2015 Partial Redraft - Feedback

[BinCookin]

Num.	Player	GP	G	A	Pts	Pts / GP
1	Connor McDavid	209	87	169	256	1.224880383
2	Jack Eichel	209	73	104	177	0.846889952
3	Mathew Barzal	84	22	63	85	1.011904762
4	Mitch Marner	159	41	89	130	0.817610063
5	Brock Boeser	71	33	27	60	0.845070423
6	Ivan Provorov	164	23	48	71	0.432926829
7	Zach Werenski	155	27	57	84	0.541935484
8	Noah Hanifin	239	18	65	83	0.347280335
9	Mikko Rantanen	165	49	73	122	0.739393939
10	Sebastian Aho	160	53	61	114	0.7125
11	Kyle Connor	96	33	29	62	0.645833333
12	Brandon Carlo	158	6	16	22	0.139240506
13	Jake DeBrusk	70	16	27	43	0.614285714
14	Thomas Chabot	64	9	16	25	0.390625
15	Travis Konecny	151	35	40	75	0.496688742
16	Travis Dermott	37	1	12	13	0.351351351
17	Jack Roslovic	32	5	9	14	0.4375
18	Pavel Zacha	140	16	35	51	0.364285714
19	Anthony Beauvillier	137	30	30	60	0.437956204
20	Markus Nutivaara	127	9	21	30	0.236220472
21	Timo Meier	115	24	18	42	0.365217391
22	Christian Fischer	86	18	18	36	0.418604651
23	Vince Dunn	75	5	19	24	0.32
24	Denis Malgin	98	17	15	32	0.326530612
25	Joel Eriksson Ek	90	9	14	23	0.255555556
26	Lawson Crouse	83	6	7	13	0.156626506
27	Dylan Strome	28	4	6	10	0.357142857
28	Daniel Sprong	26	4	1	5	0.192307692
29	Colin White	23	2	4	6	0.260869565
30	Noah Juulsen	23	1	2	3	0.130434783

[TBODY] [/TBODY]

Click to read more...

 

[XXIV97]

Provorov should be higher than Marner

 

[Viqsi]

Provorov and Werenski are both too low.

 

[Big Daddy Cane]

I'd bump Hanifin down a couple slots. I'd still have him as the 3rd D as I still believe in his potential, but Rantanen and Aho, maybe Connor, should go ahead of him.

Strome should drop not being an NHL regular 3 years in, but I think that's a bit too far for now.

 

[Filthy Dangles]

Hanifin is below Rantanen, Aho and Connor

Provorov is above Marner and Boeser

Konecny is above DeBrusk and Carlo

 

[Steveei]

Boeser, Hanifin are both high imo.

 

[MR4]

Put Provorov 4, Marner 5, Rantanen 6, Werenski 7, Boeser 8 IMO

 

[boredmale]

Wow given Rantanen's monster season this year I didn't think him and Aho were that close

 

[Bobby Orr's Knees]

Hanifin is not in the top-10.
Werenski is too low.
Provorov is either #3 or #4.
I would rank Rantanen higher.
Zacha doesn't go in the top 20

 

[Dominance]

Switch Werenski and Boeser and then Boeser and Rantanen. Drop Hanifin and Carlo. Strome looked good this year and should be a bit higher IMO. I think Fischer should be higher, too.

 

[BinCookin]

update

Num.	Player	GP	G	A	Pts	Pts / GP
1	Connor McDavid	209	87	169	256	1.22
2	Jack Eichel	209	73	104	177	0.85
3	Mathew Barzal	84	22	63	85	1.01
4	Ivan Provorov	164	23	48	71	0.43
5	Mitch Marner	159	41	89	130	0.82
6	Mikko Rantanen	165	49	73	122	0.74
7	Zach Werenski	155	27	57	84	0.54
8	Brock Boeser	71	33	27	60	0.85
9	Sebastian Aho	160	53	61	114	0.71
10	Kyle Connor	96	33	29	62	0.65
11	Noah Hanifin	239	18	65	83	0.35
12	Brandon Carlo	158	6	16	22	0.14
13	Travis Konecny	151	35	40	75	0.50
14	Jake DeBrusk	70	16	27	43	0.61
15	Thomas Chabot	64	9	16	25	0.39
16	Pavel Zacha	140	16	35	51	0.36
17	Anthony Beauvillier	137	30	30	60	0.44
18	Markus Nutivaara	127	9	21	30	0.24
19	Timo Meier	115	24	18	42	0.37
20	Dylan Strome	28	4	6	10	0.36
21	Travis Dermott	37	1	12	13	0.35
22	Jack Roslovic	32	5	9	14	0.44
23	Christian Fischer	86	18	18	36	0.42
24	Vince Dunn	75	5	19	24	0.32
25	Denis Malgin	98	17	15	32	0.33
26	Joel Eriksson Ek	90	9	14	23	0.26
27	Lawson Crouse	83	6	7	13	0.16
28	Daniel Sprong	26	4	1	5	0.19
29	Colin White	23	2	4	6	0.26
30	Noah Juulsen	23	1	2	3	0.13

[TBODY] [/TBODY]

 

[SFKingshomer]

I hate seeing threads like this knowing the Kings have nothing to show for it. The Lucic trade is the worst in franchise history...

