piqued
nos merentur hoc
- Nov 22, 2006
- 32,101
- 3,145
And summer was just starting to drag, right?
A couple of things before we get voting:
The last few years we experimented with a format where we'd wait a topic before voting and then subsequently used each following poll to discuss the next spot in the order. I think it actually worked pretty well but I'm trying to simplify a bit here and make it a little more accessible to new users. The main thing is to feel free to look ahead and debate the merits of any prospect at any time. There's value to hashing out the upcoming argument before everyone votes.
Nemeth is a prospect. He's played 13 NHL games. Keep that in mind when sorting your list.
It's going to stay a 20 player max list. We could absolutely go to 30 ordering legit prospects, that's how much deeper and better the Stars' system is compared to when we started these. I like forcing people to make tough decisions though. Appearing at all in the ranked prospects should mean something.
Quick rundown of the top 5 of years past:
2013
|
|
|
|
|
|
2012
|
|
|
|
|
|
2011
|
|
|
|
|
|
2010
|
|
|
|
|
|
Grip it and rip it, folks.
A couple of things before we get voting:
The last few years we experimented with a format where we'd wait a topic before voting and then subsequently used each following poll to discuss the next spot in the order. I think it actually worked pretty well but I'm trying to simplify a bit here and make it a little more accessible to new users. The main thing is to feel free to look ahead and debate the merits of any prospect at any time. There's value to hashing out the upcoming argument before everyone votes.
Nemeth is a prospect. He's played 13 NHL games. Keep that in mind when sorting your list.
It's going to stay a 20 player max list. We could absolutely go to 30 ordering legit prospects, that's how much deeper and better the Stars' system is compared to when we started these. I like forcing people to make tough decisions though. Appearing at all in the ranked prospects should mean something.
Quick rundown of the top 5 of years past:
2013
prospect
|
pos.
|
country
|
acquired
|
round
|
change
|
% of vote
1
|
Valeri Nichushkin
|
RW
|
2013
|
1st
|
new
|
90.2
2
|
Jamie Oleksiak
|
D
|
2011
|
1st
|
► 0
|
50.0
3
|
Alex Chiasson
|
RW
|
2009
|
2nd
|
► 0
|
50.7
4
|
Jack Campbell
|
G
|
2010
|
1st
|
▼ 3
|
50.1
5
|
Brett Ritchie
|
RW
|
2011
|
2nd
|
▲ 7
|
85.9
2012
prospect
|
pos.
|
country
|
acquired
|
round
|
change
|
% of vote
1
|
Jack Campbell
|
G
|
2010
|
1st
|
► 0
|
37.7
2
|
Jamie Oleksiak
|
D
|
2011
|
1st
|
▲ 2
|
48.0
3
|
Alex Chiasson
|
RW
|
2009
|
2nd
|
▲ 2
|
57.1
4
|
Radek Faksa
|
C
|
2012
|
1st
|
new
|
73.5
5
|
Brenden Dillon
|
D
|
2011
|
FA
|
▲ 7
|
43.9
2011
prospect
|
pos.
|
country
|
acquired
|
round
|
change
|
% of vote
1
|
Jack Campbell
|
G
|
2010
|
1st
|
► 0
|
48.7
2
|
Philip Larsen
|
D
|
2008
|
5th
|
► 0
|
44.4
3
|
Scott Glennie
|
RW
|
2009
|
1st
|
► 0
|
50.0
4
|
Jamie Oleksiak
|
D
|
2011
|
1st
|
new
|
45.0
5
|
Alex Chiasson
|
RW
|
2009
|
2nd
|
▼ 1
|
71.4
2010
prospect
|
pos.
|
country
|
acquired
|
round
|
change
|
% of vote
1
|
Jack Campbell
|
G
|
2010
|
1st
|
new
|
-
2
|
Philip Larsen
|
D
|
2008
|
5th
|
▲ 2
|
-
3
|
Scott Glennie
|
RW
|
2009
|
1st
|
► 0
|
-
4
|
Alex Chiasson
|
RW
|
2009
|
2nd
|
▲ 4
|
-
5
|
Tomas Vincour
|
RW
|
2009
|
5th
|
▲ 12
|
-
Grip it and rip it, folks.
Last edited: