I'm not at all a fn of St. Louis "spreading the wealth"
I would load up that top line and have Stevens - Lemieux - Howe. Dominant offensively and physically ... it would be without a doubt the best line in the ATD, and one that could go a long way towards winning series after series.
I fear and respect Gorman too much to give him lines to match up against. I will use Stevens-Lemieux-Howe sometimes, but, I believe the key to victory is for Hart to stay one step ahead of Gorman. And I believe that by keeping lines fluid, Hart will be the one dictating Howe things are played. Plus, if Bouchard plays Howe, Laperriere vs Lemeiux, who's gonna stop Malone?
A big edge to Detroit in net. Nothing against Benedict, but Broda is one of the best clutch players of all-time. He was a big reason for Toronto's success in the late 40s and early 50s.
Broda gets overrated because he elevated his game so much. Benedict is a 4 time cup winner who was 4 and 2 in the finals and he seemingly outplayed Chabot in 27-28. He had two bad playoff performances in an 18 year career, 1915 against a powerhouse Millionaires squad and 1919, every other year, he was stellar. He, along with Martin Brodeur is one of two goalies in NHL history to record 4 shutouts in the playoffs twice in his career. And before you say it was the era, remember this. 1) No one else did it. 2) That was 8 game and 9 game playoffs. When the Maroons won in '26, Benedict got a shutout in all three Montreal wins. His post-season GAA is 1.86, his regular season gaa is 2.30, an improvement of 0.44, or almost 20%. 1918-19 and 1923-24 are the only years his post season GAA was weaker than his regular season gaa, keeping in mind that the average playoff opponent is tougher than the average regular season opponent. In the post season he got a shutout in 32% of his playoff games and 16% of his regular season games, so he gets twice as many shutouts in the post season.
It's like this: Benedict is superior to Broda in the regular season. Benedict is a clutch money goalie who steps up noticeably in the post-season. Broda steps up slightly more. The difference still favours Clint Benedict.
I win the goalie battle. Benedict is still quite underrated.
Stats for both:
http://www.hockeygoalies.org/bio/benedict.html
http://www.hockeygoalies.org/bio/broda.html
I think we have the right team to take out the Eagles. The trap is perfect for neutralizing Naslund, Malone, Martinec, Lemieux, Suchy etc from rushing through the neutral zone. They will be forced to dump-and-chase and outside of Stevens, they don't have the forwards to win those battles against our team.
It's funny, we're both each others worst case scenario. You can out play any team that tries to play a defense first game, and I can outplay any team that tries to play offense first. It's unstoppable force vs immovable object. Quite the series for the first round.
The thing about it is, in his comeback, Lemieux routinely destroyed neutral zone traps, and he wasn't even at his best then. He didn't have to dump and chase. Systems just don't work against players of his skill level. And Howe would be just the same, you can't trap the elite. It's like setting up a trap for Indiana Jones, even if he sets it off, he makes it out alive and with the treasure. Try and trap Howe and Lemieux and they'll still get goals. I'd also be careful to underrate Howe's ability to chase. His speed, strength and fearlessness will make him a wrecking ball.
I also believe Malone and Martinec have the ability to tangle up traps some of the time, not as often as Lemieux/Howe, but you can't trap Malone & Martinec all the time, maybe the majority of the time, but if I break the trap 25% of the time, then I win 75% of the games.
Goaltending
Benedict is good, but Broda has the edge as one of the all-time elite playoff goalies and a 5-time Cup winner. It's not really his fault, but Benedict only had success in the pre-forward pass era which could have a big effect on his play.
I'll get the numbers for this at home, but relative play of players who played pre and post 1929-30 changes very little. Benedict drops due to age and Gardiner improves due to age, but Hainsworth, Connell, Chabot, Thompson etc remain at the same level of play. While the change had a huge efdfect on raw numbers, the effect on players effect on the outcome is minimal. For the reasons stated above, Benedict is the superior goalie, he's almost as money as Broda, but, he's coming from a superior base skill level.
Defense
As the saying goes, defense wins in the playoffs, and I believe this is where we have our big advantage and can win the series.
Meh, that's only because real teams can't have the 2nd and 3rd best offensive players in hockey history on the same team. Defense loses to that level of game breaking talent.
- Can 5'8 Jan Suchy hold up against our strong forcheck and physical 6'1 wingers? Can any of them? All 4 of our lines bring a ton of grit and are great on the forecheck. They will finish their checks every chance they get and use the cycle to wear down the Eagles defense. Outside of Hatcher, who will have as much trouble keeping up with his own team as ours, they are outmatched in size and as we're seeing with all the victims of the 06-07 Ducks, that's a recipe for disaster.
As Chelios proved against Bertuzzi, winning the size match-up isn't nearly as important as winning the grit and skill match-up. Yeah, an undersized player will struggle, but Vasiliev, Thomson and Heller are all tough defensive defenceman who will make life just as tough on your forwards as your forwards will be tough on me.
And, if I was you, I'd be careful forechecking, Howe, Lemieux or Malone will always be on the ice, and an unsuccessful forecheck will result in a scoring opportunity from one of the top 10-20 goal scorers in the history of hockey. If you don't keep your forwards back, you will create holes, and you don't want holes when Howe, Lemieux or Malone is on the ice. Your only hope is containing them, and a heavy forecheck will just give them room to destroy you.
As for Suchy, you got to catch him. He won't be playing much on the board, so you have to go for open ice hits against a great skater. Again, a recipe to get burned on. He dodges the player, advantage me, and you don't want me to have an advantage when there is always one of Howe, Lemieux or Malone on the ice.
- A big part of Gordie's success was intimidation, get in his way and you'd get a stickblade to the face or one of his famous elbows. He's going to lose that in this series facing an entire blueline bigger than he is and no one who is going to get bullied around. Bouchard - Abel is the perfect tandem to shut him down, as neither will back down and they have the size and skill to keep him in check.
That's all well and good, problem is, this is Gordie we're talking about. Shutting him down isn't an option, if he gets 3-4 goals in the series, you did a great job. Howe's success is that he's freaking awesome. Breakaway speed, built like a brick house, fearless, equally adept playmaker and scorer, brilliant one on one moves, etc... Yeah, he's famous for his elbows, but he can just as easily embarrass you with pure skill. And all that attention to him leaves a guy like Weiland or Stevens open in the slot for a pass, a pass that Gordie will make spot on.
- MacInnis - Laperriere is one of the best pairings in the draft and can be used against Lemieux's line. They're both great in transition and can quickly start the rush while Lemieux is taking his sweet time getting back to his blueline.
This doesn't bother me, because, it's Mario. They'll have to keep one eye behind them at all times, they lose the puck and the greatest breakaway scorer of all time has a breakaway.
- There isn't a lot of scoring beyond St.Louis' top 6, as most of them are defensive forwards, but Dailey - Reise is a solid pairing that can match up well against what's left.
That's actually not true, Kilrea, Weiland and Watson all have serious offensive credentials. Weiland has multiple top 10 finishes (I can't get the exact numbers at school.) and a goal and points scoring title that set the record for points in a season that wasn't broken until WW2 diluted the league. Watson has a playoff scoring title and a regular season assists title. Kilrea has multiple top 10 finishes.