You can't have it both ways. If a good game against a fast team in November isn't enough to conclude that the Penguins can handle a fast team then a bad game against a fast team in November isn't enough to prove that they can't handle a fast team.
I'm still not making any judgements about the Penguins under Johnston until at least 40 games in. They haven't looked good this weekend but we all expected some growing pains with the new coach and system. A few here are really over-reacting.
They're not playing better systematic hockey then Pitt, Capuano didn't become Babcock over the off-season, they got a faster, younger, and more skilled roster this year, and because Pitt is older and slower, they can't beat them. The Isles can get to puck's wrapped around the boards faster then Pitt's, they can afford to pinch their D more often because all 5 players on the ice are fast and can make up to for a bad pinch by back-checking faster then Pitt's forward's can attack. That's a roster issue, and no adjustment's by the coaches will fix it.
Also the compete level or willingness make the physical harder play to beat the opponent to free pucks is clearly in the Isles favor as well, and dissapointingly apparently I have to "troll" again to point out that this particular aspect is very prominently missing from Crosby, Malkin atleast "looks" like he's trying hard, and drew their only PP by driving the net hard.
At least two top six wingers, ideally long-term options, is not a minor issue.
We need a Dupuis replacement, ideally for the long haul. We also need a long-term replacement for Kunitz, who has been spiraling the drain to WashedUpVille for a calendar year and is only getting worse. Could also use a serviceable second winger for Geno to round out the top six, allowing Bennett to play where he's been his best (and is best suited)--the third line.
Sid has one winger for the present and long-term. Geno has zero. That's a big problem.
Kunitz to the third line. If he doesn't like it, ship him out.
Clutterbuck and Martin--two guys I'd kill to have on this team. The Isles have a fantastic 4th line.
Thank god that's over.
Now back to watching horror movies for me.
Cal Clutterbuck. My new Lord and Savior. So prescient, omnipotent, awesome.
Yeah, if tenure continues to outweigh production, then desire to play hard is reduced team wide.
I'd be looking to ship him out regardless. Even if we don't get back a top six guy, it's not like Kunitz is, and it's not like that extra cap space wouldn't help.