Ancient Video Footage: 1929-1941

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
The 1924-1928 thread remains open for discussion, but we're moving on to the next period.

Major rule changes in 1929 and in 1943 define the period this thread is dedicated to.

In the late 1920s, complaints about defense-first hockey led to discussions:

New York Times - Jan 19 1929 said:
There is a cry in the hockey galleries for more scoring. The low-score games and the scoreless ties are becoming monotonous to the spectators, and all sorts of changes in the rules have been proposed.

This prompted the NHL to adapt its rule book in 1929-30:
  1. Forward passing: Recently legalized in the defensive and neutral zone, the forward pass was finally allowed in the offensive zone too and thus everywhere on the rink. The only forward pass not allowed now was the one across the blue line (from one zone to another).
  2. Anti-defence rule: Only two defending skaters were allowed in the defensive zone until a player of the attacking player entered the zone.
  3. These rule changes led to a flood of goals, but now there were complaints about "goal-hanging" (forwards staying near the opponent's goal and waiting for a pass), which promted another rule change halfway through the season: no attacking player was allowed to enter the offensive zone ahead of the puck anymore, which is the modern offside rule we know until this very day.
The new rules sped up the game and fostered offensive hockey. However, over time the downsides also showed: Some teams proceeded to send one or even two defencemen up the ice to join the attack (giving origin to the term "power play"), which was not without risk but helped by the fact that the defending team was not allowed to counter with a forward pass across the defensive blue line. The zone became very crowded and play there turned into prolonged scrums. By the late 1930s and early 1940s, complaints about these "ganging attacks" led to talk about new rule changes and in 1943 a drastic step was made: forward passing across the defensive blue line was finally allowed, although not across the entire rink but only to the red line that was introduced now. This paved the way for modern hockey.

Looking forward to the discussion of the following clips. Later in this thread, we should get insights into contemporary "How to Play Hockey" literature again.
 
Last edited:

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
Part 2/5:

Dec.1932, New York Americans vs New York Rangers:


Apr.1933, Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Rangers:


Nov.1933, New York Rangers vs Detroit Red Wings:
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
From the March 1932 game between Maple Leafs and Canadiens:

An opening face-off is followed by movement of all six forwards in the neutral zone after an opening face-off, but the defensive players of both teams remain stationary in the middle lane at the defensive blue lines.

Cap3.jpg


But later we do get to see some offensive involvement by a defenceman:

Maple Leafs (=blue) attack. Forward 1 (Joe Primeau?) sends the puck to #2 (Busher Jackson?), but the pass is intercepted by a backchecking Canadiens forward (red 1). Note the Canadiens defencemen (3, 4) headed toward their own goal to protect it:

Cap4_1.jpg


Backchecking Montreal forward 1 gets the puck, hits the break and gets ready to move in the other direction. Defenceman 3 sees a chance for a counter and begins to turn away from his own goal:

Cap5_1.jpg


He (red 3) breaks in the other direction and provides a passing option for his center (red 1):

Cap6_1.jpg


The center passes the puck to the breaking defencemen who now becomes the spearhead of the counter attack:

Cap7_1.jpg
 

tarheelhockey

Offside Review Specialist
Feb 12, 2010
85,418
139,444
Bojangles Parking Lot
From the March 1932 game between Maple Leafs and Canadiens:

An opening face-off is followed by movement of all six forwards in the neutral zone after an opening face-off, but the defensive players of both teams remain stationary in the middle lane at the defensive blue lines.

View attachment 460436

But later we do get to see some offensive involvement by a defenceman:

Maple Leafs (=blue) attack. Forward 1 (Joe Primeau?) sends the puck to #2 (Busher Jackson?), but the pass is intercepted by a backchecking Canadiens forward (red 1). Note the Canadiens defencemen (3, 4) headed toward their own goal to protect it:

View attachment 460437

Backchecking Montreal forward 1 gets the puck, hits the break and gets ready to move in the other direction. Defenceman 3 sees a chance for a counter and begins to turn away from his own goal:

View attachment 460438

He (red 3) breaks in the other direction and provides a passing option for his center (red 1):

View attachment 460439

The center passes the puck to the breaking defencemen who now becomes the spearhead of the counter attack:

View attachment 460440

And forward #2 recognizes the pinch, floating back into alignment with the remaining D (#4) rather than trying to get in on the rush.

