Toggle sidebar

Anthony Stewart vs. Nathan Horton

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dropkick Alex

Registered User
Jan 30, 2004
4,223
0
Amherst, New York
As a Panthers fan Horton if he stays healthy could be an amazing player. Stewart needs to improve his shot but he could be a solid player aswell, kind of glad we have both ;)
 

Porn*

Registered User
Mar 6, 2002
36,386
5
In your nightmares
Nathan Frickin Horton... I can't wait til this guy owns the league. HE has the potential to be one of the elite PF in the game... ala bertuzzi.

hopefully he can stay healthy :( he's easilly one of my fav prospects/players in the league.
 

HuskyFlames

Registered User
Jan 12, 2004
4,671
0
I think Horton has more raw skill and at this age is better (more developed). If Stewart can work on his game and get up there, I think he could be a future Eric Cole type player with a bit more offense.
 

Corey

Guest
Horton. I'd trade Ribeiro or Patrice Bergeron for him in an instant.
 
Blind Gardien

Blind Gardien

nexus of the crisis
Apr 2, 2004
20,537
0
Four Winds Bar
A couple years ago after Stewart's first WJC maybe it would have been a closer debate, but right now everybody is going to say Horton. Stewart basically floated through his season in the OHL this year and really turned a lot of people off. The complacency wasn't a good sign, but you know how it is with prospects, we tend to get too high from the highs, and then too low with the lows... Stewart isn't as bad a prospect as he looked at times this year, and perhaps he'll get his game back on track with a switch to the demands of being a pro. Another injury to Horton and a rebound from Stewart and maybe the poll will swing the opposite way next year. But right now, only members of Stewart's immediate family would take him ahead of Horton.
 

Form and Substance

Registered User
Jun 11, 2004
5,670
0
Blind Gardien said:
A couple years ago after Stewart's first WJC maybe it would have been a closer debate, but right now everybody is going to say Horton. Stewart basically floated through his season in the OHL this year and really turned a lot of people off. The complacency wasn't a good sign, but you know how it is with prospects, we tend to get too high from the highs, and then too low with the lows... Stewart isn't as bad a prospect as he looked at times this year, and perhaps he'll get his game back on track with a switch to the demands of being a pro. Another injury to Horton and a rebound from Stewart and maybe the poll will swing the opposite way next year. But right now, only members of Stewart's immediate family would take him ahead of Horton.
Click to expand...

He must come from a very multi-cultural, diverse family! Just joking, I take Horton in a heartbeat, mind you his injury problems scare the crap out of me.
 

Mr.Brownov*

Guest
I'm going with the majority here.Mr.Horton has the more potential
 

pucks1

Registered User
Apr 23, 2004
723
0
Blind Gardien said:
A couple years ago after Stewart's first WJC maybe it would have been a closer debate, but right now everybody is going to say Horton. Stewart basically floated through his season in the OHL this year and really turned a lot of people off. The complacency wasn't a good sign, but you know how it is with prospects, we tend to get too high from the highs, and then too low with the lows... Stewart isn't as bad a prospect as he looked at times this year, and perhaps he'll get his game back on track with a switch to the demands of being a pro. Another injury to Horton and a rebound from Stewart and maybe the poll will swing the opposite way next year. But right now, only members of Stewart's immediate family would take him ahead of Horton.
Click to expand...
Im not apart of his fam and im going to take him. I live in fla and have seen every camp and scrimmage game with these players. The first year at Rookie camp Stewart was an absolute beast ( a man among boys). He was very powerful and hit everything that moved, and he was fast with a nice scoring touch! Horton was good to but that year i'd give the edge to Stewart, even though Horton made the team. Since then i think Horton has grown into a better player from being with the panthers. In Stewarts 2nd rookie camp he looked pissed because none of the prospects on his team could play wroth s*** ( he couldn’t get a clean pass all game).Their were many times when he would be wide open and calling for the puck and his teammates would try and make some crazy deke and loose the puck( Stewart would shake his head and slam his stick out of frustration). The only other player on the ice that looked close to Stewart was Olez but he was nothing great. I truly believe when Stewart makes the big show, his drive will be back and he will be a bigger impact player than Horton.
 

AgentNaslund*

Guest
Horton easily. Potential number 1 centerman He has the Jarome Iginla type of style to him. He can skate, has a crazy slap shot, he hits, he fights. Nathan Horton. He was drafted number 3 for a reason.
 

pucks1

Registered User
Apr 23, 2004
723
0
AgentNaslund said:
Horton easily. Potential number 1 centerman He has the Jarome Iginla type of style to him. He can skate, has a crazy slap shot, he hits, he fights. Nathan Horton. He was drafted number 3 for a reason.
Click to expand...
Ya, but Stewart can skate, has a slap shot and can fight aswell ( ask Horton, Stewart broke his jaw in a fight the year before they drafted).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Latest posts

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom