Rosters and Ratings: Xbox1 users please upload ratings!

[Jack de la Hoya]

At least EA is not to blame for that.

I'm not up to date on the rules, I guess. I would have thought that, since Gostisbehere played in the AHL last year, he'd be included this year.

 

[DB0SS]

Ok EA messed up BIG TIME.

DeKeyser is a 81 OVR with top 6 potential.
Kindl is a freakin 83 top 4 D.
CLEARY IS AN 81 SAME OVR AS DEKEYSER. BUT GUESS WHAT. CLEARY IS LISTED AS A TOP 6 FORWARD.
Quincey is an 84. SAME AS ERICSSON.
Does EA even watch hockey.....?

Now to the prospects.

Sproul is A RED POTENTIAL TOP 6 D. WTF.
Ouellet is a Med potential Top 4 D. Thats debatable.
Mantha has 1 star defense? Ok EA....
Jake Paterson and Thomas McCollum (rated 71 and 72 OVR) are listed as NHL Starters.

 

[ChibiPooky]

At least they didn't rate the Caps defense better than the Kings.

Oh.

 

[ThatNavyGuy]

Looks like 90% of the NHL is full of players rated 80 and above.

Another half assed job on the rosters by EA Sports.

the best part is (at the current moment) you can't edit players GO EA

 

[Cyborg Yzerberg]

the best part is (at the current moment) you can't edit players GO EA

 

[tsujimoto74]

Someone uploaded the ratings on YT.

Thanks for posting the vid!

But man does EA suck at ratings.
My favorite from the Sabres is how they gave Mark Pysyk a better shot than Rasmus Ristolainen. Risto outclasses Pysyk in every aspect of the offensive game (other than maybe breakout passing) and the difference is most drastic in their shooting ability. I also like how Matt Hackett, who sucked all last year in the AHL and hasn't done anything noteworthy in a while, now has a higher overall than in last year's game and still has way better potential than goalies who've actually progressed/done impressive things irl, like Ullmark. Also digging how Deslauriers is still a d-man in the game despite being a forward all last season, both in the AHL for Manchester/LA and when he came to Buffalo. Good job EA.

 

[Jetabre]

Ondrej Pavelec is an 85 overall goalie....Something is wrong there.

 

[Jetabre]

the best part is (at the current moment) you can't edit players GO EA

Wow, I was all ready to go and buy this, but they don't even give the option to edit their "mistake" ratings and potentials? I'm starting to have to reconsider..

 

[Paradoc]

rating:

Kessel 90
Bozak 87
JVR 87
Lupul 86
Kadri 85
Clarkson 85
Phaneuf 85
Santorelli 84
Gardiner 83
Franson 83
Polak 82
Booth 82
Winnik 81
Robidas 81
Frattin 80
Rielly 79 (Elite)
Holland 79 (top 6)
Ashton 79
Komarov 78
Nylander 68 (Bottom 6)

Bernier 86
Reimer 85

rating:

Subban 90
Pacioretty 88
Markov 86
Plekanec 85
Parenteau 85
Galchenyuk 84 (Elite)
Eller 84
Gallagher 84
Desharnais 83
Emelin 83
Borque 83
Gilbert 82
Prust 82
Tinordi 81 (top 4)
Bournival 80
Weise 80
Weaver 80
Moen 80
Malhotra 79
Beaulieu 76 (top 4)

Price 92
Tokarski 81

rating:

Karlsson 89
Ryan 89
Turris 89 (Elite)
Michalek 85
MacArthur 85
Legwand 85
Zibanejad 84 (top 6)
Cowen 84 (top 4)
Wiercioch 83
Smith 83
Methot 83
Ceci 82 (Elite)
Phillips 82
Greening 82
Neil 82
Chiasson 81
Condra 81
Stone 79
Gryba 78

Anderson 88
Lehner 84


Note:
- Clarkson, Bozak, Lupul, Reimer and Santorelli are too high
- Gardiner, Phaneuf are too low
- Plekanec, Parenteau, Markov, and Eller are too high
- Desharnais is too low.
- Ryan, Turris, Legwand, Zibanejad, Cowen, Anderson and Michalek is too high.
- Methot and Karlsson are too low.

 

[Jetabre]

Turris is an 89, Bozak is an 87 and Bryan Little is only an 85. What on Earth.

 

[Super Cake]

Who cares about overalls? They literally mean nothing.

 

[Ziggy Stardust]

Fourth line players are now in the low 80s and healthy scratches are in the high 70s.

Quite unlike how ratings separated players like they used to, like this classic game for instance:
http://nhl94.com/html/teamprofile.php?team=PIT

 

[Nithoniniel]

I checked through the rosters a bit. Found the following gem.

Best prospect I've found might just be a Buffalo player. Reinhart? No no. Johan Larsson. It's apparently highly likely that he becomes an elite center.