That may have something to do with being matched with Charlie Conacher here. Pundits of the day made a much bigger deal about winger-vs-winger matchups than we do today.
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
And forward #2 recognizes the pinch, floating back into alignment with the remaining D (#4) rather than trying to get in on the rush.

Right.

That may have something to do with being matched with Charlie Conacher here. Pundits of the day made a much bigger deal about winger-vs-winger matchups than we do today.

I'm curious to see whether we'll learn anything about that from the two contemporary books we're going to get in this thread. @Habsfan18 will give us some bullet points from Red Dutton's "Hockey: The Fastest Game on Earth" (1938) and later Stephen Smith (@Puckstruck) will provide insights into "Hockey, for Spectator, Coach and Player" (1939) by Richard Vaughan and Holcomb York.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tarheelhockey

TotalBruins

Registered User
Aug 11, 2021
13
33
A few general comments from my research for my book on the Bruins 1929-39:
1) The offside rule was proposed by Bruins President Charles Adams at the NHL Governor's meeting on December 12, 1929. It was accepted and went into effect on December 21 - about 13 games into the season or about 1/3 into the season. See reports from the Montreal Gazette and Boston Globe on Dec 13 and later in that week.
2) Also introduced on Dec 21 was an increase in the roster size from 13 to 15 players.
3) The anti-defense rule had other components - once the zone was cleared, passing back into the defense zone incurred the penalty. There were more events which could trigger the penalty.

A general comment on the myth that the new rules resulted in inflated scoring due to "cherry-picking" (or what was referred to in the papers of 1929 as "loafing" by the net, particularly by the Bruins). I've analyzed every goal the Bruins scoring via multiple newspaper accounts. They never used the loafing tactic (the Cougars did, particularly Carson Cooper). Combined with the offside rule going into effect 13 games in, it busts this myth that Cooney Weiland's 73 points were a product of this. The Dynamite Line was dominant because they utilized the forward passing rule, particularly across the blueline, to the greatest effect. This has been part of hockey ever since.
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
A few general comments from my research for my book on the Bruins 1929-39:
1) The offside rule was proposed by Bruins President Charles Adams at the NHL Governor's meeting on December 12, 1929. It was accepted and went into effect on December 21 - about 13 games into the season or about 1/3 into the season. See reports from the Montreal Gazette and Boston Globe on Dec 13 and later in that week.
2) Also introduced on Dec 21 was an increase in the roster size from 13 to 15 players.
3) The anti-defense rule had other components - once the zone was cleared, passing back into the defense zone incurred the penalty. There were more events which could trigger the penalty.

Thank you very much! Your addition on the anti-defense rule is particularly appreciated. I have seen that additional component hintet at in a 1929 newspaper without fully realizing what the rule exactly entailed, so it's great to have that cleared up.

Has your book already been published?

A general comment on the myth that the new rules resulted in inflated scoring due to "cherry-picking" (or what was referred to in the papers of 1929 as "loafing" by the net, particularly by the Bruins). I've analyzed every goal the Bruins scoring via multiple newspaper accounts. They never used the loafing tactic (the Cougars did, particularly Carson Cooper). Combined with the offside rule going into effect 13 games in, it busts this myth that Cooney Weiland's 73 points were a product of this. The Dynamite Line was dominant because they utilized the forward passing rule, particularly across the blueline, to the greatest effect. This has been part of hockey ever since.

Very interesting. I wonder what prompted the change to the offside rule 13 games into the season, though.

Could you please elaborate on the "across the blue line" part of the forward passing rule?
 

Habsfan18

The Hockey Library
May 13, 2003
30,707
8,856
Ontario
There isn't much in terms of published material on this time frame in hockey history, but one of the really fascinating books from this time frame is Red Dutton's "Hockey: The Fastest Game on Earth." The book was published in 1938.

The information within isn't overly technical in terms of strategies deployed, but it still provides some unique insights by someone who was obviously very involved with the game at the time, and had experienced the previous era as well. The book reads as somewhat of an introduction to hockey for someone who would be new to the sport and wants to learn more. Much of the focus is on explaining the different positions and the on-ice roles of those players. I thought it would be interesting to jot down some of the information given by Red in the book. Each bullet point below is from the mouth of Red Dutton. Again, not overly technical stuff, but I still hope you enjoy and find some of it interesting.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

- Hockey is so fast today, and changes so suddenly, that if a man has his eyes for nothing but the puck, he will wind up with the light on his own net turned into a broken traffic light that is always red.

