It's actually highly logical. A 10% chance of winning $50 is more valuable than a 50% chance of winning $5.
I can understand if your percentages and payoffs are tweaked in such a way that makes Goulbourne more valuable, but to say it's illogical to have a guy like Kase or Vorobyov or Marody doesn't really make sense.
Except those aren't the right percentages.
Kase & Vorobyov are practically complete unknowns at this point in their development. What's the likelihood that a 4th & 5th rounder play a 100 games in the NHL? Somewhere around 10%? That's not a 10% chance of winning $50, that's a 10% chance of winning anything at all out of those picks. The actual chance of winning $50 is something like 1-2%.
Goulbourne looks at this stage to have a 50/50 shot of getting to the NHL. He has skills that are fairly easy to project. It isn't that hard to see him carve out a career as a 4th line winger who'll be physical, can skate, and might even be an effective PKer. As a result, I find it far more likely that Goulbourne plays a 100 games in the NHL than either of the other two. Given that, how can he possibly not be ranked higher than them as a prospect at this juncture?
I've been a hard-core hockey fan since 1987. From 1987 until now, the Flyers have drafted a grand total of 16 skaters in the fourth round and later that have managed to play 100+ games in the NHL. 16 guys in 28 years! Here are some of those guys: Zac Rinaldo, Todd Fedoruk, Reid Simpson, Dan Kordic, Jesse Boulerice. You may have noticed a pattern. Then you've got a bunch of guys who either flamed out of the league or who I cannot recall for the life of me: Slava Butsayev (oh, how I hated Slava), Andrei Lomakin (oh, how I loved Andrei), Chris Herperger (who?), Aris Brimanis (a decent enough #8 defenseman), Alexander Selivanov (good ole Son-in-Law-ov, never played for the Flyers), Colin Forbes (looked really good there for a year or so, then went downhill), Radovan Somik (also looked really good there for a year or so). The biggest hits they've had have been two defenseman: Seidenberg & Yushkevich. Needless to say, while I would absolutely love for the Flyers to have hit a couple of homeruns in Vorobyov & Kase, I know better than to hold my breath waiting for it to happen.
Look, I didn't like the Goulbourne pick either, but people are just plain holding that against him at this point, which is silly. He's got roughly a 50/50 shot of playing in the NHL, which is far higher than the other two. Now, if those guys go and rip up their leagues this year, and get signed to contracts, I'll be more than happy to have them jump over Goulbourne in the rankings next year. This year, I don't see the argument.