with all due respect mister lou, backlund is a much better player than smith. maybe the numbers don't tell you that story, but this guy is a stud in his own zone. and he's a center. shorthanded threat and i think the best is still yet to come with him offensively. don't see an upside past 60 points, but what he gives you in all 3 zones is a much better player than reilly smith.
$3.5 per for Smith is still a bad deal. So yes...
The only bad thing about his contract is that it is only for 1y. Chiarelli should have bought low with his off year and get a 3y deal at that money. Now, if he gets back to his rookie 20g-50pts type of season, he will be able to ask for more than 3.4M on his next deal.
Smith's contract is 2 years.
Smith could easily play PK in this league as well... Hopefully he is given the shot this year.
Backlund is awful on face-offs, and admittedly takes the body better than Smith, but Smith hits as much, blocks as much ... Backlund is a puck hound defensively..I'd still take Smith over him easily.
The backlund deal might not be relevent to smith but i think it helps put chris kelly into perspective. Defensive sound centers with leadership get 3 mill even if they do average under 15 goals and 35 points. I can show at least 10 teams that have paid chris kelly level centers this type of money.
One can argue is any 3rd liner should be getting 3 mill but one cant argue that we over paid kelly market value. In fact i dont see a single contract on our team that i believe is above market value.
Our cap issue is because we won... not because we overpaid
Smith's contract is 2 years.
Oups. Thought both Krug and him signed for 1y. Makes it a better deal then.
Why exactly?
Smith is soft and one dimensional. When he's not scoring he's completely useless.
Backlund doesn't need to score to be effective. He's everything a defensive center should be but he can put the puck in the net. When he finally got healthy and Hartley took over he finally turned the corner.
Seems to me you're reading a stat line and haven't watched him play a ton I you'd take Reilly over him. Could be wrong but that's my feeling.
I don't care about other teams. Let them do what they want. I'm pissed that OUR team gave him that contract.
Reilly Smith will never have to buy himself a beer. He set the market for all of the young and semi-proven players in the league. I bet Backlund said "Look at what Reilly Smith got. Why can't I have that?" And it ain't because he's a good player on a great team anymore.