- In hockey, you must keep your mind and eyes on half a dozen things at the same time, and follow the puck by instinct. You have no time to think things out. Decisions are carried through simultaneously with the thought of them - so keep moving, keep punching!

- Your acts, paradoxically must be deliberate and yet delivered with the speed of light - and most of these actions must be continuous.

- Blinding speed is the basic fundamental of the game, but speed alone does not make a hockey player. He must be durable, able to give and take in a rough and tough hard-contact game, where a single thought of the dangers can make or break a fine player.

- Admitting the essentials of speed and endurance, there is another and just as important factor in hockey today, with its wide-open attack. That factor is finesse and deception, the art of stick-handling; for our players have a better understanding of the indispensable ability to feint, than competitors in any other sport - not excepting boxing.

- Upon your ability to outmaneuver the defense, depends your game; which is why I say you must keep your eyes and mind on half a dozen things at the same time. In no contest is deception a much an asset as in hockey. The complexion of affairs changes with such swiftness that instinct for the game must be developed as much as the ability to skate or handle a stick.

- Speed of skates and covering the attack completely are the basic fundamentals of a sound game of hockey. Obviously, without speed your team can have little more than a weak attack. Occasionally slow skaters can overcome this weakness with a sound defensive game, but holes can be punctured in a defense line when it lacks speed.

- Speed and the ability to change direction are the first fundamentals; because if you can't follow the play, you'll never get your stick on the puck, and so you'll never score goals. Mastery of this swinging turn is one of the greatest assets a hockey player can lay claim to; to master it the hockey player must make his own banks and learn to keep his balance without outside influence.

- Passing and shooting can be improved with strong forearms and powerful wrists. The power all emanates from the wrists. To my way of thinking, Charlie Conacher and Johnny Gallagher possess the fastest shots I've ever seen. Conacher could knock you off your skates with the tremendous drive he put behind a shot. Both of these men had exceedingly well developed forearm and wrists, which snapped like steel bands.

- In passing a puck, there is one cardinal point. Never pass a puck to a man who is covered; and never allow yourself to be covered for any length of time if you have the puck, or if you haven't. Pass the puck only when you when an advantage is to be gained by passing it.

- In shooting, the primary focus is to force the goalie to give you an opening. A good goalie is as cagey as the fastest skating forward in the game. A good goalie gets wise quickly, and your only chance is to pull him out of position and score.

- At all times try to shoot between six and eight inches off the ice. If there is a small opening - and the best a good goalie will ever give you is a peep of free cage - a
swift thrust from fifteen to eighteen feet out on the ice, and never more than half a dozen inches off of it, will give the goal keeper more trouble than any other shot.

- Accuracy in shooting can be promoted in only one way - by shooting. There is a legend built up around the name of Tommy Phillips, one of the old-time Kenora Thistles, which is more than a legend because many men active today in hockey remember Tommy. The story goes that Phillips was perhaps the most accurate shooter of that time or any other. He acquired his deadly aim by constant practice with a puck, stick, and an ordinary tomato can. He would bring the can out on the ice with him and set it up on a block of wood, eight to ten inches off the ice, and then pace off a dozen and a half feet from it. With astonishing accuracy he would batter the bottom from the can with shots into
it.

- Goaltenders must have a fine pair of hands - as quick and tough as they are big. He must be able to use them as efficiently as a big league first basemen. Complementing the quick hands must be eyes which are just as quick and twice as sure. No mistakes can be made in vision, for the goalie never gets two shots at a puck; if he does not sight it with the first look, there is no second chance.

- Defensemen are fearless citizens. When I first played hockey, defensemen were solely players who were used for body checking and blocking. Now, the trend in hockey has changed. The defense positions are farther up the ice and there are no unwritten laws or traditions riveting the defensemen back in the positions the held near the goal when they were known as the point and coverpoint. The best example of a player using this new style is Eddie Shore, who carries a big load of the Boston Bruins attack.

- The winning hockey team now is one with five forwards, somebody has said. For today the six-man lineup has more men on attacking zones than it ever had when we played seven men to a side.

- Five players up the ice is no longer an exaggeration. The defenseman now must be able to check and break from a standing start, and pass and shoot just as well as a man on the forward line.

