Another Rate my Draft

[Qubax]

My team is the bolded Calgary team, I had quite a few picks. How did it go?

Thanks!

Round 1

1. MTL - Ryan Nugent-Hopkins C EDM
2. VAN - Jonathan Huberdeau C/W FLA
3. CGY - Ryan Murphy D CAR
4. VAN - Gabriel Landeskog LW COL
5. CHI - Sean Couturier C PHI
6. NYR - Ryan Strome C NYI
7. PIT - Adam Larsson D NJ
8. EDM - Dougie Hamilton D BOS
9. CGY - Mark Scheifele C WPG
10. PHX - Mika Zibanejad C OTT
11. CGY - Sven Baertschi W CGY
12. CGY - Rocco Grimaldi C FLA
13. BUF - Duncan Siemens D COL
14. PHI - Joel Armia W BUF

Round 2

15. CGY - Matt Puempel LW OTT
16. NYR - Mark McNeill C CHI
17. CGY - Magnus Hellberg G NSH
18. CHI - Chris Gibson G LAK
19. CHI -John Gibson G ANA
20. NYR - Alexander Khokhlachev F BOS
21. ANA - Nicklas Jensen W VAN
22. CGY -Nathan Beaulieu D MTL
23. PHI -Samu Perhonen G EDM
24. ANA - Tomas Jurco W DET
25. CHI - Jamie Oleksiak D DAL
26. PIT -Ty Rattie W STL
27. ANA - Vladislav Namestnikov C TBL
28. ANA - Zack Phillips C MIN

Round 3

29. PHX -Joe Morrow D PIT
30. CGY -Ryan Sproul D DET
31. CGY -Stefan Noesen F OTT
32. BUF -Phillip Danault C CHI
33. CHI - Tyler Biggs W TOR
34. NYR - Nikita Kucherov W TBL
35. ANA - Brandon Saad F CHI
36. MTL - Oscar Klefbom D EDM
37. NYI - Connor Murphy D PHX
38. CGY - Jonas Brodin D MIN
39. BUF - Boone Jenner C CBJ
40. CGY - Daniel Catenacci F BUF
41. BUF - Brett Ritchie F DAL
42. ANA - Jean-Gabriel Pageau F OTT

Round 4

43. MTL - Jordan Binnington G STL
44. NYI - Lucas Lessio F PHX
45. DET -J T Miller C NYR
46. MTL - Adam Clendening D CHI
47. NYR - Shane Prince C/LW OTT
48. CAL - Reid Boucher F NJD
49. MTL - Dimitri Jaskin RW STL
50. CAL - Adam Lowry F WPG
51. DET - Victor Rask C CAR
52. PHX - Michel St Croix F NYR
53. BUF -Rasmus Bengtsson D FLA
54. ANA -Mattias Backman D DET
55. VAN -Johan Mattson G CHI
56. EDM - Xavier Ouellet D DET

Round 5

57. CHI - Mario Lucia F MIN
58. MTL -Matt Mahalak G CAR
59. NYI - Johan Sundstrom F NYI
60. BUF - David Honzik G VAN
61. CHI - Markus Granlund F CGY
62. NYR - Brendan Kichton D NYI
63. NYR - Matthew Nieto F SJS
64. TOR - Blake Coleman C NJ
65. ANA - Scott Mayfield D NYI
66. PHX -Shane McColgan - F - NYR
67. TOR -Alexei Marchenko Det
68. PHI -Steffen Soberg G WSH
69. PHI -Lars Volden G BOS
70. NYR -Laurent Brossoit - G - CAL

Click to read more...

 

[GREENs Guardian]

Murphy too high, Grimaldi that high is honestly just atrocious, Mcneil is soooooo much better. Gibson was/is the best goalie to come out of the draft, dont understand the Hellberg pick, and i cant believe Rask was available at 50 and you passed on him, i would take him over Grimaldi any day.

 

[Qubax]

Murphy too high, Grimaldi that high is honestly just atrocious, Mcneil is soooooo much better. Gibson was/is the best goalie to come out of the draft, dont understand the Hellberg pick, and i cant believe Rask was available at 50 and you passed on him, i would take him over Grimaldi any day.

