Prospect Info: Annual Detroit Red Wing Prospect Poll - #16

[Henkka]

So I'll take the torch...


1. Simon Edvinsson - LD
2. Marco Kasper - C
3. Jonatan Berggren - W
4. Sebastian Cossa - G
5. Elmer Soderblom - W
6. Albert Johansson - D
7. Carter Mazur - W
8. William Wallinder - LD
9. Dmitri Buchelnikov - W
10. Donovan Sebrango - LD
11. Shai Buium - LD
12. Theodor Niederbach - C/RW
13. Dylan James - W
14. Liam Dower-Nilsson - C/LW
15. Cross Hanas - W

Added three guys who are imo, the last ones worth to add. Plandowski, Tyutyayev and Barton.

Click to read more...

 

[OgeeOgelthorpe]

So I'll take the torch...


1. Simon Edvinsson - LD
2. Marco Kasper - C
3. Jonatan Berggren - W
4. Sebastian Cossa - G
5. Elmer Soderblom - W
6. Albert Johansson - D
7. Carter Mazur - W
8. William Wallinder - LD
9. Dmitri Buchelnikov - W
10. Donovan Sebrango - LD
11. Shai Buium - LD
12. Theodor Niederbach - C/RW
13. Dylan James - W
14. Liam Dower-Nilsson - C/LW
15. Cross Hanas - W

Added three guys who are imo, the last ones worth to add. Plandowski, Tyutyayev and Barton.

Thanks for taking the lead on this one.

I'm going with Viro here. I don't think he's going to be a world beater in the NHL but I think he can become a 6th/7th defender that doesn't cock things up.

 

[Frk It]

I suppose I'll go Viro, although I expect McIsaac to have a bigger role and be a better player for Grand Rapids this year. Then again, he is 2 years older, so I guess that makes sense.

I would like to see McIsaac get a game or two with the big club this year, just to see how he fares. But not sure that happens with the # of defenseman we have.

 

[jaster]

Ya'll are sleeping on Red MFing Savage!

Ok, you aren't, we're way too low on the list for any of these kids to be slept on. But Savage is my pick here.

Snap into a 4th-liner!

 

[norrisnick]

Black Hole for life!

At some point not being impressive in any way becomes impressive! Neutralize everything!

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Eemil Viro is my pick.

 

[simonedvinsson]

It's interesting to compare where we ranked these guys last year prior to graduations of Seider, Raymond, and Veleno:

10 Eemil Viro
11 Antti Tuomisto
15 Kirill Tyutyayev
16 Robert Mastrosimone
17 Jared McIsaac

I still have a unrealistically high expectations for Tyutya, so he gets my vote here.

 

[OgeeOgelthorpe]

It's interesting to compare where we ranked these guys last year prior to graduations of Seider, Raymond, and Veleno:

10 Eemil Viro
11 Antti Tuomisto
15 Kirill Tyutyayev
16 Robert Mastrosimone
17 Jared McIsaac

I still have a unrealistically high expectations for Tyutya, so he gets my vote here.

I'd be interested to compare last year's results after the draft to this year. Do you have them on hand or are we digging?

 

[simonedvinsson]

I'd be interested to compare last year's results after the draft to this year. Do you have them on hand or are we digging?

From this thread:

01.) Moritz Seider - RD - 20: 6'4" 207 lbs - RH Shot - Zell, GER - 96.2%
02.) Lucas Raymond - LW/RW - 19: 5'10"183 lbs - RH Shot - Goteborg, SWE - 85.1%
03.) Simon Edvinsson - LD - 18: 6'5" 207 lbs - LH Shot - Onsala, SWE - 70.1%
04.) Sebastian Cossa - G - 18: 6'6'' 212 lbs - LC catching glove - Fort McMurray, AL, CAN - 47.8%
05.) Jonatan Berggren - LW/RW- 21: 5'11'' 183 lbs - LH Shot - Uppsala, SWE - 75.5%
06.) Joe Veleno - C - 21: 6'1'' 194 lbs - LH Shot - Kirkland, QC, CAN - 69.1%
07.) Albert Johansson - D - 20: 6' 168 lbs - LH shot - Karistad, SWE - 85.5%
08.) Theodor Niederbach - C - 19: 5'11'' 172 lbs - RH shot - Örnsköldsvik, SWE - 36%
09.) Shai Buium - D - 18: 6'3'' 216 lbs - LH shot - San Diego, USA - 31.7%
10.) Eemil Viro - D - 19: 6' 165 lbs - LH shot - Vantaa, FIN - 24% (runoff 59.8%)
11.) Antti Tuomisto - D - 20: 6'5'' 205 lbs - RH shot - Pori, FIN - 32.4%
12.) William Wallinder - D - 19: 6'4'' 190 lbs - LH shot - Sollefteå, SWE - 32.7%
13.) Donovan Sebrango - D - 19: 6'1'' 190 lbs - LH shot - Ottawa, ON, CAN - 35.1%
14.) Elmer Soderblom - F - 20: 6'8'' 239 lbs - LH shot - Göteborg, SWE - 36%
15.) Kirill Tyutyayev - F - 21: 5'9'' 146 lbs - LH shot - Yekaterinburg, RUS - 39.1%

As far as I can tell, this was the last vote. Mastrosimone finished the last round with 36.6% of the votes. McIsaac was second with 33.3%.

 

[jaster]

I kinda forgot about King Toot.

 

[OgeeOgelthorpe]

From this thread:

01.) Moritz Seider - RD - 20: 6'4" 207 lbs - RH Shot - Zell, GER - 96.2%
02.) Lucas Raymond - LW/RW - 19: 5'10"183 lbs - RH Shot - Goteborg, SWE - 85.1%
03.) Simon Edvinsson - LD - 18: 6'5" 207 lbs - LH Shot - Onsala, SWE - 70.1%
04.) Sebastian Cossa - G - 18: 6'6'' 212 lbs - LC catching glove - Fort McMurray, AL, CAN - 47.8%
05.) Jonatan Berggren - LW/RW- 21: 5'11'' 183 lbs - LH Shot - Uppsala, SWE - 75.5%
06.) Joe Veleno - C - 21: 6'1'' 194 lbs - LH Shot - Kirkland, QC, CAN - 69.1%
07.) Albert Johansson - D - 20: 6' 168 lbs - LH shot - Karistad, SWE - 85.5%
08.) Theodor Niederbach - C - 19: 5'11'' 172 lbs - RH shot - Örnsköldsvik, SWE - 36%
09.) Shai Buium - D - 18: 6'3'' 216 lbs - LH shot - San Diego, USA - 31.7%
10.) Eemil Viro - D - 19: 6' 165 lbs - LH shot - Vantaa, FIN - 24% (runoff 59.8%)
11.) Antti Tuomisto - D - 20: 6'5'' 205 lbs - RH shot - Pori, FIN - 32.4%
12.) William Wallinder - D - 19: 6'4'' 190 lbs - LH shot - Sollefteå, SWE - 32.7%
13.) Donovan Sebrango - D - 19: 6'1'' 190 lbs - LH shot - Ottawa, ON, CAN - 35.1%
14.) Elmer Soderblom - F - 20: 6'8'' 239 lbs - LH shot - Göteborg, SWE - 36%
15.) Kirill Tyutyayev - F - 21: 5'9'' 146 lbs - LH shot - Yekaterinburg, RUS - 39.1%

As far as I can tell, this was the last vote. Mastrosimone finished the last round with 36.6% of the votes. McIsaac was second with 33.3%.

The pool really has changed for the better in a single season. Tyutyayev and Tuomisto probably aren't even top 20 prospects for Detroit anymore. I know Niederbach came in at 12 but should probably be closer to 20 than 10. Wallinder and others have leapfrogged Viro. I feel much better about the pool overall.

 

[Henkka]

And when Traverse City tournament is completed, Lombardi will rise 10 positions.

 

[jaster]

And when Traverse City tournament is completed, Lombardi will rise 10 positions.

Why?

 

[Henkka]

Why?

Because he will be so good, and people like to overrate small sample sizes in this kind of voting.

 

[jaster]

Because he will be so good, and people like to overrate small sample sizes in this kind of voting.

That’s true.

 

[waltdetroit]

Add Piercey

 

[Henkka]

Add Piercey

He is not a prospect. Still just a try-out.

Viro wins this and we go to #17.

 

[waltdetroit]

He is not a prospect. Still just a try-out.

Viro wins this and we go to #17.

I know, because you said "Because he will be so good, and people like to overrate small sample sizes in this kind of voting", I thought to prove your point