Youngest Cup winner that never won another one

[pnep]

Seguin is the youngest.

Larry Hillman and Gaye Stewart were both 18 when they won the Cup but they both went on to win it again over the course of their careers. Seguin is third youngest to win it.

Ross Johnstone

Lloyd Klein

 

[sr edler]

Kovalev was 21 with the Rangers in 1994, and played a vital role in that playoffs, then played until he was 40 without any more Cups.

I believe Marty Gelinas was 19/20 when he won it. Came close a few more times with Calgary and Carolina(?) though.

Gelinas was much closer to win another Cup with Vancouver in 1994 than he was with Carolina in 2002.

 

[Zuluss]

Since nobody has mentioned Mikita and Bobby Hull yet, I will.
Mikita was 20, Bobby Hull was 22.
They had better playoff runs since then in terms of individual stats, but no more Cups for either one.

 

[iamjs]

That's a good trivia question. Recchi is close behind at 15 years (1991 to 2006) - though only 14 seasons.

Chelios - 16 years
Recchi - 15 years
Guerin - 14 years

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Guerin