troubling for similar reasons

 

[TruePowerSlave]

Its a really exiting group, possibly the best in the league

 

[Patagonia]

I dont know how you can rate Helleson above anyone that plays in the NHL.

The Byram, Timmins, Kaut and Newhook rankings are troubling for similar reasons

I used the trade value and potential.

Would you seriously believe anyone would accept 1 for 1: Compher, Kerfoot or Kamenev for any of the players in the Top 10?

 

[avsfan09]

I used the trade value and potential.

Would you seriously believe anyone would accept 1 for 1: Compher, Kerfoot or Kamenev for any of the players in the Top 10?

I like Compher over Kaut. Unless Kaut takes a big step this season.

 

[Ceremony]

Please explain how Timmins is better than, has more value than, or has more potential than Zadorov.

 

[Ivan13]

I dont know how you can rate Helleson above anyone that plays in the NHL.

The Byram, Timmins, Kaut and Newhook rankings are troubling for similar reasons

This is the same guy who said Avs 2nd round this past draft was horrible.

 

[Wintersun]

I'd go

1. MacKinnon
2. Rantanen
3. Makar
4. Byram
5. Girard
6. Jost
7. Compher
8. Newhook
9. Zadorov
10. Timmins
11. Kaut
12. Bowers
13. Kerfoot
14. Burakovsky
15. Kamenev
16. Meloche
17. Greer
18. Henry
19. Helleson
20. Werner
21. Kovalenko
22. Beaucage
23. Mutala
24. Lewis
25. Shvyryov

 

[MarkT]

I think you guys should set a clear definition of "best" here or this will just devolve into pointless arguments. Are you using current best, as in who would be the best player on an NHL roster? Are you using highest potential? Are you using trade value? If you don't set the parameters these lists will not be measuring the same thing and you'll never reach a consensus.