ok so i voted Montreal and there are 2 reasons for that.
1. i think our rivalry with Toronto is dead
2. i think our Rivalry with Montreal is at an all time high.
now before i go any further i will say i started watching hockey after the 05 Lockout. i also did not start paying attention to our(or anyone's) drafting till the 2011 draft. joined this forum(first i have joined/looked at apart from nhl.com comment section[started that in 2013 season]) a little over a year ago. i say all this to make it clear i was not watching hockey when we where playing Toronto in the playoffs regularly nor was i involved in the fans vs fans "hating" while Toronto was relivant
now the reason why i think the Toronto Rivalry is dead is because i personally(and i am sure others agree) don't hate/dislike any player on Toronto atm. i don't go into the season hoping a Toronto player has a bad year. i don't go into a game wanted their star to screw up so i can tell their fans about it. if it happens ok good but i am not hoping for it. at this point i don't view Toronto in a negative way.
i fully came to realize this as i was watching the draft lottery and for some odd reason wanted them to win. i think that is because i want them to get good so we can restart the rivalry BUT it also to me made me realize that somehow they have become a team i root for(to get better) rather then a team i hope does "bad".
Montreal on the other hand i hate. their fans are the least likable fans in the league, their players are divers and dirty, Subban is nothing compared to Kalrsson, and price is overrated, etc. most of that is wrong i know that BUT if a Habs fan is in front of me i would tell them it without hesitation and back up my claims with whatever bs i could come up with simply because i dont like them.
when i look at what makes a rivalry i think of 3 things
1. the players dislike each other
2. the fans dislike each other
3. the games are close, hard, dirty sometimes, and most importantly entertaining.
with Montreal i think we have all 3 things. with Toronto we simply don't. the players don't dislike each other, the games are "meaningless", and i don't think many fans really dislike each other all that much(although you may pretend to)
well that is my opinion and my points as to why i think Montreal is our biggest rival. i am interested in see the voting and would love for someone to break down why they think Toronto is our biggest rival