- On defense, the ability to poke check is a required attribute, and if a team has a man gifted with the ability to poke and another dangerous body checker, then the defense is apt to be well balanced.

- The center will change the direction of the play almost as much as the defenseman. Usually, he is the first man to meet the play, and almost always he meets it in center ice. As the center meets the oncoming play, he becomes the most important man in your lineup, the playmaker, the man around whom your own attack will build itself if he can steal the puck.

- The defense abilities of a center in this important role will stand him in good stead, for as he breaks up the play with a body check, his ability to recover the puck and allow a team-mate to get into scoring position will help the offense of his own team beyond estimate.

- The attack swirls around the center. He is the apex around which most plays are started. In pro hockey, it is generally accepted that wings never cross the ice, but protect their own areas - which puts the burden of protecting center ice on the all-important center man. He must be the strongest man on your team and have the ability to skate with lightning speed. He must also be possessed of swivel hips as a broken field runner in football. He must also be fearless and not stopped by a mere body check.

- The wings should never unnecessarily roam from the alleys that run the length of the rink, from one corner to the other.

- Once, as a rule, it followed that left wings were left-handed shots and right wings were right-handed shots, but this is no longer the case.

- The best forwards are those who possess a good backhand shot, giving them the ability to score from either side.

- Wings must be exceptionally fast on their feet, and the fast break is an absolute essential of a good wingman. Full speed ahead in one stride is more necessary in a wing than any other player.

- The wings and center make or break a hockey club. They must be fast, gifted with the ability to make sudden decisions, and possess absolute mastery of passing, shooting, and receiving.

- Now, with the forward pass an accepted play in hockey, the forwards must be defense men as well as attacking forwards. The positions are interchangeable and with such rapidity that slow-witted, slow-footed men are lost in this fastest game on earth.

- Hockey has come a long way since the days when a defenseman rarely crossed the center zone of the ice. Now, with the forward pass, the defenseman go up the ice and mix up in the play until such time as they drop back and become safety forwards. But even then, they are at the blueline and not away back near their own net, waiting for the action to move toward them.

- Set plays and set shots are almost a rarity. In my years in hockey, I have seen only one team which appeared to have a set attack and a fixed set of plays designed to meet certain emergencies. It was, to my mind, the greatest passing combination that ever took the ice in the modern NHL. I mean that Boston Bruins team of 1929-1930, in which Art Ross whipped together a group of men which for short, fast and accurate passing was nothing short of brilliant. They passed the puck like a basketball team. That the Bruins of that era had a set passing attack goes without saying. But with a combination of men that can pass the puck into a fixed order of plays is a rarity. And when the men for such
a combination do come along, you do not often find them on the same team.

- The forward pass is the one feature that has contributed more than anything else to the terrific speed of hockey as it's played today. It is the essential feature of any attack, and absolute mastery of it must be acquired in order for any offense to function. It changed the style of hockey. It brought out the defense, it created a situation in which five forwards up the ice in the attacking zone is still fundamentally sound hockey, both offensively and defensively.

- The forward pass brought about situations which require the defensemen to become forwards, or safety forwards, rather than strictly point and coverpoint. The now stand near the blue line at the face-off, ready for the action to move away from the goal, and ready to become a part of the action.

- Another consideration of the attack is the possession of the puck. Here the dcenter's part is of first-grade importance. He is usually the apex of the attacking plays. He maneuvers the wings into position for a pass, he times the passing from one man to another, and generally speaking, he should be the best shot on the team. Much as the goalie runs the defense, the center should control the attack.

- In the game as it is played today the defensemen have their parts. Time was, when it was an infraction of the unwritten laws of the game for a coverpoint or point to sally into the opponent's defense zone; and I guess Lester Patrick was about the first player to do it. The tradition of no defensemen up the ice is a forgotten legend today; and the greatest exponents of the new style are the New York Rangers, managed by the old gray fox himself.

- The era of leaving the defensemen behind, useless to the offense, is definitely only a legend from the past. The era of the trailing man taking a pass, and the passing man dropping back and out of the play, is history.

- Chasing as many forwards into the attack as can get there, and with as much dispatch as conceivable, is the soundest attack.

