Proposal: Would you trade Tavares for Karlsson ?

[scott99]

Just wondering, with both superstars possibly leaving their teams, would you do a straight up trade ?

Click to read more...

 

[Top Corner]

But why would Ottawa do that

 

[Islesfan22]

No as it would not make a difference in my opinion.

 

[PK Cronin]

So we get to do this whole thing again next year? No thanks.

 

[MJF]

Is Karlsson’s rebuilt foot okay?

 

[beach]

I would if it was a sign and trade for Karlsson's contract.

 

[sabremike]

Why the hell was this posted? You might as well do a post as to who would win a fight between a unicorn and the Easter Bunny. This trade has less than zero chance of happening because who in their right mind thinks cheap f*** Melynik would in a million years bring in a guy he'd have to give North of $10 million a year to? It's just a ridiculous fantasy trade at its worst.

 

[CREW99AW]

No. Karlsson and his rebuilt ankle,his foot with the transplanted tendon, will not leave a dime on the table and I am leery of whether the post surgery Karlsson ever becomes as dominate as pre-surgery Karlsson.

 

[ndgolden]

WTF is going on in Vegas that they are getting it done night after night with NO superstars let alone being a cap floor team????

 

[PK Cronin]

WTF is going on in Vegas that they are getting it done night after night with NO superstars let alone being a cap floor team????

Players who are motivated, a good coaching scheme, and no real weaknesses on the roster because there is only so bad a player can be when they were hand picked by management off of other teams?

 

[scott99]

Why the hell was this posted? You might as well do a post as to who would win a fight between a unicorn and the Easter Bunny. This trade has less than zero chance of happening because who in their right mind thinks cheap **** Melynik would in a million years bring in a guy he'd have to give North of $10 million a year to? It's just a ridiculous fantasy trade at its worst.

Obviously the Easter Bunny would win, duh !

 

[Bones45]

Why the hell was this posted? You might as well do a post as to who would win a fight between a unicorn and the Easter Bunny. This trade has less than zero chance of happening because who in their right mind thinks cheap **** Melynik would in a million years bring in a guy he'd have to give North of $10 million a year to? It's just a ridiculous fantasy trade at its worst.

Wtf. Just a hypothetical question. No reason to respond like the guy kicked your dog.

 

[Bones45]

Players who are motivated, a good coaching scheme, and no real weaknesses on the roster because there is only so bad a player can be when they were hand picked by management off of other teams?

The fact that LV is as good as they are is an embarrassment to the league...especially coaches. Throw together a bunch of guys who were intentionally unprotected...castaways....and then throw all of them togetber. Presto..proper coaching and they one of the best teams in the league.

Every GM and coach should be taking notes as they all suck.

 

[PK Cronin]

The fact that LV is as good as they are is an embarrassment to the league...especially coaches. Throw together a bunch of guys who were intentionally unprotected...castaways....and then throw all of them togetber. Presto..proper coaching and they one of the best teams in the league.

Every GM and coach should be taking notes as they all suck.

It's certainly interested, but we'll see if it is sustainable. It's possible they are playing well because of the chip on their shoulder and the coaching. Time will tell.

 

[redbull]

Why the hell was this posted? You might as well do a post as to who would win a fight between a unicorn and the Easter Bunny. This trade has less than zero chance of happening because who in their right mind thinks cheap **** Melynik would in a million years bring in a guy he'd have to give North of $10 million a year to? It's just a ridiculous fantasy trade at its worst.

Easter Bunny - dirty fighter

 

[SLAPSHOT723]

I don't think we really need Karlsson. We need defensive guys a lot more than we need a guy who will help us score. We already score a shit ton.

 

[PK Cronin]

I don't think we really need Karlsson. We need defensive guys a lot more than we need a guy who will help us score. We already score a **** ton.

Guys like Karlsson have the puck more than they don't, so that prevents the other team from scoring on your team.

 

[SLAPSHOT723]

Guys like Karlsson have the puck more than they don't, so that prevents the other team from scoring on your team.

I don't disagree, but I think we need a guy like Doughty (not exactly him) more than a Karlsson. That's all.

 

[buud]

I don't disagree, but I think we need a guy like Doughty (not exactly him) more than a Karlsson. That's all.

i have been screaming for defensive D for some time, but Karlsson is a beast (if healthy). some say that a best defence is a good offence...

 

[PK Cronin]

I don't disagree, but I think we need a guy like Doughty (not exactly him) more than a Karlsson. That's all.

I love Doughty and would take him over Karlsson.

 

[SLAPSHOT723]

I love Doughty and would take him over Karlsson.

Exactly. I'm not taking anything away from Karlsson. He's a f***ing stud. But there are certain types of players we need, and he's not that guy.

But, even in just general defensemen rankings, I take Doughty and Hedman over Karlsson fairly easily. Although I think Karlsson is the clear cut #3. Subban and the like are definitely behind him.