Motte and Bailey
Registered User
- Jun 21, 2017
- 3,692
- 1,556
I don't even know where to start...where do you get these percentages? You do realize there is a chance none of Podkolzin, Madden and Lind become NHLers and a decent chance none of them become top-6 players; yet you have the three listed as having 100% chance of becoming a top a 6 player accumulatively (1/3 are guaranteed to be top-6) and you call that conservative?
The percentages come from reality. I explained it in my post already. Benning’s record with 1st rounders is the basis of Pod’s 66%. The 17% figure came from A LOT of rounding down. Each 2nd round pick has a 42% chance of turning into an NHLer per TSN so rounding it down to less than half that at 17% for those picks to make the NHL and exceed expectations is reasonable and conservative. Madden was a 3rd round pick so I guess if you wanted to nitpick he could be at 13-14% rather than 17% because 3rd rounders have a 31% chance to make the NHL but I kept all the non first rounders at 17 for simplicity.
Edit: and yes I’m aware that those percentages aren’t guarantees but they are only meant to represent our best approximations.