Hmm, thanks for the input. Yah, admitedly I was higher on Murphy and Grimaldi in a fantasy pool set up then most others. Certainly a little boom and bust with those picks.

 

[HabsFanFromOntario]

I don't think the Grimaldi pick that high is atrocious as he should be an excellent player with Huberdeau. I'd just have preferred Joel Armia. What kind of league is this

 

[R S]

Murphy too high, Grimaldi that high is honestly just atrocious, Mcneil is soooooo much better. Gibson was/is the best goalie to come out of the draft, dont understand the Hellberg pick, and i cant believe Rask was available at 50 and you passed on him, i would take him over Grimaldi any day.

Little harsh. Everyone has their own opinions, and I don't agree with alot of what you say here.

I agree that Murphy might be a bit high, but that really depends on team needs.

Gibson-Hellberg is a toss up.

Grimadli over Rask is a no brainer for me, I take Rocco.

 

[Qubax]

I don't think the Grimaldi pick that high is atrocious as he should be an excellent player with Huberdeau. I'd just have preferred Joel Armia. What kind of league is this

Forwards/Defensemen Stat Categories: Goals (G), Assists (A), Points (P), Plus/Minus (+/-), Penalty Minutes (PIM), Game-Winning Goals (GWG)
Goaltenders Stat Categories: Wins (W), Goals Against Average (GAA), Save Percentage (SV%), Shutouts (SHO)

Head to Head

 

[JumpierPegasus]

Murphy too high, Grimaldi that high is honestly just atrocious, Mcneil is soooooo much better. Gibson was/is the best goalie to come out of the draft, dont understand the Hellberg pick, and i cant believe Rask was available at 50 and you passed on him, i would take him over Grimaldi any day.

I don't really get this post... constructive critisism is nice...

Anyway... I guess if you need a defender take Murphy, but seemed a litt high.

Rest is good... Brodin at 50 is insane!

 

[HoshiBlitz]

Could've done better in the first round. But overall pretty solid.

 

[Dutchy]

Larsson 7th???

 

[Qubax]

Larsson 7th???

In real life Larsson would almost always go 1 through 4, but in Fantasy where offence is the primary concern, this is actually not THAT surprising.

I mean Larsson went 4th in real life 7th here..

Brodin 10th in real life and 38th here

and I took Murphy 3rd(albeit maybe too high, but I couldn't easily move into the 5th,6th slots) and he went 12th.

So Fantasy drafts geared for offense are different then traditional NHL Mocks

 

[Qubax]

I don't really get this post... constructive critisism is nice...

Anyway... I guess if you need a defender take Murphy, but seemed a litt high.

Rest is good... Brodin at 50 is insane!

I actually took Brodin at 38, but still pretty happy with him there...

He honestly hadn't been on my radar, but once we hit about pick 30 I looked at him a little closer...and when I really digged it seemed I would have been comfortable taking him between 15-20, so getting him at 38 seemed like a major coo....

He just seemed to be falling like traditional non-flashy defensive dmen, but when you look into Brodin this isn't Jarred Tinordi or Teubert....

Brodin's got some upside, just really raw

 

[Dutchy]

In real life Larsson would almost always go 1 through 4, but in Fantasy where offence is the primary concern, this is actually not THAT surprising.

I mean Larsson went 4th in real life 7th here..

Brodin 10th in real life and 38th here

and I took Murphy 3rd(albeit maybe too high, but I couldn't easily move into the 5th,6th slots) and he went 12th.

So Fantasy drafts geared for offense are different then traditional NHL Mocks

The Fantasy league I currently a part of works with a simulator (STHS), so you do have to take into account the defensive ability of your roster. I guess I forgot Yahoo style fantasy leagues. When points are the only thing that matter, Larsson would take a nose dive.

 

[DaFranzenator]

Best Mock draft I"ve seen so far.

Detroit's actual haul from your top 70 is real NICE!!

Jurco, Sproul, Backstrom, Ouellet and Marchenko.