- Rebounds off the goalkeeper, the goal posts, or the backboards, are the breaks which may contribute to a victory as much as anything. A set play in hockey, when a wing does not get an open from a goalie, is to drive the shot over the net, deliberately, and skate like the mischief back into the area at the rear of the net for a rebound and another chance to set up a scoring play.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: KevinFinnerty

TotalBruins

Registered User
Aug 11, 2021
13
33
Thank you very much! Your addition on the anti-defense rule is particularly appreciated. I have seen that additional component hintet at in a 1929 newspaper without fully realizing what the rule exactly entailed, so it's great to have that cleared up.

Has your book already been published?



Very interesting. I wonder what prompted the change to the offside rule 13 games into the season, though.

Could you please elaborate on the "across the blue line" part of the forward passing rule?

Apologies for the confusion. Passing across the blueline just like today's hockey. Previously, the puck had to be carried across.
What I can gather from reading the paper accounts is that concern for "jamming" the goalie via the cherry-picking and the increase in goal scoring were the 2 main drivers for the offside institution. I highly encourage a read of the newspapers of the time, they provide a lot of detail though it does take time to go through.
My book should be out next year. Waiting for the border to open to go to Boston to finish it off. Game by game account of the Bruins 1929-39 with >1000 pictures, over half are game action. 500 pages.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
Apologies for the confusion. Passing across the blueline just like today's hockey. Previously, the puck had to be carried across.

I guess we need to be careful when we refer to the "forward pass". Originally, forward passing wasn't allowed in hockey at all, but that doesn't mean one was literally not allowed to pass the puck forward – it just means that the receiver was not allowed to be ahead of the passer when the latter was parting with the puck. If the receiver was on-side [=on his own side of the puck] when the pass ahead was made and then skated forward to receive it, it wasn't an off-side situation.

So what you are saying is that previously not only the forward pass (=receiver ahead of passer) across the blue line was not allowed, but also any pass across the blue line even if the receiver was not yet ahead?

What I can gather from reading the paper accounts is that concern for "jamming" the goalie via the cherry-picking and the increase in goal scoring were the 2 main drivers for the offside institution.

Thanks. So loafing was indeed a factor, even if the Bruins and Cooney Weiland were not the culprits – contrary to public perception.

My book should be out next year. Waiting for the border to open to go to Boston to finish it off. Game by game account of the Bruins 1929-39 with >1000 pictures, over half are game action. 500 pages.

Great, looking forward to it!
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
There isn't much in terms of published material on this time frame in hockey history, but one of the really fascinating books from this time frame is Red Dutton's "Hockey: The Fastest Game on Earth." The book was published in 1938.

Great contribution!

Two quick catches:

- Hockey has come a long way since the days when a defenseman rarely crossed the center zone of the ice. Now, with the forward pass, the defenseman go up the ice and mix up in the play until such time as they drop back and become safety forwards. But even then, they are at the blueline and not away back near their own net, waiting for the action to move toward them.

(...)

- The forward pass brought about situations which require the defensemen to become forwards, or safety forwards, rather than strictly point and coverpoint. The now stand near the blue line at the face-off, ready for the action to move away from the goal, and ready to become a part of the action.

In my post yesterday I referred to the defensemen remaining stationary at the blue line. But as Dutton points out here, this is already a step forward compared to the prior era. Before, the defensemen tended to remain deeper in their own end. Now they're further advanced, luring at the blue line, a positioning that prompts Dutton to label them as "safety forwards". The capture below from right after an opening face-off is a perfect visualization of that sentence by Dutton: "They now stand near the blue line at the face-off, ready for action to move away from the goal, and ready to become a part of the action":

cap3-jpg.460436


- Now, with the forward pass an accepted play in hockey, the forwards must be defense men as well as attacking forwards. The positions are interchangeable and with such rapidity that slow-witted, slow-footed men are lost in this fastest game on earth.

This interchangeability is visualized by the second scene from my post yesterday. A defenseman quick-wittedly and quick-footedly senses the opportunity for a break and becomes an attacking player. Meanwhile his backchecking LW fills in defensively, as pointed out by @tarheelhockey.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: tarheelhockey

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
Gotta say, I really like the quality of the footage from 1932 on. If only we had a full game or at least a full period, it would be priceless.
 
  • Like
Reactions: johan f

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
Maybe it's also interesting to see some training footage (other than scrimmages/practice games) from the 1930s, even if it's not from the NHL:

Austrian national team drills, December 1935:



Including a stickhandling relay and stops & starts.

