I voted for Datsyuk, but meant to vote for Fedorov. Fedorov has an impressive career, and benefits from having played longer than Datsyuk will be able to play. Datsyuk has been fairly consistent in the post lockout era, but the fact remains that Fedorov's peak is among the best of any player to play for this team. I thought Datsyuk's consistency may give him some points, but injuries and lockouts have robbed us a bit, and the fact is, Fedorov put up a good string of seasons in the 90's and even his decline I think can be overstated. Fedorov was over a PPG in his first season in Columbus. I like Datsyuk more than I like Fedorov, and I do love Fedorov, but he's definitely the better player. It sort of underscores how dominant those 90's teams were.