 

[BinCookin]

I hate seeing threads like this knowing the Kings have nothing to show for it. The Lucic trade is the worst in franchise history...

Well you do have those stanley cups...

 

[SFKingshomer]

Well you do have those stanley cups...

before the stupid trade yes

 

[BinCookin]

which trade is the stupid trade?

 

[ChaoticOrange]

I’d honestly have Rantanen no worse than fourth here.

 

[Big Daddy Cane]

which trade is the stupid trade?

Lucic, I presume. LA has nothing to show for Jones, Miller and a pretty high 1st several years later.

 

[Tripod]

There is only 1 person I would trade Provorov for on this list, McDavid.

For Dmen in the league this year, Provorov was:

1st in ES goals
1st in overall goals
8th in ES points

So at ES, no Dman scored better, and only 7 produced more, all while Provy played against top lines. And he did this with AMac as his partner for half the year before Ghost finally replaced him.

No forward from this draft(McDavid aside) finished top 10 in goals or at ES points. Barzal was 2nd in ES assists.

Provy is a beast. And his work ethic is unmatched.

 

[CuriousGeorge]

Num.	Player	GP	G	A	Pts	Pts / GP
1	Connor McDavid	209	87	169	256	1.224880383
2	Jack Eichel	209	73	104	177	0.846889952
3	Mathew Barzal	84	22	63	85	1.011904762
4	Mitch Marner	159	41	89	130	0.817610063
5	Brock Boeser	71	33	27	60	0.845070423
6	Ivan Provorov	164	23	48	71	0.432926829
7	Zach Werenski	155	27	57	84	0.541935484
8	Noah Hanifin	239	18	65	83	0.347280335
9	Mikko Rantanen	165	49	73	122	0.739393939
10	Sebastian Aho	160	53	61	114	0.7125
11	Kyle Connor	96	33	29	62	0.645833333
12	Brandon Carlo	158	6	16	22	0.139240506
13	Jake DeBrusk	70	16	27	43	0.614285714
14	Thomas Chabot	64	9	16	25	0.390625
15	Travis Konecny	151	35	40	75	0.496688742
16	Travis Dermott	37	1	12	13	0.351351351
17	Jack Roslovic	32	5	9	14	0.4375
18	Pavel Zacha	140	16	35	51	0.364285714
19	Anthony Beauvillier	137	30	30	60	0.437956204
20	Markus Nutivaara	127	9	21	30	0.236220472
21	Timo Meier	115	24	18	42	0.365217391
22	Christian Fischer	86	18	18	36	0.418604651
23	Vince Dunn	75	5	19	24	0.32
24	Denis Malgin	98	17	15	32	0.326530612
25	Joel Eriksson Ek	90	9	14	23	0.255555556
26	Lawson Crouse	83	6	7	13	0.156626506
27	Dylan Strome	28	4	6	10	0.357142857
28	Daniel Sprong	26	4	1	5	0.192307692
29	Colin White	23	2	4	6	0.260869565
30	Noah Juulsen	23	1	2	3	0.130434783

[TBODY] [/TBODY]

Why did you not include your explanations with your post?

 

[BinCookin]

Why did you not include your explanations with your post?

Oh i figure i have made enough posts people know what im doing by now.

 

[Jacko95]

You are missing out on Anthony Cirelli, would personally put him at 25 or even a tad higher. Or ist it because of the 20 games regular season drop off?

 

[BinCookin]

You are missing out on Anthony Cirelli, would personally put him at 25 or even a tad higher. Or ist it because of the 20 games regular season drop off?

Basically ya, i didnt bother showing round 2, and Cirelli looks great, id just like more than 15-25 GP for results.

 

[HoseEmDown]

Basically ya, i didnt bother showing round 2, and Cirelli looks great, id just like more than 15-25 GP for results.

He's played 5 less games than White and has 5 more points, he's played 8 less games than Sprong and has 6 more points, he's played 65 games less than Crouse and has just 2 less points. All while being very good defensively and playing on the PK already. Not sure why it would matter if he has a few less games when he clearly looks like a better player than a few on the list?

 

[BinCookin]

fair enough, ill add him

 

[Cygnusx1018]

I think Beauvillier should be ahead of Zacha. More points in a couple less games.