Micklebot
Moderator
- Apr 27, 2010
- 53,829
- 31,041
Ah ok, I stand corrected. I tried looking at larger sample size and didn't realize they started playing at different ages. In that case if ZO becomes JA but also someone who elevates their game in the playoffs (which Anderson does not), I'll be ecstatic with the pick.
I think he's got a good chance of becoming a similar caliber player, he's well ahead of Anderson at the same age imo, but tbh my memory of Anderson at the same age is foggy so there's likely some recency bias going on. I liked what I saw from Ostapchuk even early in the season when the numbers weren't there, he seemed to be doing the right things but just not getting the payoff on the scoresheet. Reminds me of when people criticized Tkachuks production from his draft year but failed to recognize all the fundamentals where there to produce a lot more.
Nobody is suggesting Pageau is a bonified #1 or a #2 center, you might find those that see him as a middle six guy though because he can fill in on a second line in case of injury. That's basically what a middle six guy is, a high end third liner that can step up from time to time on the 2nd. One thing is for sure though, you'll get laughed at if you call him a 4th liner.Sure evaluation is high, but no one will say he's a 1C or 2C. They'll say he's a 3C who plays better in playoffs. That's my point, you'll be laughed at if you say JGP is a 1C or 2C.
Why do you keep saying 4th liner, Paul hasn't played 4th line at all in the last two years but has gotten significant time in the top 6. I agree in his case, he likely will not maintain middle six level performance he did with Tbay even if that's what he's been used as over the last two years, but he's pretty solidly a third liner if you ask me. People often overestimate how much production to expect from a 2nd line. If there are 192 top 6 players (6*32 teams) last year's pts per game at that cutoff is at about a 41 pts pace. Paul comes a little short while Pageau is usually right around there.Middle six might be much. He's a 3rd/4th line guy who can play up the line up is short bursts. Middle six guy to me is someone who can consistently play in either 2nd or 3rd. I don't think you'll see Paul on the second line at the start of the year at TB, nor playing there more than a handful of games.