I think that is still just too easy unless every line he has been on relies too heavily on him. I don't think it is valid to separate his performance that much from his linemates. When the whole line dies he starts trying to compensate and just gets worse. But the fault is on the whole line.
He is our most skilled player and I don't think he has any lack of heart or guts. He has shown plenty of both over his career.
He is a creative player who rubs coaches the wrong way. He is somewhat difficult to play with because of the unpredictability of his game. But that same unpredictability is a great strength. It should be on his coaches to find ways to take advantage of that strength instead of trying to coach it out of him.
That said, I have accepted the need to move on from him but only because I think he will have had enough of this org. If he won't extend, he needs to be moved.
I think we will be just as much in 'win now' mode next year as we were this year. So the return has to be now players. Futures just won't cut it.
No, he's very easy to game plan against for a best of 7 scenario. He can get away with whatever he's doing in the regular season, but he becomes extremely predictable to shut down (with his line) once the playoffs start. It's easy to let him go off-script, dance around, while you're really getting him to do what you him to do. Burn gas. We have a 37 game sample size of this. Let's the roll the dice again? We're due?
Teams do their homework, and I'm certain the word on Ehlers has been out there for quite some time. This fan base seems to be the last to have figured that out.
Vladimir Guerrero had a cannon of an arm. But his throwing was erratic (to say the least). So, his arm in right didn't matter, and he was better suited as a DH.
Ehlers is more talented than he is skilled. If you can't put your skill set to better use within the concept of "team", then it's no different than Guerrero's erratic arm.
He's more speedy than he is fast. I've never really seen him blow past a defender in all of my years watching him. I see him wind up, carry the puck with very good speed, but where is he going with his speed? It's rarely in tighter spaces. He's not a guy who explodes from the jump, separating himself from a pack, going from 0-to-60.
How is he creative? His shot selection, often works against his own team. He kills too many plays, spraying shots from bad angles, where it often ends up directly in the goalie's chest. I get the concept to shoot whenever you can, get as many shots on net as possible, fine, but there's the flip side, that you're keeping the other goalie engaged; with poor shot selection. Add to this, and this is important, how many times when it's clear to everyone watching that he absolutely needs to take the shot, and then decides to pass it?
And his passing can be as erratic as his shot selection.
It says a lot about a players heart when he's doing a line change (Game 4) with 20 seconds left, with the puck being carried in the wrong direction, heading towards an empty net.