All time Roster

[c-carp]

Your team's all time team

I will do the Blues

Momesso-Oates-Hull
Sutter-Federko-Mullen
Berenson-Unger-Babych
Twist-Corson-Ewen

Pronger-MacInnis
Bob Plager-Barc Plager
Gassoff-Ramage


Liut
Hall

Click to read more...

 

[MiamiScreamingEagles]

We had something similar on the Flyers' board within the last few days. JohnFlyersFan posted this and I don't have any major disagreements (though I added options in parenthesis):

Barber - Clarke - Leach
LeClair - Lindros - Recchi
Propp - MacLeish - Kerr
Gagne - Brind'Amour - Tocchet

Howe - McCrimmon
Desjardins - Timonen
Dupont - Johnsson (Jimmy Watson)

Parent
Lindbergh (Hextall)

 

[pappyline]

Hawks off the top of my head

Hull-Mikita-litzenberger
D. Bentley-M.Bentley-Mosienko
Thompson-Savard-Larmer
R.Conacher-Sloan-March

Seibert-pilote
Chelios-Wilson
gadsby-Vasko

gardiner
Hall

 

[FissionFire]

Assuming I am only using their time in Detroit and not their entire career.....

Ted Lindsay - Steve Yzerman - Gordie Howe
Sid Abel - Marcel Dionne - Mickey Redmond
Alex Delvecchio - Sergei Fedorov - Larry Aurie
Brendan Shanahan - Syd Howe - Ray Sheppard

Nicklas Lidstrom - Red Kelly
Black Jack Stewart - Marcel Pronovost
Ebbie Goodfellow - Vladimir Konstantinov

Terry Sawchuk
Normie Smith
Chris Osgood


Probably not the best lineup but I'm going off the top of my head.

 

[Hyperkookeez*]

Flames:

Makarov - Nilsson - Iginla
Roberts - Nieuwendyk - Fleury
Drury - Savard - Mullen
Tanguay - Bullard - McDonald

Suter - MacInnis
Reinhart - Regehr
McCrimmon - Phaneuf

Kipper
Vernon
Fuhr

Initially, I wanted to do it with a realistic roster based off their time with the flames and playing style(seeing as how you wouldnt put mullen, savard, or tanguay in bottom 6 roles), but that idea got thrown out the window when some quality names were being left out. Makarov got put into LW just because its so hard to fit him on RW with the names currently there.

 

[Hedberg]

Vancouver:

Kirk McLean
Roberto Luongo
Richard Brodeur

Mattias Ohlund - Jyrki Lumme
Doug Lidster - Ed Jovanovski
Kevin McCarthy - Harold Snepsts
Dennis Kearns

Markus Naslund - Trevor Linden - Pavel Bure
Tony Tanti - Thomas Gradin - Stan Smyl
Daniel Sedin - Henrik Sedin - Todd Bertuzzi
Don Lever - Andre Boudrias - Petri Skriko
Patrik Sundstrom - Brendan Morrison

 

[finchster]

My Bruins

Bucyk - Espo - Neely
Dumart - Schmdit - Bauer
Cashman - Cowley - Middleton
O'Reilly - Oates - Hodge

Orr - Shore
Bourque - Park
Chara - Clapper

Brimsrek
Thompson
Thomas/Cheevers

 

[Mr Pipe]

Orr - Shore
Bourque - Park
Chara - Clapper

Amazing.

 

[crobro]

My Bruins

Bucyk - Espo - Neely
Dumart - Schmdit - Bauer
Cashman - Cowley - Middleton
O'Reilly - Oates - Hodge

Orr - Shore
Bourque - Park
Chara - Clapper

Brimsrek
Thompson
Thomas/Cheevers

amazing defense is right.

i wouild throw in andy moog and or reggie lemelin in there in goal

but christ whata defense

 

[tomi2]

My Bruins

Bucyk - Espo - Neely
Dumart - Schmdit - Bauer
Cashman - Cowley - Middleton
O'Reilly - Oates - Hodge

Orr - Shore
Bourque - Park
Chara - Clapper

Brimsrek
Thompson
Thomas/Cheevers

Damn, there are quite a few Norris trophies in that defence.

