It is times such as these that I miss
@Richard88 with his Cap Friendly skills. No trade nor player exists in a vacuum. HF tends to oversimplify situations and nowhere is that more obvious than in discussions of Byram / Toews.
Money - At $3.75M per year, Byram is not a bad deal. That said, if he starts playing to his draft day potential he is going to want to get paid, and some team is bound to offer him $7 if he pans out during this 2-year contract.
Position - I am reasonably sure that Bo sees himself as a top pair, if not a 1D. He was never going to get 1D with the Avs, and the second the ink dried on Toews' extension, Bo's chances for top pair all but evaporated. Similarly, he was never going to get PP1, and the Avs second unit rarely gets more than 30 seconds of action. Bo could / should find a home where he runs PP1, is top pair and.......
Bednar's system - While Bednar's architecture allows either defenseman to activate, each pair really needs a puck-moving defenseman and a guy more comfortable staying at home. Pairing Byram with Makar gives you two guys, on the same line, who want to fly through traffic. That is not ideal.
Other contracts - Mikko and Georgie need new contracts for the same season Byram does. Landy might ( I personally think not) come back during Byram's contract, eating a ton of cap space. The cap is increasing, but not by some astronomical amount. If Byram fulfills his potential, he will be looking to double ( another $3.75M) his current AAV.
If Byram gets his act together, and is comparable to a $7.5 AAV player, where does the money come from? Someone is going to have to get traded. Is it Byram? Toews? Mikko? Nuke? Getting a quality 2C might require two of those players to be shipped out. (OK, OK, or Girard!) Regardless, the checkbook cannot withstand
Makar - $9M
Toews - $7.25M
Byram - $7.25M
Girard - $5M
Manson $4.25M
Malinski / JMFJ - $1M
That is $33M+ for 6 defensemen, which is unsustainable with the current cap. So whether we at HF like it or not, if we want a 2C of any caliber, one or two of the players mentioned above have to go. Considering the 4 areas discussed, it makes the most sense to trade Byram+ for a 2C with some term and cost control. FTR, I do not have a specific target in mind whom Cmac could pick up easily. The Avs might have to be the anchor for a blockbuster and move Ryjo, Byram, Girard, Lehky and maybe even Nuke. Manson has a NMC so he is staying. Landy will retire as an Av, so he is off the trade bait list. Yes, that qualifies as a retool, but SakMac bought themselves these problems by overpaying a number of players, including Landy.