The Austrian national team had had Canadian coaches (Gordon Dempsey, Blake Watson) in the late 1920s and early 1930s.

Wembley teams, January 1936:



Including stops & starts and a presentation of the equipment.

The English clubs of that era featured many Canadian players, one team in the clip is even named "Wembley Canadians".
 
Last edited:

Michael Farkas

Celebrate 68
Jun 28, 2006
13,592
8,245
NYC
www.hockeyprospect.com
One of my takeaways from the early clips in the thread is that there's a pretty fair talent divide between the top of the league and the lower end players/teams...Boston and Toronto are really good...
 

tarheelhockey

Offside Review Specialist
Feb 12, 2010
85,418
139,444
Bojangles Parking Lot
Maybe it's also interesting to see some training footage (other than scrimmages/practice games) from the 1930s, even if it's not from the NHL:

Austrian national team drills, December 1935:


Wembley teams, January 1936:



Including stops & starts and a presentation of the equipment.

The English clubs of that era featured many Canadian players, one team in the clip is even named "Wembley Canadians".


The game action clips at the beginning and end… look at the size of the goal crease!

I’m not familiar with the rules in force in Britain at the time. Would be really interested to know what exactly was forbidden inside a space that large.

Also, I’d love to see an analysis of those training clips by someone who has experience coaching players on their skating. We talk a lot about the limitations of equipment in different eras, and that’s some good footage for determining just what was/was not possible on those skates. The thing that’s immediately striking is that the players seem to have a lot less depth when leaning into their turns, and a generally more upright posture all the time.
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
Part 3/5:

Mar.1936, New York Americans vs Toronto Maple Leafs:


Dec.1936, New York Rangers vs Montreal Canadiens:


Apr.1937, New York Rangers vs Montreal Maroons:
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
Part 4/5:

Feb.1938, Boston Bruins vs New York Rangers:


Mar.1938, New York Rangers vs New York Americans:


Nov.1938, Chicago Black Hawks vs New York Rangers:
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
Part 5/5:

Nov.1938, New York Americans vs Boston Bruins:


Nov.1939, Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Rangers:


Apr.1941, Detroit Red Wings vs Boston Bruins:
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
There isn't much in terms of published material on this time frame in hockey history, but one of the really fascinating books from this time frame is Red Dutton's "Hockey: The Fastest Game on Earth." The book was published in 1938.

The information within isn't overly technical in terms of strategies deployed, but it still provides some unique insights by someone who was obviously very involved with the game at the time, and had experienced the previous era as well. The book reads as somewhat of an introduction to hockey for someone who would be new to the sport and wants to learn more. Much of the focus is on explaining the different positions and the on-ice roles of those players. I thought it would be interesting to jot down some of the information given by Red in the book. Each bullet point below is from the mouth of Red Dutton. Again, not overly technical stuff, but I still hope you enjoy and find some of it interesting.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

- Hockey is so fast today, and changes so suddenly, that if a man has his eyes for nothing but the puck, he will wind up with the light on his own net turned into a broken traffic light that is always red.

- In hockey, you must keep your mind and eyes on half a dozen things at the same time, and follow the puck by instinct. You have no time to think things out. Decisions are carried through simultaneously with the thought of them - so keep moving, keep punching!

- Your acts, paradoxically must be deliberate and yet delivered with the speed of light - and most of these actions must be continuous.

- Blinding speed is the basic fundamental of the game, but speed alone does not make a hockey player. He must be durable, able to give and take in a rough and tough hard-contact game, where a single thought of the dangers can make or break a fine player.

- Admitting the essentials of speed and endurance, there is another and just as important factor in hockey today, with its wide-open attack. That factor is finesse and deception, the art of stick-handling; for our players have a better understanding of the indispensable ability to feint, than competitors in any other sport - not excepting boxing.

- Upon your ability to outmaneuver the defense, depends your game; which is why I say you must keep your eyes and mind on half a dozen things at the same time. In no contest is deception a much an asset as in hockey. The complexion of affairs changes with such swiftness that instinct for the game must be developed as much as the ability to skate or handle a stick.

- Speed of skates and covering the attack completely are the basic fundamentals of a sound game of hockey. Obviously, without speed your team can have little more than a weak attack. Occasionally slow skaters can overcome this weakness with a sound defensive game, but holes can be punctured in a defense line when it lacks speed.