 

[hfboardsuser]

Semenko-Gretzky-Kurri
Tikkanen-Messier-Anderson
Smyth-Weight-Guerin
Moreau-Marchant-Grier
Simpson

Pronger-Coffey
Lowe-Huddy
Hamrlik-Smith
Siltanen, Ruotsalainen

Fuhr
Moog

Not really all that impressive when stacked up against O6 teams.

 

[cynicism]

Leafs:
Mahvolich-Sundin-Mogilny
Roberts-Sittler-Macdonald
Clark-Gilmour-Ellis
Andreychuck-Keon-Teeder

spares: Vaive, Pulford, Williams

Salming-Kaberle
Horton-Turnbull
Brewer-Yushkevich
Horner

Bower
Broda
Potvin

 

[pnep]

Ottawa Senators - St. Louis Eagles (1917-35)

Cy "The Cornwall Colt" Denneny -- Frank "The Flying Dutchman" Nighbor -- Harry "Punch" Broadbent
Hec "Hurricane Hec" Kilrea -- Joe Lamb -- Jack Darragh
Bill Touhey -- Syd Howe -- Frank "The Slumbering Romeo" Finnigan
Milt Halliday -- Jack J. "The Squire Of Napanee" Adams -- Reginald "Hooley" Smith

George "Buck" Boucher -- Francis "King" Clancy
Eddie Gerard -- Sprague "The Big Train" Cleghorn
Harry "Cammie" Cameron -- Alex "Boots" Smith
Lionel "Hitch" Hitchman

Clint "Praying Bennie" Benedict
Alex "The Ottawa Fireman" Connell
Bill Beveridge


Quebec Bulldogs - Hamilton Tigers - New York Americans - Brooklyn Americans (1919-42)

David "Sweeney" Schriner -- Billy "Yonkers Billy" Burch -- Lorne Carr
Redvers "Red" Green -- Joe "Phantom" Malone -- Eddie "Pee Wee" Wiseman
Charley "Rabbit" Mcveigh -- Nels "Old Poison" Stewart -- Wilf "Shorty" Green
Johnny "Jake" Sheppard -- Art Chapman -- Charlie "Big Blue Bomber" Conacher
Norman "Normie" Himes

Tom "Cowboy" Anderson -- Mervyn "Red" Dutton
Ken "Pepper Kid" Randall -- Goldie "The Cinnamon Bearcat" Prodgers
Bill Brydge -- Leo Sr. Reise

Roy "Shrimp" Worters
Jake "Jumpin' Jakie" Forbes
Earl Robertson


Montreal Maroons (1924-38)

Lawrence "Baldy" Northcott -- Nels "Old Poison" Stewart -- Jimmy Ward
Albert "Babe" Siebert -- Reginald "Hooley" Smith -- Earl Robinson
Dave Trottier -- Russ "Beaver" Blinco -- Harry "Punch" Broadbent
Herb Cain -- Meryn "Bill" Phillips -- August "Gus" Marker
Bob Gracie

Lionel "The Big Train" Conacher -- Duncan "Dunc" Munro
Cy "Cyclone" Wentworth -- Reg "Old Sarge" Noble
Stewart "Stew" Evans -- Mervyn "Red" Dutton

Clint "Praying Bennie" Benedict
Alex "The Ottawa Fireman" Connell
James "Flat" Walsh


Pittsburgh Pirates - Philadelphia Quakers (1925-31)

Gerry Lowery -- Hibbert "Hib" Milks -- Harry "Howl" Darragh
Baldy "The Cork Screw" Cotton -- Frank Frederickson -- Herb "Monkey" Drury
Francis "Duke" Mccurry -- Syd Howe -- Wilfred "Tex" White
Jim "Bud" Jarvis -- Ogilvie "Odie" Cleghorn -- Wally Kilrea
Ernest "Ty" Arbour

Rodger Smith -- John Mckinnon
Bert "Mac" Mccaffrey -- Jesse "Jess" Spring
Lionel "The Big Train" Conacher -- Martin "Marty" Burke

Roy "Shrimp" Worters
Joe "Red Light" Miller
Wilf "Petch" Cude


Oakland Seals - California Golden Seals - Cleveland Barons (1967-78)

Joey Johnston -- Ted "Tick" Hampson -- Al "Big Al" Macadam
Gary Jarrett -- Dennis "Pee-Wee" Maruk -- Norm Ferguson
Gary "Crow" Croteau -- Walt "Wake Up Walt" Mckechnie -- Bill Hicke
Stan Gilbertson -- Dave Gardner -- Gerry "Tex" Ehman
Earl Ingarfield