 

[Swedishpredator]

rating:

Kessel 90
Bozak 87
JVR 87
Lupul 86
Kadri 85
Clarkson 85
Phaneuf 85
Santorelli 84
Gardiner 83
Franson 83
Polak 82
Booth 82
Winnik 81
Robidas 81
Frattin 80
Rielly 79 (Elite)
Holland 79 (top 6)
Ashton 79
Komarov 78
Nylander 68 (Bottom 6)

Bernier 86
Reimer 85

rating:

Subban 90
Pacioretty 88
Markov 86
Plekanec 85
Parenteau 85
Galchenyuk 84 (Elite)
Eller 84
Gallagher 84
Desharnais 83
Emelin 83
Borque 83
Gilbert 82
Prust 82
Tinordi 81 (top 4)
Bournival 80
Weise 80
Weaver 80
Moen 80
Malhotra 79
Beaulieu 76 (top 4)

Price 92
Tokarski 81

rating:

Karlsson 89
Ryan 89
Turris 89 (Elite)
Michalek 85
MacArthur 85
Legwand 85
Zibanejad 84 (top 6)
Cowen 84 (top 4)
Wiercioch 83
Smith 83
Methot 83
Ceci 82 (Elite)
Phillips 82
Greening 82
Neil 82
Chiasson 81
Condra 81
Stone 79
Gryba 78

Anderson 88
Lehner 84


Note:
- Clarkson, Bozak, Lupul, Reimer and Santorelli are too high
- Gardiner, Phaneuf are too low
- Plekanec, Parenteau, Markov, and Eller are too high
- Desharnais is too low.
- Ryan, Turris, Legwand, Zibanejad, Cowen, Anderson and Michalek is too high.
- Methot and Karlsson are too low.

Wrong...check https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qXKShV50HPg that is the roster via menu...not for be a GM...i dont know but might be some diffrences in rating within modes :S oh and btw turris is 87. and i find that still to high

 

[Mikeaveli]

Eric Brewer is rated the same as Anton Stralman. Congrats, EA, you've done it again.

 

[The Hockey Tonk Man]

Fourth line players are now in the low 80s and healthy scratches are in the high 70s.

Quite unlike how ratings separated players like they used to, like this classic game for instance:
http://nhl94.com/html/teamprofile.php?team=PIT

ahh memories.
It makes me laugh that some goalie named John Blue on the Bruins is rated higher than Andy Moog who was on the freakin cover.

 

[FLYguy3911]

I'm not up to date on the rules, I guess. I would have thought that, since Gostisbehere played in the AHL last year, he'd be included this year.

He played on an ATO. That doesn't count. He would still have to sign a waiver assuming he doesn't open the season in the NHL to be in this year's game.

As far as the overalls and potentials, the past couple years EA has released an update that corrected a lot of obvious mistakes. I know 13 had a release day update, forget what they did for 14.

If we can't edit players, EA better be on their game and not think 1 update a month is sufficient. As an online player, I've always been at the mercy of their ratings.

 

[Hansen]

Organization Skaters (cut it down a bit):

D. Sedin - 88
H. Sedin - 87
D. Hamhuis - 88
N. Bonino - 85
C. Higgins - 85
A. Edler - 85
K. Bieksa - 85
R. Vrbata - 85
Z. Kassian - 84
A. Burrows - 84
L. Sbisa - 83 (Med Elite potential rofl)
S. Matthias - 83
B. Richardson - 83
C. Tanev - 82 (Med Top 6 D potential)
J. Hansen - 81
R. Stanton - 80 (High Top 4 D potential)
D. Dorsett - 80
N. Jensen - 79 (Med Top 6 potential, also of note, he has finally been listed at his actual size: 6'3 202lbs)
L. Vey - 79 (Med Bottom 6 potential)
F. Corrado - 78 (Med Top 4 D potential)
Y. Weber - 78
T. Sestito - 77
B. Horvat - 76 (Med Top 6 potential)
M. Zalewski - 75 (High Bottom 6 potential)
H. Shinkaruk - 74 (Med Top 6 potential)
K. Lain - 73 (Low Top 6 AHL potential)
B. Sweatt - 72 (Havent we lost his rights already)
B. Gaunce - 71 (Med Top 9 potential)
J. McCann - 70 (Med Top 9 potential)
J. Virtanen - 70 (Med Top 6 potential)

Organization Goalies:

R. Miller - 89
E. Lack - 84 (Med NHL Starter potential)
J. Markstrom - 82 (Med NHL Starter potential)
J. Eriksson - 75 (Med NHL Starter potential)
J. Cannata - 68 (Med NHL Backup potential)

 

[Bubba88]

would want to know how European leagues are rated...

 

[Jack de la Hoya]

When someone gets the chance, can you check these ratings (drawn from Xbone) against the old-gen consoles? We've been assuming that the ratings will be the same, but I'm not sure.

Thanks.

 

[FLYguy3911]

When someone gets the chance, can you check these ratings (drawn from Xbone) against the old-gen consoles? We've been assuming that the ratings will be the same, but I'm not sure.

Thanks.

The categories are the same I know that. Whether or not the formula for overall changed I'm not sure. I would say it hasn't, but I don't know for sure.

 

[Swic21]

Lmao, Del Zotto an 85?????? I mean I'm happy but... Wow lol.

 

[Crymson]

Apparently Mantha has lost two inches and 20 pounds since I last looked. I'd launch a snark comment at EA here, but I've come to expect this sort of garbage from them. Needless to say, there are loads of other errors in the Red Wings roster alone. The one that really cracked me up was Dan Cleary as an 82 with a top-six tag. Cleary was the worst player on the team last season.

 

[kassian]

Ovechkin rated 85 defensively

 

[ThatNavyGuy]

Man no Hagg.....Prospects for the Flyers are pretty good though