Larry Robinson vs. Earl Seibert, Slight advantage Nova Scotia
This is a very close call between two pretty good number 1's in an ATD context. Both are very good both ways, both can hit hard, and both can scrap with the best of them. I think Robinson may be a step ahead of Seibert defensively, but both guys are about as reliable as they come. Look for an absolute blood-bath of a fight if they decide to throw down as well.
Ken Reardon vs. Hod Stuart, Slight advantage Nova Scotia
Another close call between top end number 2's. They play very similar games, as both were known as hard hitters who were solid defensively, who could pull of some great rushes offensively. Both guys are in the hall as well. It's hard for me to find much info on Stuart, as there isn't much about him online, which is why I gave Reardon the slight advantage. Definitely debatable though.
Jean-Guy Talbot vs. Lionel Hitchman, Advantage Nova Scotia
Two hard-hitting guys who played for keeps, Hitchman is best known for setting an NHL record for PIMs for his time. He was a mean SOB, and very tough to play against, who could also be a very effective leader. However, he provided almost nothing offensively. Talbot was a guy, although not recognized as a star player, who was good at almost every aspect of the game. He was an excellent passer, provided rock-solid defense, and was well liked by his teammates. There may be a slight gap physically and defensively between the two, but Talbot's huge advantage in offense and puck-handling ability gives him the overall advantage here.
Ted Green vs. Flash Hollett, Slight advantage Canada
Two vastly different hockey players, Hollett was very well known for his offensive prowess and hockey sense, while Green was a stay at home defender, who hit like a truck and was tough to play against. Green has a big advantage defensively and physically, but Hollett was possibly the best offensive defenseman of his time, which has to be recognised. Still, while Hollett is on the ice, Nova Scotia will be looking for some soft dump-in's into his corner, if you know what I mean.
Alexander Gusev vs. Ted Harris, Slight advantage Canada
I'm a big Ted Harris fan. The guy was as tough as they come and looks great on a third pairing in an ATD. However, like Hitchman on the second line, he provides next to nothing offensively. Gusev was a big, lumbering defender with a huge shot. He was known for his defensive prowess, however he chipped in offensively as well, with a decent transition game and as I said, a big slapper. However, he was known for struggling against quicker forwards and for a bad turnover every now and then, which is why I gave Teddy the slight advantage.
Hamby Shore against Andrei Markov, Slight advantage Nova Scotia
Both men are recognized as two of the top defenseman of their time. Both are great both ways, partiularly in the offensive zone. They can defend pretty well, help on the transition, and skate with most anyone in the league. However, Shore was known as a pretty tough player as well, who could throw a pretty good hit every now and then. Markov's physical game is, well, lacking. I think that Markov could struggle against Nova Scotia's second and fourth lines, who have guys on there who hit to hurt, where as I trust Shore out there against any one of Canada's lines. Slight advantage comes from that.
Overall, Advantage Nova Scotia
With an advantage and three slight advantages, Nova Scotia's defensive squad is a step above the SS. Canada has a strong first pairing, with their 1 and 2 guys matching up with each other, but after that, you see the typical defensive defender with offensive defender. Nova Scotia has a solid mix of two way players all around, particularly in the defensive zone. A big advantage on the second pairing and a small one on the third more than make up for a slight disadvantage on the first pairing for the Voyageurs.