- Speed and the ability to change direction are the first fundamentals; because if you can't follow the play, you'll never get your stick on the puck, and so you'll never score goals. Mastery of this swinging turn is one of the greatest assets a hockey player can lay claim to; to master it the hockey player must make his own banks and learn to keep his balance without outside influence.

- Passing and shooting can be improved with strong forearms and powerful wrists. The power all emanates from the wrists. To my way of thinking, Charlie Conacher and Johnny Gallagher possess the fastest shots I've ever seen. Conacher could knock you off your skates with the tremendous drive he put behind a shot. Both of these men had exceedingly well developed forearm and wrists, which snapped like steel bands.

- In passing a puck, there is one cardinal point. Never pass a puck to a man who is covered; and never allow yourself to be covered for any length of time if you have the puck, or if you haven't. Pass the puck only when you when an advantage is to be gained by passing it.

- In shooting, the primary focus is to force the goalie to give you an opening. A good goalie is as cagey as the fastest skating forward in the game. A good goalie gets wise quickly, and your only chance is to pull him out of position and score.

- At all times try to shoot between six and eight inches off the ice. If there is a small opening - and the best a good goalie will ever give you is a peep of free cage - a
swift thrust from fifteen to eighteen feet out on the ice, and never more than half a dozen inches off of it, will give the goal keeper more trouble than any other shot.

- Accuracy in shooting can be promoted in only one way - by shooting. There is a legend built up around the name of Tommy Phillips, one of the old-time Kenora Thistles, which is more than a legend because many men active today in hockey remember Tommy. The story goes that Phillips was perhaps the most accurate shooter of that time or any other. He acquired his deadly aim by constant practice with a puck, stick, and an ordinary tomato can. He would bring the can out on the ice with him and set it up on a block of wood, eight to ten inches off the ice, and then pace off a dozen and a half feet from it. With astonishing accuracy he would batter the bottom from the can with shots into
it.

- Goaltenders must have a fine pair of hands - as quick and tough as they are big. He must be able to use them as efficiently as a big league first basemen. Complementing the quick hands must be eyes which are just as quick and twice as sure. No mistakes can be made in vision, for the goalie never gets two shots at a puck; if he does not sight it with the first look, there is no second chance.

- Defensemen are fearless citizens. When I first played hockey, defensemen were solely players who were used for body checking and blocking. Now, the trend in hockey has changed. The defense positions are farther up the ice and there are no unwritten laws or traditions riveting the defensemen back in the positions the held near the goal when they were known as the point and coverpoint. The best example of a player using this new style is Eddie Shore, who carries a big load of the Boston Bruins attack.

- The winning hockey team now is one with five forwards, somebody has said. For today the six-man lineup has more men on attacking zones than it ever had when we played seven men to a side.

- Five players up the ice is no longer an exaggeration. The defenseman now must be able to check and break from a standing start, and pass and shoot just as well as a man on the forward line.

- On defense, the ability to poke check is a required attribute, and if a team has a man gifted with the ability to poke and another dangerous body checker, then the defense is apt to be well balanced.

- The center will change the direction of the play almost as much as the defenseman. Usually, he is the first man to meet the play, and almost always he meets it in center ice. As the center meets the oncoming play, he becomes the most important man in your lineup, the playmaker, the man around whom your own attack will build itself if he can steal the puck.

- The defense abilities of a center in this important role will stand him in good stead, for as he breaks up the play with a body check, his ability to recover the puck and allow a team-mate to get into scoring position will help the offense of his own team beyond estimate.

- The attack swirls around the center. He is the apex around which most plays are started. In pro hockey, it is generally accepted that wings never cross the ice, but protect their own areas - which puts the burden of protecting center ice on the all-important center man. He must be the strongest man on your team and have the ability to skate with lightning speed. He must also be possessed of swivel hips as a broken field runner in football. He must also be fearless and not stopped by a mere body check.

- The wings should never unnecessarily roam from the alleys that run the length of the rink, from one corner to the other.

- Once, as a rule, it followed that left wings were left-handed shots and right wings were right-handed shots, but this is no longer the case.

- The best forwards are those who possess a good backhand shot, giving them the ability to score from either side.

- Wings must be exceptionally fast on their feet, and the fast break is an absolute essential of a good wingman. Full speed ahead in one stride is more necessary in a wing than any other player.