Carol "Vad" Vadnais -- Bob "Stewie" Stewart
Bert "Moose" Marshall -- Rick "Crow" Hampton
Doug Roberts -- Jim "The Chief" Neilson

Gilles "The Saviour" Meloche
Gary "Suitcase" Smith
Gary "The Cobra" Simmons
​

 

[tony d]

Ottawa Senators

Heatley-Yashin-Alfredsson
Arvedson-Spezza-Hossa
Scheafer-Bonk-Mceachern
C.Kelly-Fisher-Dackell

Redden-Phillips
Chara-York
Mezaros-Rachunek

Lalime
Emery

 

[DaveG]

Hartford Whalers/Carolina Hurricanes
Bobby Hull - Dave Keon - Gordie Howe
Brendan Shanahan - Ron Francis - Mark Recchi
Gary Roberts - Rod Brind'Amour - Pat Verbeek
Ray Whitney - Doug Weight - Eric Staal

Chris Pronger - Paul Coffey
Mark Howe - Glen Wesley
Al Iafrate - Ulf Samuelsson

Tom Barrasso
Mike Liut
Arturs Irbe

 

[Penner getrdonebryan]

Ottawa Senators

Heatley-Yashin-Alfredsson
Arvedson-Spezza-Hossa
Scheafer-Bonk-Mceachern
C.Kelly-Fisher-Dackell

Redden-Phillips
Chara-York
Mezaros-Rachunek

Lalime
Emery

Havlat?Hasek?Volchenkov?

 

[Canadiens Fan]

Just for fun and because of the wealth of talent, I decided to put together a first and a second team of all-time Habs greats.

Montreal Canadiens

First Team

Moore - Beliveau - M. Richard
Shutt - H. Richard - Lafleur
Blake - Morenz - Geoffrion
Gainey - Lach - Cournoyer

Harvey - Robinson
Savard - Lapointe
Johnson - Bouchard

Plante
Roy

Blake

Second Team

Joliat - Lalonde - Provost
Olmstead - Lemaire - Rousseau
Naslund - P. Mahovlich - Richer
F. Mahovlich - Carbonneau - M. Tremblay

J.C. Tremblay - Laperriere
Chelios - Talbot
Reardon - Mantha

Dryden
Durnan

Bowman

 

[ck26]

Dallas Stars
Jere Lehtinen - Mike Modano - Brett Hull
Brendan Morrow - Joe Nieuwendyk - Bill Guerin
Kirk Muller - Guy Carbonneau - Mike Keane
Jamie Langenbrunner - Neal Broten - Pat Verbeek

Derian Hatcher - Sergei Zubov
Richard Matvichuk - Darryl Sydor
Craig Ludwig - Stephane Robidas

Ed Belfour
Marty Turco​

 

[Canadiens Fan]

Leafs:
Mahvolich-Sundin-Mogilny
Roberts-Sittler-Macdonald
Clark-Gilmour-Ellis
Andreychuck-Keon-Teeder

spares: Vaive, Pulford, Williams

Salming-Kaberle
Horton-Turnbull
Brewer-Yushkevich
Horner

Bower
Broda
Potvin

Mogilny, McDonald, & Ellis over Charlie Conacher ???
Andreychuk & Roberts over Busher Jackson & Dick Duff ???
No mention of Syl Apps, Red Kelly, & Joe Primeau ???
A mention of Tiger Williams ???
Kaberle, Turnbull, Yushkevich over King Clancy, Stanley, Pronovost & Baun ???
Potvin over Hainsworth & Lumley ???

 

[ck26]

Mogilny, McDonald, & Ellis over Charlie Conacher ???
Andreychuk & Roberts over Busher Jackson & Dick Duff ???
No mention of Syl Apps, Red Kelly, & Joe Primeau ???
A mention of Tiger Williams ???
Kaberle, Turnbull, Yushkevich over King Clancy, Stanley, Pronovost & Baun ???
Potvin over Hainsworth & Lumley ???

I think there is a higher percentage of Maple Leafs fans who don't understand anything about their franchise's history than any other team. Say what you want about the Thrashers, at least their fans know the team ... heck, most even know the old Atlanta Flames. A Leafs list without Dick Duff and Busher Jackson and Chuck Conacher is LOL.

 

[Pear Juice]

Alright so here's my Frölunda HC.

Let's see how many of these you recognize. It's a somewhat mixed team, some played out their entire careers in Frölunda while some made it big across the pond.

Niklas Andersson - Patrik Carnbäck - Daniel Alfredsson
Jörgen Pettersson - Jonas Johnsson - Sura-Pelle Pettersson
Lars-Erik Lundvall - Mikael Andersson - Tomi Kallio
Jonas Esbjörs - Ulf Sterner - Per-Johan Axelsson

Ronnie Sundin - Stefan Larsson
Magnus Johansson - Roger Olsson
Petteri Nummelin - Anders Broström

Henrik Lundqvist
HÃ¥kan Algotsson


disclaimer: Somewhat hasty so I might have missed some obvious ones.

 

[MXD]

My Bruins

Bucyk - Espo - Neely
Dumart - Schmdit - Bauer
Cashman - Cowley - Middleton
O'Reilly - Oates - Hodge

Orr - Shore
Bourque - Park
Chara - Clapper

Brimsrek
Thompson
Thomas/Cheevers

I'd actually have Lionel Hitchman instead of Chara, but you aren't MUCH wrong with Chara.

 

[MXD]

Just for fun and because of the wealth of talent, I decided to put together a first and a second team of all-time Habs greats.

Montreal Canadiens

First Team

Moore - Beliveau - M. Richard
Shutt - H. Richard - Lafleur
Blake - Morenz - Geoffrion
Gainey - Lach - Cournoyer

Harvey - Robinson
Savard - Lapointe
Johnson - Bouchard

Plante
Roy

Blake

Second Team

Joliat - Lalonde - Provost
Olmstead - Lemaire - Rousseau
Naslund - P. Mahovlich - Richer
F. Mahovlich - Carbonneau - M. Tremblay

J.C. Tremblay - Laperriere
Chelios - Talbot
Reardon - Mantha

Dryden
Durnan

Bowman

Like most would do it, but Ken Reardon and Aurel Joliat would be better picks than AT LEAST two of their respective "rivals".

Especially for Joliat, who is IMO pretty close to Moore.

 

[pnep]

Leafs:
Mahvolich-Sundin-Mogilny
Roberts-Sittler-Macdonald
Clark-Gilmour-Ellis
Andreychuck-Keon-Teeder

spares: Vaive, Pulford, Williams

Salming-Kaberle
Horton-Turnbull
Brewer-Yushkevich
Horner

Bower
Broda
Potvin

Toronto Arenas -- Toronto St. Patricks -- Toronto Maple Leafs (1917-09)

Frank "Big M" Mahovlich -- C.J. Syl "Slippery Syl" Apps -- Charlie "Big Blue Bomber" Conacher
Harvey "Busher" Jackson -- Ted "Teeder" Kennedy -- Cecil "Babe" Dye
Sid "Muff" Smith -- Dave Keon -- Gordie "Lefty" Drillon
Bob "Pully" Pulford -- Mats "Sudden" Sundin -- George "The Chief" Armstrong
Garnet I. "Ace" Bailey

Tim "Superman" Horton -- Francis "King" Clancy
Harry "Cammie" Cameron -- Borje "The King" Salming
Allan "Snowshoes" Stanley -- Carl "Skitz" Brewer

Turk "Old Slippery" Broda
Johnny "China Wall" Bower
Harry "Apple Cheeks" Lumley
​

 

[pnep]

New York Rangers (1926-09)

Lynn Patrick -- Frank "Raffles" Boucher -- Bill Cook
Frederick "Bun" Cook -- Mark "Mess" Messier -- Andy "Handy Andy" Bathgate
Camille "The Eel" Henry -- Jean "Ratty" Ratelle -- Bryan Sr. "Hex" Hextall
Vic Hadfield -- Neil Colville -- Rod "Mr. Broadway" Gilbert
Ceece "Two Gun" Dillon

Brian "Leetchie" Leetch -- Douglas "Brad" Park
Ching "The Holding Corporation" Johnson -- Bill "Gads" Gadsby
Harry "Harry The Horse" Howell -- Erhardt "Ott" Heller

Ed "Fast Eddie" Giacomin
Dave "Davey" Kerr
Chuck "Bonnie Prince Charlie" Rayner​