Epsilon said:
Good lord. I wonder how long it is going to take until someone predicts Crosby will break Selanne's records at age 18...
OK Epsilon and Vlad. But you should know that before this season started I predicted that Crosby would win the Q scoring title, be its MVP and make the Canada WJC team. And I got a lot of similar scoffs at that time.
Sidebar-
Actually, I think that hype is usually GOOD! Countries that do well at the Olympics etc. usually tell their top athletes "We expect you to win!". I think in hockey too often we say "Don't make him out to be the next Gretzky, let's let him be the first Joe Shmoe". Then Joe Shmoe is considered a top 15 pick for the draft and people say "I think his upside is third-liner with 40 points".
It's a recipe for mediocrity!! Young athletes SHOULD be thinking that they could become the next superstar. You can bet that Sid Crosby is! Imagine a kid at a good high-school getting 95% in academic courses and teachers telling him "Ah- it'll be fine if you just enter any 4 year university, get your degree, go out and work". Nah- you"re selling that kid short! He SHOULD be thinking PhD at Harvard...
Hype makes people work hard and dream big! Underhyping makes excuses for failure and mediocrity.
Of course there is a caveat for all this. Average athletes (or whatever) should not be hyped, and young kids should not be hyped. But for those who want to and have the natural skills to excel? Sure!
As for the inevitable Dan Cleary, Jason Bonsignore comparisons. The hype surrounding these players itself is hype. On these boards I see comments like "In Bonsignore's draft year everybody said he'd be the next Mario Lemieux". Well, I've been active in the draft scene for awhile and I can tell you people never said things like that. If you research it you'll find things said like "His style reminds of Mario Lemieux". Same with Cleary. No way was he expected to be a 1st overall- the closest quote I can remember was when he was a year before the draft and a scout in THN was quoted as saying "He looks like a solid top 10 pick at this point".
But suddenly in retrospect- and as a warning to all who (want to) predict greatness for Crosby- many people on this board decide that players like Bonsignore and Clearly were equally hyped. They weren't. Nor were they ever regarded as being as talented as Crosby.