- The wings and center make or break a hockey club. They must be fast, gifted with the ability to make sudden decisions, and possess absolute mastery of passing, shooting, and receiving.

- Now, with the forward pass an accepted play in hockey, the forwards must be defense men as well as attacking forwards. The positions are interchangeable and with such rapidity that slow-witted, slow-footed men are lost in this fastest game on earth.

- Hockey has come a long way since the days when a defenseman rarely crossed the center zone of the ice. Now, with the forward pass, the defenseman go up the ice and mix up in the play until such time as they drop back and become safety forwards. But even then, they are at the blueline and not away back near their own net, waiting for the action to move toward them.

- Set plays and set shots are almost a rarity. In my years in hockey, I have seen only one team which appeared to have a set attack and a fixed set of plays designed to meet certain emergencies. It was, to my mind, the greatest passing combination that ever took the ice in the modern NHL. I mean that Boston Bruins team of 1929-1930, in which Art Ross whipped together a group of men which for short, fast and accurate passing was nothing short of brilliant. They passed the puck like a basketball team. That the Bruins of that era had a set passing attack goes without saying. But with a combination of men that can pass the puck into a fixed order of plays is a rarity. And when the men for such
a combination do come along, you do not often find them on the same team.

- The forward pass is the one feature that has contributed more than anything else to the terrific speed of hockey as it's played today. It is the essential feature of any attack, and absolute mastery of it must be acquired in order for any offense to function. It changed the style of hockey. It brought out the defense, it created a situation in which five forwards up the ice in the attacking zone is still fundamentally sound hockey, both offensively and defensively.

- The forward pass brought about situations which require the defensemen to become forwards, or safety forwards, rather than strictly point and coverpoint. The now stand near the blue line at the face-off, ready for the action to move away from the goal, and ready to become a part of the action.

- Another consideration of the attack is the possession of the puck. Here the dcenter's part is of first-grade importance. He is usually the apex of the attacking plays. He maneuvers the wings into position for a pass, he times the passing from one man to another, and generally speaking, he should be the best shot on the team. Much as the goalie runs the defense, the center should control the attack.

- In the game as it is played today the defensemen have their parts. Time was, when it was an infraction of the unwritten laws of the game for a coverpoint or point to sally into the opponent's defense zone; and I guess Lester Patrick was about the first player to do it. The tradition of no defensemen up the ice is a forgotten legend today; and the greatest exponents of the new style are the New York Rangers, managed by the old gray fox himself.

- The era of leaving the defensemen behind, useless to the offense, is definitely only a legend from the past. The era of the trailing man taking a pass, and the passing man dropping back and out of the play, is history.

- Chasing as many forwards into the attack as can get there, and with as much dispatch as conceivable, is the soundest attack.

- Rebounds off the goalkeeper, the goal posts, or the backboards, are the breaks which may contribute to a victory as much as anything. A set play in hockey, when a wing does not get an open from a goalie, is to drive the shot over the net, deliberately, and skate like the mischief back into the area at the rear of the net for a rebound and another chance to set up a scoring play.

My takeaways from this summary of Dutton's book:

-The forward pass (unsurprisingly) had an immense impact on the game.
-1930s hockey was viewed as a game of speed and offense.
-Center was generally regarded as the key position on the ice. The center was the playmaker and also the first defensive player to meet the opposition.
-Defencemen were much more involved in the game and in the offense now. Thus interchangeability between positions became a thing.
-Wingers stayed in their lane, but were asked to backcheck.

Interestingly, Dutton would later become NHL president (1943) and oversee steps to counter some of the consequences of the forward passing game.
 

Theokritos

Global Moderator
Apr 6, 2010
12,551
4,974
Some interesting face-off setups:

1936:

1936.jpg


The defencemen have moved into the neutral zone.

1938:

1938_1.jpg


The defencemen are positioned a tad more conservatively again, but one winger of each team is now in front of them in the center.

---

Those 1930s clips show that professional hockey was more of a passing game than before, but individual forays with speed and stickhandling still seem the prevalent means of attack. The physical and rowdy nature of the game is captured very well and in some clips you can see and hear the crowd go wild. My favourite clips:



Very good video quality and you get the authentic pace of the game (as opposed to e.g. the first clip).



Great shots from the dressing room. Blade sharpening, stick taping etc.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad